Pie Mafia [Endgame]

Johnny said:
I'll buy it, for now.
Click to expand...
So ominous! Gonna be on my toes for the entire game, it seems! :P

I like Nina's claims on Altaria, even though I'm not sure that the jd theory (voting for him is a bad because he's obviously aligned with the town, being the GM) is as waterproof as people think it is. Maybe he could surprise us and his death could result in a pie machine going crazy and flooding the bakery with extra pies? Stranger things have happened...
 
Johnny said:
Your thoughts on Altaria are fair, but what exactly makes me suspicious? I'm concerned that you'd rather vote for Altaria than for Bard.
Click to expand...

Partly gut, partly like I said, you're not worried.

Even this response you don't seem that worried I'm suspicious of you then immediately trying to shift blame on to me for bucking the bandwagon, even though you just said my thoughts on Altaria are fair.
 
I wonder... I've been lowkey sussing Bard for a while so I'll ride this sort-of bandwagon. Johnny can't be maf at this point- that Twiggy lynch would have been an awful play for another maf. I also realy want to know what Abby knows because it's gotta be something, right?

[#VOTE] Bardothren
 
Ngl, lynching the GM seems to be a bad idea...

Other than that, I havent been following much on the reads, so I might read some later...

EDIT: 5,500th post, be grateful
 
Johnny said:
was the one to catch Twiggy and argued a strong case against him. Getting a mafioso lynched on day one should be enough proof of my innocence
Click to expand...

Getting a lynch day one is lucky Johnny. If you're inno there's nothing to go on. I would have been fine with an Altaria bandwagon, it's day one with no info.
I wasn't paying attention back then or I would have called you out that jumping on a bandwagon day one isn't honestly that sus, what the heck else are you supposed to do?
And how did they get sus and I didn't for that vote now that I look at it. You got lucky Johnny and got the pull of the day one "I have no idea I'll bandwagon the guy who is sus for bandwagoning."

Though I did actually miss it.
That would have been a pretty stupid mafia move, it's true. Hmmmm. Unless you're a third party serial killer type, than it would be a silly mafia move.
I'm still not changing my vote on Altaria though.
 
I was hoping Bard would defend himself somehow before the end of this phase (or, at least, before I go to bed). Alas, 'twas not to be.

[#Vote] Bardothren
 
;p I don't usually say "I killed them" if it was a group effort Johnny. You're being arrogant and acting like leading a lynch makes you a glorious warrior.
 
NIGHT 3


"Arg!" Jd cried, as he clumsily spilled his glass of water on the counter. "Darn it, the math textbook got all wet! Though why is it even open? I don't remember doing that." Jd inspected the textbook to see how bad the water damage was, and concluded that while it could be salvaged, he would have to take it home to dry it out as best as he could. As he carried the book away, the remaining group left on the counter looked on in dismay.

Bardothren was lynched. He was:
Spoiler:
PM or Discord message me your night actions! You have 24 hours.
​
Rules and Mechanics
  1. Each day phase will last 48 hours. Each night phase will last 24 hours. These times are approximate.
  2. Lynch votes must be written in the format of [#VOTE] Username. If you want to change your vote, you must use the format [#UNVOTE] Username. Not following this format will result in your vote not being counted.
  3. Votes for a no lynch are NOT allowed, but a tied lynch vote will result in a no lynch.
  4. Missing two consecutive lynch votes will result in your removal from the game, or a sub filling your spot if possible.
  5. Do not share PMs for any reason. If you do, you will be modkilled.
  6. You can't target yourself.
  7. The GM, jdthebud, is a valid target for lynching or targeting at night. Perhaps something special will happen?!?
  8. All important game conversation should be kept in the game thread, or in any chats provided by the GM.
  9. If you are dead, don't haunt the thread, and refrain from liking any posts. You do get to post a single "death post" that may not contain any game-related information.
  10. Posting in the night phase is not allowed, unless stated otherwise.
  11. If you have any questions, feel free to ask jdthebud, either by PM or on Discord (jdthebud#2509).
The Pie List

jdthebud as Jd the Baker, the GM

Aquacorde
gimmepie
Salzorrah
Mr Cat Dog
Seth Rollins
Nightkrow
Bidoof FTW
Johnny
Abby
Lucario
Altaria
TheCapsFan
Nina

Empty Pie Tins (dead players)​

Lycanthropy as a Whipped Cream Pie (Vanilla Townie) - killed Night 0
Alex Kaz as Pecan Pie (Vigilante) - killed Night 0
Twiggy as American Pie (Watcher) - lynched Day 1
TheCapsFan as Peach Pie (Oracle) - killed Night 1
Wiicked as Game Pie (Tracker) - lynched Day 2
Charlie Brown as Shepherd's Pie (Watcher) - killed Night 2
Lelouch as Coffee Pie (Alert Townie) - killed Night 2
Bardothren as π - lynched Day 3
​
 
DAY 4


Determined to avenge the loss of a comrade the previous day, the fungus crept into the pie racks and added a nasty concoction of its own design to a pie, with the goal of ensuring its demise. "I'm not eating this one, it can go to the dumpster in the morning!" the mushroom chuckled evilly to itself. After a little time had passed, another pie approached and tried its hardest to revive its fallen mate, but to no avail.

Yet another pie was swept into a mouth that screamed "GIMME PIE!" The face checked its Pie Clock hopefully, only to be frustrated again at what it showed. "Well, at least I'm still eating pie," it muttered as it rolled away into the shadows.

gimmepie was killed. He was:
Spoiler:
Nina was killed. She was:
Spoiler:
Day 4 will last for 48 hours, and ends about 12:00AM PST on Monday, December 5.
​
Rules and Mechanics
  1. Each day phase will last 48 hours. Each night phase will last 24 hours. These times are approximate.
  2. Lynch votes must be written in the format of [#VOTE] Username. If you want to change your vote, you must use the format [#UNVOTE] Username. Not following this format will result in your vote not being counted.
  3. Votes for a no lynch are NOT allowed, but a tied lynch vote will result in a no lynch.
  4. Missing two consecutive lynch votes will result in your removal from the game, or a sub filling your spot if possible.
  5. Do not share PMs for any reason. If you do, you will be modkilled.
  6. You can't target yourself.
  7. The GM, jdthebud, is a valid target for lynching or targeting at night. Perhaps something special will happen?!?
  8. All important game conversation should be kept in the game thread, or in any chats provided by the GM.
  9. If you are dead, don't haunt the thread, and refrain from liking any posts. You do get to post a single "death post" that may not contain any game-related information.
  10. Posting in the night phase is not allowed, unless stated otherwise.
  11. If you have any questions, feel free to ask jdthebud, either by PM or on Discord (jdthebud#2509).
The Pie List

jdthebud as Jd the Baker, the GM

Aquacorde
Salzorrah
Mr Cat Dog
Seth Rollins
Nightkrow
Bidoof FTW
Johnny
Abby
Lucario
Altaria

Empty Pie Tins (dead players)​

Lycanthropy as a Whipped Cream Pie (Vanilla Townie) - killed Night 0
Alex Kaz as Pecan Pie (Vigilante) - killed Night 0
Twiggy as American Pie (Watcher) - lynched Day 1
TheCapsFan as Peach Pie (Oracle) - killed Night 1
Wiicked as Game Pie (Tracker) - lynched Day 2
Charlie Brown as Shepherd's Pie (Watcher) - killed Night 2
Lelouch as Coffee Pie (Alert Townie) - killed Night 2
Bardothren as π - lynched Day 3
gimmepie as Doughnut Pie (Cop) - killed Night 3
Nina as Pumpkin Pie (Shadow Voter) - killed Night 3
​
 
Or maybe the doctor got roleblocked last night? Could there be another roleblocker? This sucks. RIP gimme and Nina.
 
Last edited:
It's only a theory, of course. Possibly the cheesecake? It's role description says it's "the most distracting and mouthwatering pie of them all".
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top