Map Rating/Review Thread

[Blazichu]

Map Name: Route 1001
Map Game: Fire Red

Comments: Its my first attempt at route hacking and i want you all to tear it apart.the first house is the home of a gardener. And the second place is the future home of a family. Sorta under construction thing. Well, I fixed it up a bit and work on it here is the map.

Good to see an original map, alot of grass and flowers. Also there were some minor mapping errors around the water and rock tiles, otherwise fine.

I'll give this a 5/10

 

[Binary]

Hey nice map lasthland
(i wont be harsh)
8/10
i thin its real good.
Well heres my map:

Name: route1
Game:Ruby

 

[palkey1]

Hey nice map lasthland
(i wont be harsh)
8/10
i thin its real good.
Well heres my map:

Name: route1
Game:Ruby

well its good a lot of room but very good

how about mine

route 101

 

[thethethethe]

well its good a lot of room but very good

how about mine

route 101

celebi XD, I give that about a 6/10 it feels too empty, and there are a few errors. Sorry palkey1, but I gave yours 4/10. It's full of errors.

 

[palkey1]

celebi XD, I give that about a 6/10 it feels too empty, and there are a few errors. Sorry palkey1, but I gave yours 4/10. It's full of errors.

well it is my first attempt so i stil;l need to get the hang of it

 

[Zanacross]

This map has loads of errors (ive marked them all with a red square)

This is a map that has just had more grass added, the stairs look flat and its just not nice to look at 1/10
(i am going to feel guilty for this rateing but i had to save you)

To improve it start it again

Edit: That is what my maps started out like.

This is my map
Map off ruby

 

[palkey1]

This map has loads of errors (ive marked them all with a red square)

This is a map that has just had more grass added, the stairs look flat and its just not nice to look at 1/10
(i am going to feel guilty for this rateing but i had to save you)

To improve it start it again

Edit: That is what my maps started out like.

This is my map
Map off ruby

lol thats a lot of errors but not even all of them

 

[thethethethe]

This map has loads of errors (ive marked them all with a red square)

This is a map that has just had more grass added, the stairs look flat and its just not nice to look at 1/10
(i am going to feel guilty for this rateing but i had to save you)

To improve it start it again

Edit: That is what my maps started out like.

This is my map
Map off ruby

You still missed some of the mistakes in palkey1's map. Doesn't matter. I give your map a 6/10 because those stairs are annoying me.

 

[Zanacross]

I did change the stairs but it didnt save.

This is another map

I think i uploaded it befor but no one rated it.

palke i know i didnt get all the errors. on your map.

 

[destinedjagold]

7/10
the map looks nice and all...

 

[suoert]

here are some images of my personal hack, i'm trying to recreate johto and kanto, it's not a remake it's a totally diferent story.

i hope you guys like them and please tell me if there is anything i can do to make them better.

 

[destinedjagold]

well... I kinda miss Johto a lot now...

I like your maps. ;)

Spoiler:

1st - 7/10 :)
2nd - 8/10 :D
3rd - 7/10 :)
4th - 7/10 ;)
5th - 7/10 :)

I see no tile errors. I sense that you've really spent a lot of time with those maps.
I like your effort and determination. You deserve those ratings! :)

Best of luck! ^^

 

[Alistair]

Map Name: Route D

Game: Pokémon FireRed Version

Notes: The waterfalls are supposed to be mapped like that, and the small error on top of the moutain canot be fixed, as I have no room left in the tileset to make one that is correct.

 

[Zanacross]

10/10 i love you tiles they are brilliant.

Waterfalls look mint and the trees are so good i love them.

 

[destinedjagold]

lovely... 9/10.

keep it up... it's very good. ^^

 

[coin3]

These are the starting maps for my hack. They changed to jpg for some reason....stupid photobucket.

I still need to do some editing. What do you suggest?

 

[thethethethe]

Hey that's two map's. Just noticed. About 5/10 for the first and 4/10 for the secong. There are lots of errors in the second one. They're just too empty. I've put what you need to fix below.

 

[Blazichu]

coin3 I would give those maps a 2/10, try to fix up the errors and the large amount of space you have. Constructive Criticism never hurts anyone.

Good luck with mapping in the future :)

 

[Lady Berlitz]

You're right... oh well, it looks like you're a starter, Coin3.

 

[BlackRainbow*]

This is the starting town of my upcomming hack:
Azio Town

Comments plz.