Map Rating/Review Thread

[Neti]

I'm posting these maps cause I want to see if people are willing to play in them, some spaces may be empty but thats to allow events and the player to walk around in.

Name: Bonlite Town
Credits: Kyledove

Spoiler:

Name: Route 1
Credits: Kyledove

Spoiler:

Name: Cokoo City
Credits: Kyledove

Spoiler:

Name: Route 2
Credits: Kyledove

Spoiler:

Name: Terrafin City
Credits: Kyledove

Spoiler:

I dont think theyre empty, they appear really well filled to me. The only thing i noticed was the river being unnaturally straight and on route 1 you should remove some of the tall grass patches randomly in the middle of the tall grass section. that looks good^^
other than that i think these are are really well done, much space, but thats no problem to me

 

[Pokepal17]

This is my map. If it's rubbish, it's because I'm a noob at hacking. One of the builings on the map is meant to be inaccessable, incase you notice.

 

[Tropical Sunlight]

@Pokepal17: The map is rubbish, like you said. Look at Neti's or Itman's tutorial for mapping.

1. NEVER EVER make words out of anything.
2. The GYM is unacessible
3. The rocks under the big building are not meant to be placed like that, the same for the bushes
4. You have a problem with the border
5. More, but I don't have time to count it all...

2/10

 

[Pokepal17]

Ok thanks, I know where I went wrong
BTW the Gym was an accident, i forgot to put stairs for it.

 

[sab]

I hope this one is good it's only like my third map.
cedit saurav

 

[Pokepal17]

My new map. Credits go to Neti, dshayabusa, Fangking Omega for making the ROM base I used. Plz comment and rate.



@ sab, 8/10, it would be great for jungle/safari zone. The palette gives it a feeling of wilderness.

 

[sab]

Pokepal17

Hacker in training

My new map. Credits go to Neti, dshayabusa, Fangking Omega for making the ROM base I used. Plz comment and rate.



@ sab, 8/10, it would be great for jungle/safari zone. The palette gives it a feeling of wilderness.

Looks good. I have the feeling that it would look lots better with the events put in. It gives the feeling of emptyness without them for some reason unknown to me.I think if you added some scenery like flowers or pathes it might help a lot.All in all if it has good placement of events 7/10. You are getting better.

 

[Makorin]

Ok i have a new map!

Map Name: Slowpoke Well (yes, from Johto)
Map Game: Fire Red
Comments: My remake of Slowpoke Well from Johto If liked ill use in my hack :D
Map shot:

Spoiler:

 

[Pokepal17]

Ok i have a new map!

Map Name: Slowpoke Well (yes, from Johto)
Map Game: Fire Red
Comments: My remake of Slowpoke Well from Johto If liked ill use in my hack :D
Map shot:

Content hidden:
Click here to view.

10/10 for an exact remake

 

[FoggyDoggy]

Ok i have a new map!

Map Name: Slowpoke Well (yes, from Johto)
Map Game: Fire Red
Comments: My remake of Slowpoke Well from Johto If liked ill use in my hack :D
Map shot:

Spoiler:

Meh... The paths are a bit empty, and I cherish Silver Version... (My first Pokemon Game) So I rate Remakes pretty harsh...
I don't like it.
I am really not trying to be mean, but the only things that make it look like slowpoke well in any way, are the Elevated ground being in the same general area, and even that's not right...

For Mapping quality, if it had events in it, I'd give it a 6/10
For calling it a re-make, and having it be nothing like the original, 4/10
Soory... :\

 

[bboykev]

Well I kinda ''upgraded'' my map whit some help from Neti (thnx Neti) so here it is rate it please ^_^

Spoiler:

 

[Pokepal17]

My third map.
ROM: Fire Red
Map Name: Hikari Village
Credits to: Pounder_Zeikku, Alistair, Peyi, Kyledove, TB Pro for their awesome ROM base. Sorry if the tiles are a bit squashed lengthways (from uploading). Plz rate and comment.



@bboykev 9/10 Great map but the road to the gym seems a bit uneventful.

 

[Banjora Marxvile]

I've got another map. This one is in Ruby and is the starting town for Island Mystery.

Credits: Kyledove for tiles and pallettes. I modified them slightly.

 

[Pokepal17]

@ Turtwigtoon

10/10 - It is simple and the palette gives it a feel of mystery and judging by the name of your hack, it should be just right.

 

[Vrai]

M'kay, I've worked pretty hard on this one. I'd like it if I could get a few honest comments here.. ^^

Map Name: Route 701
Map Game: Fire Red
Comments: There's no grass whatsoever because as the player is going through this map, he doesn't have any Pokémon.
Mapshot: Located here

 

[Osher99]

Map Name: Lax Yar Town

Map Game: FireRed

Comments: Newest Map! Rate ^^

Mapshot:

 

[haefele]

There is many empty space.... thats not good
Your mapping isn't very good now, but not bad. Learn and make maps to get better.

Here is a map with the Kyledove DP Tiles:

img3.imagebanana.com/img/9a1500ex/Haferbreimap3.png

This map was for a contest in a german pokemon forum, and I won :)
Here, one other map of the contest:

img3.imagebanana.com/img/x01ys0xl/Insel.PNG

 

[Tropical Sunlight]

@haefele:

1st map: 9.99999/10: OK, this definetly looks cool. Nice job on the tiles, though.

2nd map: 6/10: I don't know what kind of contest that was, but that map is certainly not good. It only has one level and it's boring.

 

[Disturbed]

Keep in mind... I only rate maps that will receive above a 5.5 from me.

There is many empty space.... thats not good
Your mapping isn't very good now, but not bad. Learn and make maps to get better.

Here is a map with the Kyledove DP Tiles:

img3.imagebanana.com/img/9a1500ex/Haferbreimap3.png

This map was for a contest in a german pokemon forum, and I won :)
Here, one other map of the contest:

img3.imagebanana.com/img/x01ys0xl/Insel.PNG

I'm only rating your first map because of what I said above.
Rating: 6.5/10
Reason: Okay, these tiles just dominate the map, and if we were to look at the map without the tiles, it'd look plain and simple. It feels like there wasn't enough effort added into this map, and there would be soo many border errors >.<. Also, looking at the bushes, the outline is orange... >.<
I'd like to see more good maps from you ;D

 

[nadjim]

Map Name: Félondelle

Map Game: Rubis us
Comments: My First Map!

Mapshot: