clbgolden
Swampert Fan
- 639
- Posts
- 10
- Years
- Seen Sep 22, 2019
You make a good point with Colosseum/XD thing, but I still don't see how the anime could carry on without badges. What would be the goal of Ash's adventure? Just walking around Alola doing stuff? With the gyms you at least have a point of Ash's journey, but without them I just can't see how they could make it work.You're dismissing arguments out of hand for really arbitrary reasons, as well as utilizing appeals to tradition.
"It's only a season and not an entire series" - so what? I don't understand how you think a team of salaried, professional writers experienced in churning out hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of episodes with unique elements for nearly 20 years is incapable of going on with the anime simply because there are no gyms in the games. In fact, I think the anime might be more interesting if it were changed from "spend 20 filler episodes to get from gym A to gym B" because the vast majority of the anime episodes are already not about the gyms or gym leaders.
Not to mention, I would argue that a very small fraction of the game playing audience actually regularly follows the anime, and it would deeply upset a lot of people to discard new and interesting game mechanics simply because of the anime.
"Colosseum/XD are spinoffs" - again, so what? They are relevant to this discussion because unlike the vast majority of other spinoffs, they are mutually compatible with main series games and the core gameplay is an RPG in a similar vein to the main series games, minus Pokemon acquisition and the gyms. They still managed to make an incredibly unique and compelling game that in my opinion should have some elements carried over to the main series games.
My main point is that everything will be fine if there aren't gyms. We not only have small precedents but you are doing a ton of game developers and professional anime screenwriters a disservice by assuming they can't do their jobs. The series keeps evolving, in fact many less hardcore fans have complained that the 8 gym-E4-champion format has gotten stale, and I wouldn't disagree with them as the past couple of generations have been fairly linear and with decreasing difficulty. So for those reasons, I strongly support the idea of more freeform gameplay and "well they haven't done it before" is a rather poor excuse imho.
You are entitled to your opinion - if you love the gyms, great! Different strokes for different folks. But I strongly disagree with your reasonings for it.
Also, I still don't see how I "ignored" the points. I may have used not so good counters, but I still addressed them.