PC Arcade [FINISHED]

Status
Not open for further replies.
This'll do for now, just wanted some Vestigo colours up at the top of the leaderboards.

Frogger - 15,580
Spoiler:


Asteroids - 20,580
Spoiler:


Simon - 19
Spoiler:


Donkey Kong - 24,750
Spoiler:


Regarding MAME emulation, personally I'd much prefer to play the original over the most poorly made Donkey Kong flash that must be floating around the internet, but even if the scoring works the same the game itself runs way, way differently. Ignoring the fact that the stages aren't even in the correct order, there's a huge issue with ladders where Mario won't line up with the ladder correctly (the first flame in 75m can even hit you from the opposite ladder if you don't climb down from the very edge of the platform), 50m is much harder to complete as instead of just reaching the top platform you have to perfectly time yourself on both a randomly switching conveyor and between DK's animation because his hitbox will change and cover the ladder up to Pauline (plus the pies don't even work), and 100m's flames will just jump over the small gaps in the platforms which they aren't supposed to be able to do. There's also a lot of little tricks like barrel manipulation, bouncing off walls, and spawning 100m's fires where they can't get you that are impossible to do in the flash game. Minor, but all together they're an unfair advantage for MAME players. I'd have much preferred to just use MAME, but considering it also has the ability to savestate it still wouldn't be fair if everyone was using it.
 
finally hit the 35k mark... This event's going to give me a ceaseless addiction to Asteroids now I'm sure...

[PokeCommunity.com] PC Arcade [FINISHED]
 
Spoiler:

Would you look at that!
 
There's also a lot of little tricks like barrel manipulation, bouncing off walls, and spawning 100m's fires where they can't get you that are impossible to do in the flash game. Minor, but all together they're an unfair advantage for MAME players.
The solution to that is 2 leaderboards, one for Flash players and one for MAME players.
 
Last edited:
Dunno if that'd be fair either. I can't imagine there being many MAME players, it'd be an easy way to score more points.
 
Regarding MAME emulation, personally I'd much prefer to play the original over the most poorly made Donkey Kong flash that must be floating around the internet, but even if the scoring works the same the game itself runs way, way differently. Ignoring the fact that the stages aren't even in the correct order, there's a huge issue with ladders where Mario won't line up with the ladder correctly (the first flame in 75m can even hit you from the opposite ladder if you don't climb down from the very edge of the platform), 50m is much harder to complete as instead of just reaching the top platform you have to perfectly time yourself on both a randomly switching conveyor and between DK's animation because his hitbox will change and cover the ladder up to Pauline (plus the pies don't even work), and 100m's flames will just jump over the small gaps in the platforms which they aren't supposed to be able to do. There's also a lot of little tricks like barrel manipulation, bouncing off walls, and spawning 100m's fires where they can't get you that are impossible to do in the flash game. Minor, but all together they're an unfair advantage for MAME players. I'd have much preferred to just use MAME, but considering it also has the ability to savestate it still wouldn't be fair if everyone was using it.

The solution to that is 2 leaderboards, one for Flash players and one for MAME players.

Dunno if that'd be fair either. I can't imagine there being many MAME players, it'd be an easy way to score more points.

So I think we'd be best sticking to the Flash versions of these games at the moment. Browser-based/Flash games have typically worked the best for these events because of user accessibility, and right now I think consistency would be best. I'll reconsider emulation and its place in this in the event for future incarnations. Thank you guys for bringing the topic to my attention! :)

(nice scores btw)
 
First High scores for me of the competition! Expect more to come hehe

Asteroids
Spoiler:


Simon
Spoiler:
 
Donkey Kong: I'll be taking the second third spot >:)
Spoiler:


Simon: Meh
Spoiler:


Asteroids: Got harder and harder
Spoiler:
 
Last edited:
So I think we'd be best sticking to the Flash versions of these games at the moment. Browser-based/Flash games have typically worked the best for these events because of user accessibility, and right now I think consistency would be best. I'll reconsider emulation and its place in this in the event for future incarnations.
I understand, good to hear that you'll reconsider emulation and its place in this in the event for future incarnations because emulation might be the only option after Flash is gone, Adobe kills Flash at the end of 2020 so there's only 3 years left.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top