Map Rating/Review Thread

[Shadows]

I'm bored so I made a map(My mapping stinks, but I decided to get it rated anyways...)
Map Name: Doesn't have one

Map Game: Doesn't have one.

Comments: Neti's Rombase.

Edit again:
Fixed the error

Map:

Spoiler:

 

[Dratii]

T's map: 7.3/10 because;

Looks too square, small tree's don't look good in a straight line and stairs look wierd.

Suggestions: fix the shape and mix in some big trees with the small trees.
Also your map is really hard to see.


Thanks for the comments on my second town/city I have tried to fix it. I think it is a lot better than before.

Spoiler:

Extra comments: The cave would (if I was making a hack, which I am not because I can't script) have a small event in there and would be closed in.

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

That's pretty good, dratii! I love the shape of the mountain!
The shape of the trees is pretty good too as well as the path shape.
Overall a very nice map! You're improving a lot!
8.5/10

 

[SerenadeDS]

@ dratii: That looks good. Big, nice and simple. I only spot one error, and it's with the PokeCenter roof. Also you didn't do custom tiles, which I like.

The Error

Other then that, it's well done. Keep it up.

 

[iBlade]

Please rate :( ... I think you guys oversaw it ..

MAAANN can't you just rate this ?? .. thats a repost of my repost o.o

I'll give you 6/10 ..

Here is mine .. no new tilesets .. and yeah .. please rate ..

ohh erhm i mean this .. .. .. ..

 

[Hiche..]

No need for demands Freaky.

About your map, it is good. I don't like the two cave entrances near each other.
The mountain around the gym is disturbing, and you pt too much flower.
There's a tile error on the very right of the map. The tree is missing. It supposed to be attached to the mountain.
Rating: 6.5/10

 

[DarkZeroONE]

Here is one of my Maps =)
Credits to Kyledove..

 

[Hiche..]

Here is one of my Maps =)
Credits to Kyledove..

That's a well done map. The map is square on the right side only.
Rating: 8.5/10

 

[Neti]

Hey all mapeprs ot there, ive got an announcement for you
From the next issue of the rom hacking newsletter on there will be a map review section
all reviews will be done by me
i will only rate one map per week, or two if i cant decide (but thats the maximum)
i will only choose a map that has something very special about it, so please dont ask me to review just standard maps that you made in 10 minutes
if you think one of your map really stands out of a all the other maps on this thread pm me and ill have a look at it
the map that i find the best will be in the review

Neti

 

[DarkZeroONE]

Here comes the next Map... It's a little mountain (water tiles and lava tiles from me =)...)
PS: Sorry for my bad english =P

 

[Satoshi Sugimori]

Alright here's a map for my hack it's a wip so not finished!
BUt I need some advice on what I could make in it because I don't know anything..
Map Name Brakta Pass
For hack Ever Dark

 

[Chimchar 9]

Alright here's a map for my hack it's a wip so not finished!
BUt I need some advice on what I could make in it because I don't know anything..
Map Name Brakta Pass
For hack Ever Dark

its good but fill up the space with trees and stuff + add paths and maybe flowers well if you correct what i said ill give you a 7.5 out of 10.
but so far 5.6

 

[Satoshi Sugimori]

Thanks but I really need some good ifnormation about what I could do into it because I really can't think of something except some paths and flowers then... More reetz pleassee :P

 

[WindBlows]

Here is a new map.

Map Name: Monolith City.

Map Game: Pokémon Zephyr (Absolute)

Comments: No.

Spoiler:

 

[Mages4ever]

Here is a new map.

Map Name: Monolith City.

Map Game: Pokémon Zephyr (Absolute)

Comments: No.

Spoiler:

Due to my noob rating skills, I see no Tile errors (Don't attack me)
Also I like how to map looks, but not the flowers or that thing made up of
about 20 pixels. Overall The map Imo 8.5/10

 

[Fraot]

New Cities...

Well, here are my maps... I "remastered" Babeil City, i dunno if looks better now.

First Map name: Babeil City
BaseRom: Fire Red
Comments: the same as before.

Second Map name: Grandwood Town
BaseRom: Fire Red
Comments: the town where you receive your first pokemon... not the starter town.

Third Map name: Teblan Town
BaseRom: Fire Red
Comments: where the first Gym leader, Nolan, is.

Fourth Map name: Efeny City
BaseRom: Fire Red
Comments: where the fourth gym leader, General Ace, is.


I hope you to give a good critic, not a laugh, as you usually do. Also, I want to know what to add/remove/change.

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

The first map, Babeil City, looks pretty good.
The house placement is nice as well as the road placement, but to me that really looks like Veilstone City. :\ I think it's just me. Other than that, the trees are a little square, but that's to be expected near a city.
7/10

 

[negative]

Here Is my already made map-redone!
Credits to:
-kyledove
-sourav
-and TB PRO
please rate EVERYTHING exept the lack of NPCs and the pallete of the water grass!

 

[Lightning Sage™]

name: Lonely villige
Rom: Pokemon ruby
The DP tileset I got from wah and I forgot who actule made it

 

[Mages4ever]

Well, since I can't enlarge it, I give it like umm...
7/10?
Can't see any tile errors but what is surrounding that house? o.O.
and I wonder how come there is a Mart and a Center for such a small place.