Map Rating/Review Thread

[haefele]

Thanks for the feedback. So, i have decided to post another map of me, pls give feedback!
;)

Here (Netis rombase in night):
img147.imageshack.us/my.php?image=rhwmappingwb12mx1.png

And here one more:
img201.imageshack.us/my.php?image=rhwmappingwb11cy1.png

mfg,
haefele, the german mapper...

 

[Hiche..]

Thanks for the feedback. So, i have decided to post another map of me, pls give feedback!
;)

Here (Netis rombase in night):
img147.imageshack.us/my.php?image=rhwmappingwb12mx1.png

And here one more:
img201.imageshack.us/my.php?image=rhwmappingwb11cy1.png

mfg,
haefele, the german mapper...

Again :|. you're a brilliant mapper! That's such a great map you did, both of them.
I will rate both of them a 9.4/10

 

[Aerodynamic]

You forgot the tiles above the doors otherwise, good work.

 

[Alistair]

Well, here is a remake map I did of Pallet Town using some D/P/Pt tiles.

Name: Pallet Town
Base: None (made in Paint)
Credits: Kyledove - Palettes, tiles
Other Comments: I just made this this map to see what Pallet Town would look like in D/P/Pt style. I do not really want any crit, considering I just remade another map, but I con't care if you post some anyway.

 

[Shadows]

Map Name: Doesn't have one

Map Game: Firered

Comments:
Mitchel1's rombase, slightly edited by me.

Spoiler:

 

[Hiche..]

Map Name: Doesn't have one

Map Game: Firered

Comments:
Mitchel1's rombase, slightly edited by me.

Spoiler:

A neat map. I don't see any tile errors, however, if you add more large trees than the small trees, it would be better.
Rating: 8.4/10

 

[/Circa]

Map Name: None
Notes: I know some palettes are a bit iffy, i'm fixing them. And the black squares are tiles I haven't inserted yet.
Credits: Kyledove - Tiles, Someone - PC and Mart (cant remember who it is)

Spoiler:

 

[Disturbed]

Alright, I have probably, the hardest-to-make map I have ever made in my life.

It looks really basic at first, but look closely, over 40 block edits were done, for me to just get a couple ratings. Please, I'd prefer it if people who know how to block edit will rate this map, and not any one else. Thanks :D

Map Name: Coalae Town
Map Time: 3.5 hours (for a 30x30 map, ridiculous!)
Map Game: Firered
Hack Game: NONE!

Please, remember, I'd like requests from only those who can block edit, or else you'll think this map is crap.

-Disturbed

HAS BEEN SLIGHTLY REVISED.

 

[Surf]

Alright, I have probably, the hardest-to-make map I have ever made in my life.

It looks really basic at first, but look closely, over 40 block edits were done, for me to just get a couple ratings. Please, I'd prefer it if people who know how to block edit will rate this map, and not any one else. Thanks :D

Map Name: Coalae Town
Map Time: 3.5 hours (for a 30x30 map, ridiculous!)
Map Game: Firered
Hack Game: NONE!

Please, remember, I'd like requests from only those who can block edit, or else you'll think this map is crap.

-Disturbed

HAS BEEN SLIGHTLY REVISED.

Disturbed How do you do it!
I have to give this map a Ten
The block Editing is well done but i can see one tile error in the side of the mountain
but no points off for that
Good Job

 

[Disturbed]

Disturbed How do you do it!
I have to give this map a Ten
The block Editing is well done but i can see one tile error in the side of the mountain
but no points off for that
Good Job

Do you mind pointing it out please? More specific, I can't find it. If it is the one in the top right, THE VERY TOP RIGHT, that isn't an error.

 

[Surf]

Do you mind pointing it out please? More specific, I can't find it. If it is the one in the top right, THE VERY TOP RIGHT, that isn't an error.

Sorry it's next to the house
it's a bit of path that looks like a mistake

 

[Tyrantrum]

Alright, I have probably, the hardest-to-make map I have ever made in my life.

It looks really basic at first, but look closely, over 40 block edits were done, for me to just get a couple ratings. Please, I'd prefer it if people who know how to block edit will rate this map, and not any one else. Thanks :D

Map Name: Coalae Town
Map Time: 3.5 hours (for a 30x30 map, ridiculous!)
Map Game: Firered
Hack Game: NONE!

Please, remember, I'd like requests from only those who can block edit, or else you'll think this map is crap.

-Disturbed

HAS BEEN SLIGHTLY REVISED.

Rating: 9.0/10.0
Errors: N/A
Suggestions: Fill up the empty space at the bottom of the mountainous area of the map.
Comments: Lovely block editing, and also, 3.5 hours for a small map isn't ridiculous. The reason why is because of all the block editing and what not. xD
Again, very lovely~

 

[TB Pro]

Map Name: None
Notes: I know some palettes are a bit iffy, i'm fixing them. And the black squares are tiles I haven't inserted yet.
Credits: Kyledove - Tiles, Someone - PC and Mart (cant remember who it is)

Spoiler:

Form:
Tile Usage/Placement: {2/4}(Average)[I Liked the tree placement, very superb, It makes the map have a nice rounded feel to it; The flowers, however, I didn't like, they were few and far between, where there were flowers, they were very bunched up; I'm not too fond of the path placement, it's a little to straight and wide for my taste, yet it still looks fairly good; I'm not crazy about the small tree placement either, they are clumped up wherever they are found; The building placement is nice, they are placed along the path, and they are spread out quite nicely; I'm disappointed in the mountain placement, it is completely straight, which is a big no-no; The water rock placement is alright, seeing as there is no truely good way to place them.]
Map Shape: {3/4}(Good)[The general map shape is good, however some things throw if off of being great; The tree shape is great(as stated above) it gives the map a great feel; The mountain shape is bad, it throws the map off from having great shape, and that saddens me; The path shape is just a matter of taste, I guess, and I prefer round-ish thinner paths; The water sand shape is great, it is not straight, or square, or anything it's just great.]
Complexity: {1.5/3}(Average)[Nothing particularly complex about this map, but it's not extremely simple either, It's just in the middle.]
Errors: {1.5/2}(Good)[Nice job on errors, I could only find one, It's in the path to the right of the downward-most house.]
Emptiness: {2/3}(Good)[You filled up most of the space nicely with good tile placement, but there is still some emptiness in the map, Most people aren't fond of emptiness, Such as me.]

Total: {10/15}(Good){B-}[Congradualtions, you made a nice map, there are just a few things keeping it from being great; Keep at it.]

Alright, I have probably, the hardest-to-make map I have ever made in my life.

It looks really basic at first, but look closely, over 40 block edits were done, for me to just get a couple ratings. Please, I'd prefer it if people who know how to block edit will rate this map, and not any one else. Thanks :D

Map Name: Coalae Town
Map Time: 3.5 hours (for a 30x30 map, rediculous!)
Map Game: Firered
Hack Game: NONE!

Please, remember, I'd like requests from only those who can block edit, or else you'll think this map is crap.

Spoiler:

-Disturbed

Form:
Tile Usage/Placment: {3/4}(Good)[Okay to start off, you did a great job on placing most of the tiles in a great way; The tree placement is good, scattered around to give the map a little green, makes it look great; The small tree placement is great too, it just helps break the map up with some green, which looks nice; The flower placement is nice, not too many of them, and they're scattered around nicely; The path placement is probably most astounding of all, All the block edits you did to make the path so great is just wonderful, kudos; Nice job with the building placement is nice too, the block edits make it look nice; The mountain placement is great, not too square, the second and third layers don't follow the same path too closely; The rock placement is great too, not too many, and they're spread out perfectly.]
Map Shape: {3/4}(Good)[The general map shape is great, however, it's not perfect; The path placement is wonderful, you took a lot of time with all the block edits to make it look good, and you succeeded; The mountain shape is great, except for the upper left corner, it just looks a little...off, too square-ish I guess.]
Complexity: {3/3}(Astounding)[Yep, this map has complexity, all of the block edits add together to make a great complex map, I really can't suggest anything to make it more complex, all of the many block edits flow together to make a nice and complex map.]
Errors: {2/2}(Good)[No errors, as always.]
Emptiness: {3/3}(Astounding)[Great job man, you used the space up very well, If you added anything else, it would be cramped.]

Total:{14/15}(Astounding){A}[Kudos Jake, another great map, very complex with all the Block Edits, great job.]

 

[Neti]

I think I didnt post a map for a really long time now
So here is my new version of Kouan, a city in Huoshi form my Hack Legend of Fenju:

Map Name: Kouan
Base: FireRed BPRE + Melting RomBase (not published yet)
Game: Pokemon Legend of Fenju
Comments:
The unofficial name of the town is Rainbows Edge.
The big house on the island is the village elders home.
Mapshot:

 

[Likewise]

Alright, I have probably, the hardest-to-make map I have ever made in my life.

It looks really basic at first, but look closely, over 40 block edits were done, for me to just get a couple ratings. Please, I'd prefer it if people who know how to block edit will rate this map, and not any one else. Thanks :D

Map Name: Coalae Town
Map Time: 3.5 hours (for a 30x30 map, ridiculous!)
Map Game: Firered
Hack Game: NONE!

Please, remember, I'd like requests from only those who can block edit, or else you'll think this map is crap.

-Disturbed

HAS BEEN SLIGHTLY REVISED.

MUAHAHAHAHA now i get to rate on of YOUR maps:badsmile:

Well you put a lot of time into it, more then me since i only make like 1 block edit for a giant map xD.

The mountains, though in some places a bit emptey, (but the player wouldn't see them so who cares) are extremley detailed.

I think you should have eased up on the size of the path not much but a bit.

Only tile error I spot is the path on the top left side beside the house (I'm not even sure if it is one!)

There really wasn't much to critisise do....
9/10
Wow I finally rate one of your maps and I decide to do this one T.T

 

[Hiche..]

I think I didnt post a map for a really long time now
So here is my new version of Kouan, a city in Huoshi form my Hack Legend of Fenju:

Map Name: Kouan
Base: FireRed BPRE + Melting RomBase (not published yet)
Game: Pokemon Legend of Fenju
Comments:
The unofficial name of the town is Rainbows Edge.
The big house on the island is the village elders home.
Mapshot:

I love the tiles used :D The shape is very good, and sea is placed nicely. No tile errors, or such.
Rating: 9.2/10

 

[TB Pro]

I think I didnt post a map for a really long time now
So here is my new version of Kouan, a city in Huoshi form my Hack Legend of Fenju:

Map Name: Kouan
Base: FireRed BPRE + Melting RomBase (not published yet)
Game: Pokemon Legend of Fenju
Comments:
The unofficial name of the town is Rainbows Edge.
The big house on the island is the village elders home.
Mapshot:

Spoiler:

Form:
Tile Usage/Placement: {4/4}(Astounding)[Great job with the placement of tiles on this map Neti; The mountain placement is great, you placed them in ideal areas to take up space and add to the beauty of the map; The path placement is wonderful, not too straight, and not too wide, It's just perfect; The building placement is also great, they're spread out nicely, not too cramped up, the only thing I don't like is that the path dosen't lead to all of them; The rock placement is great, you have a great variety of them, and you alternated them wonderfully, not too cramped with them, either; The greenery placement is nice, not too much to take away from the desert feel, but enough to add some color; The water rock placement is also wonderful, there is a great variety of rocks you placed in the water, which is a big turn-on; The extra tile placement(such as chairs, umbrellas, ect.) is also great, it just adds beauty to the map, and fills up some space.]
Map Shape: {3/4}(Good)[Overall, the shape is nice, there are just a few things that take away from it being perfect; The mountain shape is great, for the most part, you placed the mountains in a wonderful shape, very nice and rounded, but not awkwardly round, I just don't like the mountain placement above the Elder's House; The beach shape is great, it makes it feel like a real beach, and it also takes up some of the space that needs to be filled.]
Complexity:{2/3}(Good)[The complexity of this map is at a good level, however, it's not great, there are a few things that add to the complexity, but nothing that really makes it super complex.]
Errors:{2/2}(Perfect)[I could spot no errors, which is to be expected from a great mapper like yourself.]
Emptiness: {2.5/3}(Great)[Overall, you filled up most of the space nicely, but it still looks a bit empty to me, I know it's a desert and it's supposed to be sorta empty, but I just think you could insert more tiles or something and fill up some more space.]

Total: {13.5/15}(Astounding){A-}[Congratz, Neti, this was a very well-made map, a few things kept it from being even better, however, you should still be proud.]

 

[negative]

HI! This Is My Map:
PLEASE I BEG YOU; DO NOT STEAL; COUSE I WILL MAKE A ROMBASE ONE DAY...
Name:Route 801
Hack: Plasma Force-scrapbox
Credits: Kyledove, Me

 

[Chimchar 9]

nobody rated my map before so im reposting it
hack name : pokemon white isle
hacking : fire red
comments : i changed the base to fire red again,because i map better with fire red anyway please rate these 2 maps !

maps :
breeze town :

Spoiler:

route 1:

Spoiler:

plz rate this time ^^

 

[Surf]

nobody rated my map before so im reposting it
hack name : pokemon white isle
hacking : fire red
comments : i changed the base to fire red again,because i map better with fire red anyway please rate these 2 maps !

maps :
breeze town :

Spoiler:

route 1:

Spoiler:

plz rate this time ^^

I'll give the first one 9.5 and the second one 8 because i don't like those rocks