Overwatch Mafia: Game over?!

jdthebud said:
Don't see that right now.


Sorry about that, it got lost in the shuffle since I was responding to more recent interactions. Goku never did address his Rabi/McCree alliance accusation in more detail, but I think Rabi and McCree have addressed it enough that I believe they aren't working together intentionally at this point. Would still be interested in hearing more about why Goku made that accusation in the first place though.

Also I think Rabi meant you were getting town read and were trying to take advantage of it to push your scum reads out aggressively and perhaps set up mislynches. Not sure if that's what you were/are actually doing, but I can see how Rabi could interpret it that way. What are your thoughts on Johnny vs. Goku? Anybody you want to vote for other than perhaps Ninjorf?
Click to expand...
That makes more sense then if that's what he meant (even if it's not true). I do still want to lynch Ninjorf, but no one has given any opinion on him besides me and McCree. Let me look over D2 again quick, should be easier now that I'm at my computer.
Rabinov said:
jd basically hit the nail on the head - what I meant was that I'm getting the feeling you pushing out your reads to then cause lynches to go wrong essentially.

Pecilia: I only outed because otherwise I think I was going to be a goner and I can at least potentially be saved during the night, whereas it might be that if I were lynched today that then as we determine mafia we can't pick them off because I'm not here.

However, you pose an interesting point regarding jd, I won't act on it right now but I will keep an eye for sure.

[Unvote]SuperJolt in the mean time though, and because it's close to end and I need to vote otherwise I get in trouble

[Vote] Goku
Click to expand...
EDIT: @Rabi ok that is what you meant, fair enough

EDIT 2: actually putting Rabi's quote in here

btw I don't know if you were referring to my point about jd from my last post (about him not acknowledging what I said earlier) but I'm good with his response. There is something else from jd though that bugs me, stay tuned

[Lynch] Ninjorf in case I don't get my next post up before the day ends
 
Last edited:
Johnny's being super aggro with no evidence, while simultaneously making the same claims that he suspects people for. Goku has not stricken me as suss, and Johnny's suggestion for Goku to shoot the gun doesn't gain him any points. Today's day phase is a bit whack but we're running up on time.

[Lynch] Johnny
 
Night 2

As the heroes were preparing to eliminate Goku, Winston realised that he recognised him from one of his investigations. He had caught Goku doing scummy things during the night. This made Winston very angry indeed.

[PokeCommunity.com] Overwatch Mafia: Game over?!


Goku has been eliminated. He was Sombra.

Players

NightKrow as the GM​
Abby as ???
EvilChameleon as Widowmaker​
Ninjorf as ???
Johnny as ???
gimmepie as ???
Goku as Sombra​
McCree as ???
Tracer as ???
Rabinov as ???
Bardothren as ???
Pecilia as ???
Uzumaki Naruto as ???
jdthebud as ???
Paranoia_ as Torbjörn​
Zapmolticuno as ???
Superjolt as ???
Alex Kaz as Civilian​

Spoiler:
 
Day 3

The Terrorist set out on another mission for his boss. He had found who he had been asked to kill, all he had to do was not mess up. His bomb was in place, all he had to do was press the button when the time was right...

CHAAAAAARGE!!!

[PokeCommunity.com] Overwatch Mafia: Game over?!


Before the Terrorist could react, he was pinned up against the wall by a large German man. The Terrorist fell limp - his body could not handle the impact.

Meanwhile, Bastion had awoken from his slumber. Overgrown, and with his bird friend in tow, he stumbled across Reaper. He was tending the grave of his fallen comrade, Sombra.

*Sad beep*
"Oh, hey. Sombra...she was a brilliant hacker and a valued member of the team. She died too young."
It was at that moment that Bastion knew his new purpose. He beeped with determination as the light on his face turned red.

Bardothren has been eliminated. He was the Terrorist.
Bastion has taken Sombra's role!

Abby, Ninjorf and Uzumaki Naruto must have a vote by the end of this day phase or get eliminated/replaced.

Players

NightKrow as the GM​
Abby as ???
EvilChameleon as Widowmaker​
Ninjorf as ???
Johnny as ???
gimmepie as ???
Goku as Sombra​
McCree as ???
Tracer as ???
Rabinov as ???
Bardothren as Terrorist​
Pecilia as ???
Uzumaki Naruto as ???
jdthebud as ???
Paranoia_ as Torbjörn​
Zapmolticuno as ???
Superjolt as ???
Alex Kaz as Civilian​

Spoiler:
 
gimmepie said:
I'm assuming that it was Abby simply because I can't think of anything else that would result in that happening.

I'm not sure what to say on the matter of Bastion/Sombra other than, why would you do that? The mafia are getting demolished.
Click to expand...
Well to be fair they didn't know that Bard would die the same night...and I kind of understand though, it's fun being mafia. Fortunately for us Bard is dead now, and also fortunately Bastion didn't choose the Strongman, that would have been annoying to deal with. At least we have 2 real guns still floating around - Ana's and the one the GS handed out last night, assuming they did so. Sucks that you can't get one since you have a fabbed gun.

Anyway, I think McCree is probably not scum considering Goku threw shade on them, assuming they aren't cult or even Bastion, which is a possibility.

I think the current game state now is 2 mafia, 3 cult, and 7 town left. So we are doing ok right now, but that will change very quickly if we mislynch today and the next day.

What do you think about Tracer? He voted for you yesterday for some odd reason.
 
jdthebud said:
Well to be fair they didn't know that Bard would die the same night...and I kind of understand though, it's fun being mafia. Fortunately for us Bard is dead now, and also fortunately Bastion didn't choose the Strongman, that would have been annoying to deal with. At least we have 2 real guns still floating around - Ana's and the one the GS handed out last night, assuming they did so. Sucks that you can't get one since you have a fabbed gun.

Anyway, I think McCree is probably not scum considering Goku threw shade on them, assuming they aren't cult or even Bastion, which is a possibility.

I think the current game state now is 2 mafia, 3 cult, and 7 town left. So we are doing ok right now, but that will change very quickly if we mislynch today and the next day.

What do you think about Tracer? He voted for you yesterday for some odd reason.
Click to expand...

I'd say it's a safe bet that Johnny isn't maf also considering how hard he was gunning for Klippy.

I could definitely see Matt as scum, that vote on me during all that was just plain weird. The only thing really stopping me from dropping a vote on him is that it was almost too blatant a scum move. It wouldn't be a big loss to us to see him go either way though, his contributions have been minimal.
 
Johnny said:
Tfw you nail it.

Anyway, I'm more concerned on Superjolt's vote on ninjorf, and the fact that he didn't do his usual move and ask questions about me vs Klippy. Usually we would've gotten a lot of that.
Click to expand...

I honestly wasn't paying that much attention to that, but now that you mention it that's interesting. I'd like to hear more from him on that.
 
Johnny said:
Tfw you nail it.

Anyway, I'm more concerned on Superjolt's vote on ninjorf, and the fact that he didn't do his usual move and ask questions about me vs Klippy. Usually we would've gotten a lot of that.
Click to expand...
I'm not that concerned about the vote on Ninjorf since he was rather upfront about his suspicion of him. You're right that he did seem to avoid the Goku vs Johnny debate a little, so I agree with GP that it would be nice to hear from him about that, although I also think there are better lynch targets than him right now. I'm actually still not sure about Rabinov considering his stumble over his claim and lack of another kill last night. Wouldn't surprise me if he was cult claiming his old role.

Abby said:
poke
Click to expand...
That reminds me, Abby needs to say who she protected last night. They will be non-mafia.
 
jdthebud said:
Well to be fair they didn't know that Bard would die the same night...and I kind of understand though, it's fun being mafia. Fortunately for us Bard is dead now, and also fortunately Bastion didn't choose the Strongman, that would have been annoying to deal with. At least we have 2 real guns still floating around - Ana's and the one the GS handed out last night, assuming they did so. Sucks that you can't get one since you have a fabbed gun.

Anyway, I think McCree is probably not scum considering Goku threw shade on them, assuming they aren't cult or even Bastion, which is a possibility.

I think the current game state now is 2 mafia, 3 cult, and 7 town left. So we are doing ok right now, but that will change very quickly if we mislynch today and the next day.

What do you think about Tracer? He voted for you yesterday for some odd reason.
Click to expand...
I could kind of see an angle with scum!Klippy distancing from McCree? Actually, that feels too easy
Johnny said:
Tfw you nail it.

Anyway, I'm more concerned on Superjolt's vote on ninjorf, and the fact that he didn't do his usual move and ask questions about me vs Klippy. Usually we would've gotten a lot of that.
Click to expand...
To be fair, I was paying attention to you vs Klippy but was a little more focused on other things, I did go back to reread before the day ended and was getting a post ready with comments/questions but Nightkrow ended the day a few minutes before I finished. But some of the things I made note of are not really relevant anymore given Klippy's flip.

What do you think about jd and Ninjorf?

I want to hear McCree answer my question from D2 and why he didn't answer in the post he made before the day ended
 
Morning dogs & cats. Bummer that Sombra is back again but I'll definitely take the second coming of Sombra over the second coming of Widowmaker.

Superjolt, I'll answer your question from yesterday. Sorry for ignoring you. Yesterday was crazy.

Superjolt said:
@McCree: I expected you to vote Ninjorf again, what made you vote Rab over him?
Click to expand...

Right, while I still find Ninjorf a little suss (although, at this point its just due to inactivity), Rabi was becoming a liability to my survival in the game. I voted for Rabi to prove a point. He and I are not working together. That was before he claimed Soldier 76. I unvoted him following that.

I must say though, it's getting a little frustrating having so many inactive players. We are maybe six active players including myself, out of the 12 remaining players. :\
 
At a 7/2/3 split.

If we lynch a mafia it's 7/1/3. Assuming the mafia kills a townie & the cult recruits one, we're at 5/1/4.
If the cult recruits mafia it's 6/4. Both situations take us to MYLO.

If a townie is lynched, it'll be 6/2/3. This means 4/2/4 or 5/1/4, much like the previous situation.

Lynching a cult however, takes us to 7/2/2. This is favourable as it can go 5/2/3, 6,1,3 or 7/1/2.

Of course we can just hope the mafia will hit a cult tonight, but who can trust them?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top