Map Rating/Review Thread

[Tropical Sunlight]

Map name:Stent Road
Hack name-???(Secret shh)
Mapshot-

Spoiler:

Comments: The starting map i know the tile errors don't worry like the water and the "hotel"...I think that the flower in the bush seems a bit pointless but enough self critism what do you think?
Made by Me

2/10
The map is sooooo poor!
Try to read a mapping tutorial...

 

[Vrai]

yeah its a lil to basic and small

Uhm, yeah. Don't post if you're just going to repeat what others said.

Map name: Grand Valley
Hack: Pokemon Turquoise
Base ROM: Firered English (BPRE)
Mapshot:

(click)
Notes: The map is pretty difficult for your second route, so there is a psychic who heals you in front of the cave entrance. And, you come from the left.
Credits: Saurav, rhevarhe_duh for tiles

I think, one of your best maps so far. The paths aren't straight for the most part (looks at exit), flowers and trees aren't overused, and the grass looks pretty well done. Some of the straighter parts of the mountain bug me a bit, and I think the area to the northeast of the three cave entrances feels a bit empty (as in you might want to add an exta mountain level or two). Overall, this is an excellent map. I hope you do just as good of a job in the future. ;)

Also, that one staircase leading downwards is bugging me, too. >_<

 

[TheNerdyPotato]

Here are some of the first maps in my hack, please rate nicely and keep in mind its supposed to be a maze
all of the maps are from Doshido woods, and the base rom is fire red and the viridian forest tileset

 

[Surf]

Map Name: None
Rom Base: Fire Red
Credits: Disturbed

Description: Well I got bored and I tought I'd make another map
It's not in a hack so you can use it if you please.

 

[TB Pro]

Well, I inserted most of the tiles into Onyx again, and I mapped the first route. Enjoy.

Map Name Windfry Pass

Game Pokémon: Onyx

Base ROM Fire Red[English]

Mapping Time About an hour and a half

Credits Alistair - Tiles

Mapshot

Spoiler:

EDIT: Fixed map.

 

[TheNerdyPotato]

Well, I inserted most of the tiles into Onyx again, and I mapped the first route. Enjoy.

Map Name Windfry Pass

Game Pokémon: Onyx

Base ROM Fire Red[English]

Mapping Time About an hour and a half

Mapshot

Spoiler:

its about an 8 because of the fact you cant get out well, only one way in and the mountain is well detailed but it leads no where

 

[Surf]

Well, I inserted most of the tiles into Onyx again, and I mapped the first route. Enjoy.

Map Name Windfry Pass

Game Pokémon: Onyx

Base ROM Fire Red[English]

Mapping Time About an hour and a half

Credits Alistair - Tiles

Mapshot

Spoiler:

EDIT: Fixed map.

Nice map Ipro 9\10
Why?: It has brilliant placement of tiles with a wide veriaty of them.
The only thing that annoys me is the fact that there onl looks like thes on entrance and no exit

 

[Disturbed]

Disturbed bring you all Dugalake City, for the hell of it.
It's not being used in anywhere, but I really don't want anyone using it unless given strict permission by consulting me only on MSN :D

Thanks go to Alistair for some tiles and Punk Rocker for rombase

Spoiler:

 

[пзо]

Map

Map name: Route 1 (Obsidian Redone)
Map of: Fire Red
Comments: I was getting bored so i decided to make a harder route 1.
Im very prowed of this map, so dont crush me over it. :P
*Looks at Disturbed*

 

[Surf]

Map name: Route 1 (Obsidian Redone)
Map of: Fire Red
Comments: I was getting bored so i decided to make a harder route 1.
Im very prowed of this map, so dont crush me over it. :P
*Looks at Disturbed*

I love this map.
The placement is brilliant and the map is full of a great veriaty of tiles
9.5\10

 

[Disturbed]

Map name: Route 1 (Obsidian Redone)
Map of: Fire Red
Comments: I was getting bored so i decided to make a harder route 1.
Im very prowed of this map, so dont crush me over it. :P
*Looks at Disturbed*

You're about to be crushed.
I'm not giving it an actual rating, I'm just critiquing it.
1. Loads of tile errors
2. Loads of tree shading errors
3. Berry grass abundance
4. Poor mountain shape
5. Border errors maybe I'm wrong.
6. Way too filled, easily possible.
7. I believe your trying to hard.

There's my criticism. Enjoy it, it can only help you improve.




EDITZ:

I gotz a forest here that whoever wants it (with my permissionz) can take it.

Random Foresty thing:

Spoiler:

Credits to Punk Rocker for rombase

 

[пзо]

Since

Map name:
Revior Town
Map of:
Pokemon Fire Red
Comments:
Since I was getting complaints about obsidian having Tree shadow errors.
So I changed the tiles a and Pallets.

 

[Liquid Shadow]

Map name:
Revior Town
Map of:
Pokemon Fire Red
Comments:
Since I was getting complaints about obsidian having Tree shadow errors.
So I changed the tiles a and Pallets.

This map is so beatuiful and simple. I don't really have a "rating" style but...
I'd say for the shape I'd give you a 4.8/5, just because the left side is a little bit square.
For building placement a 4.2/5 simply because that house on the right of the pond is kind of aligned to the purple one.
For water, its shape is perfect, 5/5
No tile errors that I can see.
5/5 for paths
Some of the silvery and brown rocks to the right are sticking out.

Overall, you get a 94/100.

Oh, and I don't even know how to fix tree shading so I can't say anything on that.

 

[TheNerdyPotato]

You're about to be crushed.
I'm not giving it an actual rating, I'm just critiquing it.
1. Loads of tile errors
2. Loads of tree shading errors
3. Berry grass abundance
4. Poor mountain shape
5. Border errors maybe I'm wrong.
6. Way too filled, easily possible.
7. I believe your trying to hard.

There's my criticism. Enjoy it, it can only help you improve.




EDITZ:

I gotz a forest here that whoever wants it (with my permissionz) can take it.

Random Foresty thing:

Spoiler:

Credits to Punk Rocker for rombase

Nice Map,
I give it a 9 because it looks just like a forest, but a few things are just plain too random and ockword, so yeah.
And If allowed, may I use it?

 

[colcolstyles]

Since I was getting complaints about obsidian having Tree shadow errors.
So I changed the tiles a and Pallets.

Wow.
So when you're faced with a problem, you just find a way to avoid solving it? That's an interesting outlook on life.
Try this tutorial if you're really struggling with it that much.

I suppose I have to rate a map.
@iPro. 5/10
There. Bye.

 

[TB Pro]

Comments:
Since I was getting complaints about obsidian having Tree shadow errors.
So I changed the tiles a and Pallets.

You mean stole my palettes If you use my palettes please give credit. Oh a rating eh? 4/10.

 

[~Teh Panda~]

Pokemon underground is back??? Yes it is!

New base, new everything!
Map: Milano Valley

Credits to kay3o for some tiles ;)

 

[Liquid Shadow]

Well, here's now my fourth ever map. Well, not COMPLETELY original but.....

This is Old Bark Town, a revamp of New Bark Town... It's supposed to look like 30 years later.
Although it may not look like it but.. I had to do over 10 block edits :S
Oh, and don't rate me on tree shadowing.. I'm still trying to learn that stuff.

 

[SmashLucario]

I like that map Neo. Love how you turned it into a coastal town! :D

Anyway here's a few maps from me..

For the following maps: Credit to Avatar_Ryan, Forgotten Memory, and Kyledove for the Rom Base.

^^ This map is in the middle of a forest. That explains the long paths (Kinda like the Safari Zone how it has different areas).

More to come

> SL

 

[TB Pro]

Oh, and don't rate me on tree shadowing.. I'm still trying to learn that stuff.

Lol, that's a joke, right? How can we grade you on tree shadows if you used a base without tree shadows? 5/10