I personally feel that's the wrong way to go about things. Judge a series for what it is yourself. Don't let what a, b or c says about it affect your opinion of the series unless they point out some details you overlooked.
Like, for example, NGE is called a masterpiece by its fandom and is considered a psychological anime with many 2deep4u elements and it has been overanalysed to death. I saw NGE, I read a few analysis for fun. But I enjoyed the series more for how it was so different than your average mecha anime and did possess a lot of things that deviated from the norm for its time (whiny protag, most cast having psychological prolems, the over the top nature of the EoE etc.).
Maybe I'm just not smart enough to understand all the things it tries to say and maybe the fandom are correct - but, for me, NGE was nothing more than a very fun ride. Fun because it was something truly unique and I enjoyed the battles. :p