Map Rating/Review Thread

[Hiche..]

Improved Route 1

Image:

Spoiler:

 

[Logan]

Hack of: FR

Credits:
Mitchel1
Kyledove
Pey
Alistar
Haraken

Hack name: Pokamon: Tranquil Moon & Blazing Sun

Spoiler:

Map name: Base

Comments: Not sure if the grass is correct. It's the start place for my hack.

(image no longer exists)

4/10. A few things bother me, it is very square and rather weird. The doors on the houses look very weird and why is there are a mart and center in the starter town?

Spoiler:

Map name: -

Comments: Not sure if the grass is correct. The first route in my hack.

(image no longer exists)

Hmm... I actually quite like this map. 7/10 It is very nice for a little route, it is quite nice :P

Improved Route 1

Image:

Spoiler:

I liked it before, and now I like it even more xD 9/10

 

[Ray Maverick]

Improved Route 1

Image:

Spoiler:

Very nice..how long it took you to make?
rating: 8,4/10

 

[Master Terrador]

Time for me to review some...Lets get to it...

Improved Route 1

Image:

Wow...I like it...Such a nice...Beautiful map...
9/10
Looks good as is...:)

again i'll post a map :/ its the complete map of the part i showed you last time...

Map Name: -
Map Game: FireRed (GER)
Comments: It was hard :S
Credits:
-rhevarhe_duh
-Pey!
-TB Pro Zeikku

Wow thats big...And Great...Can't find a single mistake...The map was too big to fit on my post...
10/10
Looks good as is...

Tiles by WesleyFG...

Screen:

Please rate ;).

mfg,
haefele

I...Too...Have fallen in love with this one...Theres so much going on in this map...Its...Urm...Awesome...
10/10
looks good as is...

Map-??? Town
Game-Emerald(U)(ENG)
Description-A town with a drainage river from Mirror Mt's and it eroded a hole in the south-east of the town leading into Waterfall Cave. In the north-east sector is a herbal shop. In the center, a gym with a stepping rock in front to get over the water. Outer border is tall grass to represent a field, and a lake below the fence on the bottom.
Comments-It was interesting to find out that pokemon games use so little tiles, It get you wondering.(new to the hacking world)

The tiles are pretty random...and I'm definitely not a fan of the Gaping hole in the middle of a town...Its out of place...
3.5/10
Read a mapping tutorial...Learn Natural mapping...

Hack of: FR

Credits:
Mitchel1
Kyledove
Pey
Alistar
Haraken

Hack name: Pokamon: Tranquil Moon & Blazing Sun


Map name: Base

Comments: Not sure if the grass is correct. It's the start place for my hack.

(image no longer exists)

Map name: -

Comments: Not sure if the grass is correct. The first route in my hack.

(image no longer exists)

Map#1-One of the most important rules...Don't make your maps Square...Add some more vegetation...you have enough room...
4/10
Don't make them square...Give them Shape...

Map#2-This ones not bad...A nice route...I Actually like it...
8.5/10
Its good as is...

~Shadow~

 

[Laidjon*]

Map Name: Route 2

Map Game: Fire red

Comments: Please don't mind the top-right corner as players can't see it ingame.
And as you can see, I'm not so good at mountains.
So please rate honestly and please point out errors or possible improvements.
Thanks.

BTW the map is big.

Mapshot: See attachment.

 

[Samike360]

Map Name: Route 2

Map Game: Fire red

Comments: Please don't mind the top-right corner as players can't see it ingame.
And as you can see, I'm not so good at mountains.
So please rate honestly and please point out errors or possible improvements.
Thanks.

BTW the map is big.

Mapshot: See attachment.

Rating: I would give it 7/10

Reason: I like the map, it is big, and I really like the tree and the path tiles your using.

Suggestions: I would eliminate some of the rocks in the mountain region, there seems to be a lot of them. It also wouldn't hurt to eliminate some of the grass, it will be a pain going through all that grass when you're playing it. I also would suggest connecting the two paths at the bottom right.

 

[Neti]

Map Name: Route 2

Map Game: Fire red

Comments: Please don't mind the top-right corner as players can't see it ingame.
And as you can see, I'm not so good at mountains.
So please rate honestly and please point out errors or possible improvements.
Thanks.

BTW the map is big.

Mapshot: See attachment.

Really cool map i think
although the mountain sure could be improved, i think its not bad
maybe try to add some variety into the mountain shape... i discovered that technique only a short while ago: the first step of making natural mountains is to make them from scratch (and no 100% straight lines that most people start off with). now that you have those nice lookin round shapesthat have some randomness in them, you can go one step further and make them even more random by not making them go into the desired target direction nearly-straight as they are right now... its kinda hard to explain... now you have curves, and it would be better if you wouldnt have curves but replace them with random shapes... well i think ill just attach a map of mine that sows what i mean
i disagree with the previous post, i dont think there are too many rocks or too much grass... maybe remove one or 2 grass patches in every field

ill rate it 8/10

and heres my map, dunno if you get what i meant with the mountains from it, its really hard to explain
feel free to rate it:

Map Name: Route 20
Game: Legend of Fenju - Huoshi
Comments: The cave is the cremation cave

Spoiler:

 

[MASTEROFPUPPETS93]

Map Name: Route 20
Game: Legend of Fenju - Huoshi
Comments: The cave is the cremation cave

Spoiler:

Again an amazing map, Neti :D The only thing that bugs me is the lava... It's next to the edge of the mountains... Don't you think it would flow down, too? But it's your map, I don't have to teach you in these things... I leaned many things from you in mapping so I'll give it 9/10 ;)

Map Name: Route 2

Map Game: Fire red

Comments: Please don't mind the top-right corner as players can't see it ingame.
And as you can see, I'm not so good at mountains.
So please rate honestly and please point out errors or possible improvements.
Thanks.

BTW the map is big.

Mapshot: See attachment.

Great Map :) I like it! It's huge and natural^^ But why is the path so yellow? It's too light, I think :/ I give it 8,5/10

A new map (again again) It was boring :/ But this is an emerald one^^ i changed palettes and inserted just ONE tile;) Here it is:

Map Name: Route 6463 xD
Map Game: Emerald (GER)
Comments: It was easy :P

Mapshot:

Spoiler:

 

[Samike360]

Ok I edited my map (oceanview town for Ruby) with some changes to some of the errors I had:

I made the map larger, redid the ocean border.
I eliminated some rocks on beach and land, moved stuff around.
I increased the size of the houses.
I changed the border between grass and beach to a cliff.
I fixed the tile above the cave.

I would appreciate suggestions to make this map better, it is the starting town so its important in the hack :D (Map in attachment)

 

[Red-eX]

New Maps for You.
Credits: Kyledove
hxxp://img3.imagebanana.com/img/em0164aa/Anfangsdorf2009.png
hxxp://img3.imagebanana.com/img/k48zeuc1/Schluchtbrcke.png
hxxp://img3.imagebanana.com/img/wr689gr/Waldroute.png
hxxp://img3.imagebanana.com/img/nzjiyr31/100prozentWaldschlucht.png

!! don't hxxp:// !!
You must do it http

 

[Lightning Sage™]

Map Name: Mushi town
Map Game: Fire red
Comments: This is the second place you visit in my hack

Mapshot: See attachments

 

[PI Hudson]

Revised map

2nd attempt

Name-Crescent Town(new name, too)
Game- Pokemon Shale(not listed)
Base- Emerald (U)
Comments-

Spoiler:

I removed the fence thats above the lake, added custom tiles for paths, added some forestry, gave mountains more detail, moved Waterfall Caves' waterfall entrance into another map, extended river to lake below, changed tiles gym was on, and redid the river.

Should I extend the waterfall in Crescent town?

I'm also going to put the route below it to give some understanding, which may also need some improvement.(Route 135)

Also, border for both is tall grass

 

[Sweet Jasmine]

Map Name: Route 6463 xD
Map Game: Emerald (GER)
Comments: It was easy :P

Mapshot:
Spoiler:

This Map looks good. Especially the Mountains and the Grass palette.
I think this doesn't have some errors some i give you a Perfect Score 10/10.

Map Name: Route 20
Game: Legend of Fenju - Huoshi
Comments: The cave is the cremation cave
Spoiler:

The map looks a mazy one. But it's really nice.. No Errors. Perfect Score! 10/10

 

[Logan]

Map Name: Inshika Town
Game: Pokémon Island Mystery: Torn Shadows
Comments: As you may know, me and Marxvile decided to re-start IM on Ruby. But I have never mapped on Ruby before. So here was my shot it the starter town, enjoy xD

 

[Aljam]

Map Name: Inshika Town
Game: Pokémon Island Mystery: Torn Shadows
Comments: As you may know, me and Marxvile decided to re-start IM on Ruby. But I have never mapped on Ruby before. So here was my shot it the starter town, enjoy xD

youre map is good but its a little beAr... youre water is square as well. youre map is also really grenn. If your intending to make it greenish go ahead. if not change the path. other than that it is quite good

7.5/10

 

[Luck]

I was just scribbling on paper and made world maps.
This was what I made(just aesthetics, no playability).



Also, no one rated this map either. I would prefer if no one skipped me this time.
https://img132.imageshack.us/img132/589/seran.png

 

[Sweet Jasmine]

Map Name: Inshika Town
Game: Pokémon Island Mystery: Torn Shadows
Comments: As you may know, me and Marxvile decided to re-start IM on Ruby. But I have never mapped on Ruby before. So here was my shot it the starter town, enjoy xD

This looks good Goodies :3. and i really like the map. except the pond can you make it a little bit smaller? then add some trees to make it look good.. I'll rate you 8/10 :P.

 

[Pokestick good times.]

Map Name: Inshika Town
Game: Pokémon Island Mystery: Torn Shadows
Comments: As you may know, me and Marxvile decided to re-start IM on Ruby. But I have never mapped on Ruby before. So here was my shot it the starter town, enjoy xD

Well, Basicly, I like the map. I like the way you placed everything and so, I think the playability is really good, the map is nice and simple.

Although, the trees and the pond are a little square, the pond itself is just a little too big, and it's a bit empty at some spots of the map.
I don't really like the trees, but i won't make my rate lower just because my taste is different. The pond tiles are tearing my eyes out, they just don't fit there at all... But as I said, I'm not gonna rate the map lower because of the tiles.

My rating... 8,23/10.

Suggestions: Well, first of all, I would change the pond tiles. You've probably figured that out already. then, maybe make the pond more basic and add some trees. and maybe fill the empty spaces just a little. Maybe a flower or two, that'd do it... I'm not really a fan of the RSE-games, but this map is pretty good. Good luck hacking!

 

[Laidjon*]

Map Name: City 2 (Unnamed)

Map Game: Fire red

Comments: Just a town/city without a gym

Mapshot: See attachment.

 

[Lightning Sage™]

U guys and girls missed me
Map Name: Mushi town
Map Game: Fire red
Comments: This is the second place you visit in my hack

Mapshot: See attachments