Map Rating/Review Thread

[TB Pro]

Oh thanks guys...
I noticed the sandy tiles at the top of the Mountain and I fixed them!
Also I did not notice the fence tiles...Thanks for pointiong them out!
@Thethethethe are you saying that I need to add grass patches that cannot be missed?
or are you saying that you can just go through the grass at the entrance with the fence above it to the patch of grass at the end with the Mountain?
If you are,did you notice the ledge at the end?
well that is for a quick way to get back from the end of the map.
So, because of the ledge and the trees you cannot just bypass the detour!
Also do you think that i should put less flowers in?
But,thanks for the warm welcome and help!
I look up to you all!
I hope to become as good at hacking as you guys!

____________________________________________________EDIT__________________________________________________
Here's another version of the map!

Spoiler:

 

[destinedjagold]

I do think thethethethe meant was the maze was useless if the player can just simply go through this route...

Spoiler:

But anyways...

RATING= 8.6/10

REASON= It's even more lovelier than the last map. Great job. ;)

SUGGESTION= Still lessen the flower tiles. :D

 

[Lady Berlitz]

I agree. Unless you can put some sort of 'prize' if you go through the maze route. An item or a rare Pokémon?

 

[TB Pro]

Spoiler:

Ok the arrows at the entrance are saying that it is both the entrance and exit of the route.
The circle is where you battle your rival.
the arrow curving to the ledge is saying that you cannot go cheat through it!
The X is saying that you cannot go to a new map through there.
Hope that cleared thing up for ya!

 

[PlatinumDawnFtw]

Map Name: Electra Town

Map Game: FireRed

Comments: This is the starter town for my new hack, Pokemon: Legend of Thunder. The formation at the bottom left hand corner is a shrine to Raikou, and will play a major role in the games storyline, nothing else is really too special about the map.

P.S: Don't worry about the border block, I've got it covered. ;-)
P.S.S: Credit to PHO for the ROM base and Saurav for the tree tiles.

Mapshot:

Spoiler:

 

[destinedjagold]

to PokéHackerOmega..,
REASON= nothing else to say but lovely. I love the new grass tiles there...
RATING= 8/10

to Crashink..,
REASON= lovely trees. lovely grass and what a lovely map. But the only thing that disturbs me is that circle patch of water on the grass. :/
RATING= 6.7/10

Spoiler:

I have nothing to suggest... :D

 

[PlatinumDawnFtw]

Map Name: Route 501

Map Game: FireRed

Comments: The first route in my hack. Nothing really too special. No new events will occur on this route.

Mapshot:

Spoiler:

Credit to PHO for the Rom Base and Saurav for the tree tiles.

 

[Corrosion]

Map Name: Route 501

Map Game: FireRed

Comments: The first route in my hack. Nothing really too special. No new events will occur on this route.

Mapshot:

Spoiler:

Credit to PHO for the Rom Base and Saurav for the tree tiles.

6/10.

The map itself is quite aesthetically pleasing, but there are a few flaws. To kick off, there is FAR too much grass. You should break this up, and allow shorter routes through the grass if the player does not wish to bump into many pokemon. Secondly, the map is far too contricting- The player should be allowed to take his own route, whereas here in certain areas the player has to stick to a predetermined path. Third, though this is a mere preference there is not, unlike the official games you have not given a direct link without grass to the starter town. Lastly there is an area you cannot reach near the top left. I would change those things to improve the map.

Map Name: Jigoku (Town)

Game: Pokemon Emerald

Comments: Though not entirely finished this is a map of the second town, Jigoku. I need to add new sprites for the houses, which will probably be in the style of Japanese A-Frame houses. There are no real exceptional features, apart from the house of Mr. Tullus who will play a part in the storyline, a cafe leading to a Shrine to an unspecified (at the moment) pokemon and an additional shop to the Mart.

Mapshot:

 

[+Sneasel™]

Map name: Lucky town

Game: Fire red

Comments: Did this one over Viridian city and the cave will lead to the gym.

Credit goes to don for the palette

 

[destinedjagold]

to Corrosion..,
RATING= 6/10
REASON= A very wonderful and big map. However, some mountain tile error there. It disturbs my eyes @_@...

to itman1234..,
RATING= 8/10
REASON= I love the pallete and the map. ALthough it's a bit empty and a bit weird that the player should go throught the cave just to reach the GYM.., but hey.., that's a player's challenge! ;)

 

[+Sneasel™]

Here's another map I made

Map name: Route 209

Comments: Celebi's shrine is in the bottom left. Person in house gives you an item.

 

[destinedjagold]

REASON= Heh.., what can I say..? It's beautiful ever! Lovely stone formation!

RATING= 9/10 ;)

SUGGESTION= -Nothing to suggest- :D

 

[Binary]

Here's another map I made

Map name: Route 209

Comments: Celebi's shrine is in the bottom left. Person in house gives you an item.

Rating:8/10
Reason: I don't think its that much of a good map, they seem like good tiles(don patchs' tiles, am I right?) The map looks ok to me, but not that excellent. The map is a square. The stone formation looks good. and the placemnt of the ledges and the grass look good
Suggestions: Make the map less square!

~Celebi

-EDITED-
A map by me:
you can click here
sorry, I can't show it becuase its too wide, please click the link.
Name: Route _____
Comments: route of pokemon garnet

 

[Kristian]

Well, its time for a new map issn't it? :D
Name: Sanflour Town
Base Game: FireRed
Map for: Pokemon - Crescent (My hack)
Map:

Spoiler:

Credit to Zel for teh palettes =)
Comment: This is the second town in my hack, This is also the place where the second Gym is..
Please rate :) And give suggestions to improve the map.

 

[destinedjagold]

to Celebi_XD..,
Rating= 7/10
Reason= It is a very complicated route, but a very challenging one! It's like a maze, but I like it. ;)

to stead573..,
Rating= 8/10
Reason= it looks really nice for a forest... I guess there's going to be a special event there, huh..? Sweet. :)

to Kristian..,
Rating= 8.6/10
Reason= WHat can I say..? I love the simplicity and the harmonious feel around that map! I love it. :D

 

[TB Pro]

Ok heres another map....

Name:
Jastral Town

Map Of:
Fire Red

Map:

Spoiler:

Comments:
This is a starting town map...
PLZ Rate!

 

[destinedjagold]

Rating= 6/10
Reason= The map is okay at first, but then I got distracted.., since the map lacks some tiles that curves on the edges of the island. If ya know what I mean.

 

[TB Pro]

Yea....I coundn't find em'.
So naturally I figured on low ratings.

 

[destinedjagold]

Well, you could just make a tile.., but I'm sure it's around there. You'll just have to look closer at the available tiles.

Anyways...
Map Name: UnownCave

Map Game: PKMN Ruby

Comments: I am not much of a cave-mapper, and so I decided to post it around here to see if it's 'cave' enough. :D

Spoiler:

 

[Kristian]

Map name: New bark town
Base Game: Pokémon Firered
Comment:
please rate, comment, and give suggestions to improve the map =)
map:

Spoiler:

Credits:
Kristian (Everything)