Pie Mafia [Endgame]

[NightKrow]

I could see Gunner being scum. I've also got a hunch that Altaria could be Gimmepie, as Nina called them out last phase, and now Nina is dead. Plus, Altaria and Lucario never replied to me last phase, which is kinda suss and also kinda rude tbh... #ignored

 

[Salzorrah]

Poison Pie targeted GP, most probably a one time use ability that ensures that the kill goes through, even though the doctor saved them. Doc wasnt blocked, Poison Pie did it.

Also I like how you're just writing it off as scum!gunner when I always do these things even as inno.

If you want my reads, Seth is def inno in my eyes, even though he's the first one who pointed at me. He's persistent, in such a way, that is almost naive. I don't think scum!Seth would try to pin the blame on me with something flimsy as my play style, especially if I turn out as inno.

I could see Johnny and probably NightKrow as scum, and trying to bw against me. I could see Johnny being Gimme Pie, but I don't have any leads on that, so it's mostly a gut feel. Johnny especially feels as if he's trying to restart the bandwagon against me, by following Seth's train of thought, and to me it's kinda shady...

Honestly Catdog and Anna seems to be inno in my eyes, but then again, Anna has already pulled the confused inno card before, so I'm slightly wary about her.

 

[Altaria]

Plus, Altaria and Lucario never replied to me last phase, which is kinda suss and also kinda rude tbh...

Lmao, sorry. I wasn't trying to be an asshole by not replying, I just didn't know if it was necessary to make another post saying the same thing that I already said; I truly have no idea who to vote for, and this is my first mafia, so maybe I'm just not good at reading yet; Cause some things that I find suspect people come back and say "Oh they're definitely innocent then" and vice versa.

And quite honestly not much has changed since the last day phase as far as my suspicion, aside from this:

Anna has already pulled the confused inno card before, so I'm slightly wary about her.

 

[Salzorrah]

Okay remove my reads right now, coz I literally only read the Day 1 posts just now, and I'm def clearing you now, coz you voted for Twiggy first when you noticed that he joined a random vote, and it wouldnt make sense for scum!Johnny for voting Twiggy, unless you plan to be risky af, which I highly doubt you do, but I'm still keeping my suss on NightKrow because of how he's acting towards you. If he was scum!NightKrow, he could be acting to stay on your good side, because most of his posts have been generally siding with you, and he knows you are a good player when it comes to mafia.

Okay so here's the deal these are the only people still alive:

Aquacorde
Salzorrah
Mr Cat Dog
Seth Rollins
Nightkrow
Bidoof FTW
Johnny
Abby
Lucario
Altaria

Here is the list of roles, bolded ones are still alive
Doughnut Pie - gimmepie
Apple Pie
Game Pie - Wiicked
Shepherd's Pie - Charlie Brown
Pecan Pie - Alex Kaz
Peach Pie - TheCapsFan
Cheesecake
Lemon Meringue Pie
Pumpkin Pie - Nina
Black Bottom Pie
Coffee Pie - Lelouch
Shaving Cream Pie
Whipped Cream Pie (2)
Whipped Cream Pie - Lycanthropy
Sushi Pie
π - Bardothren
American Pie - Twiggy
Poison Pie
Pie O'Clock!, a.k.a. "GIMME PIE"


Shaving Cream Pie is probably a miller type role, so there should be 3 Whipped Creams currently alive.

 

[NightKrow]

I could see Johnny and probably NightKrow as scum

Lmao what

[#Vote] Salzorrah
I wasn't even going to bw you straight away xD. I was waiting to hear from Altaria first, but I guess this just helps to confirm my suspicion on you.

Plus, I'd like to think scum!me wouldn't have pointed out what was wrong with Wiicked's wagon and just sheeped along like everyone else did...and why would I not side with Johnny when I'm 99% confident he's town? Johnny and GP were the only people to actually think about what I said about the Wiicked wagon, after all. And if I was scum, why would Bard suss me?

also Anna = Aquacorde right?

this:

So you're a bit suss of Anna then? Personally I don't think she's that scummy, but then she's also not a strong town read for me either. Welp, some thoughts are better than no thoughts, but that still doesn't clear all suspicion on you, especially with that Nina kill. Looks like you did it, but then I guess someone could be trying to frame you. Any opinion on Salzorrah at all?

 

[Altaria]

that still doesn't clear all suspicion on you, especially with that Nina kill. Looks like you did it, but then I guess someone could be trying to frame you. Any opinion on Salzorrah at all?

Honestly, an attempt to frame me was my thought too when you brought up the Nina kill. I had to go back and check to see what 'calling me out' you were referring to because I hadn't even seen that she'd voted me, although of course, who's going to believe that? However, if someone is in fact attempting to frame me, killing off someone who has voted to lynch me twice now is kind of an obvious way to go.

As for Salzorrah, I don't have any reads on them. It's DEFINITELY interesting to me that they saw Johnny as scum, but they took back that statement so idk what to think.

but I'm still keeping my suss on NightKrow because of how he's acting towards you. If he was scum!NightKrow, he could be acting to stay on your good side, because most of his posts have been generally siding with you

I mean yeah this is also pretty accurate because Johnny is giving inno vibes to quite a few people, myself included. It's really in any mafia's best interest to side with Johnny (if they're going to side at all) but I don't think that necessarily puts suss on NightKrow, either.

 

[Altaria]

On a side note: there's a term for what you're talking about, Lataria :p it's called "pocketing" when someone sides with a confirmed or most likely innocent, with hopes of getting townread back.

Ah, gotcha.

 

[Aquacorde]

anna's not playing confused inno this time anna was genuinely confused and kind of dumb right then lol

anyway im kind of iffy on gunner because shes been... not so talkative over all? and trying to pin my playstyle when she knows i wouldn't use that one again and i've been in like three completed games to date- hardly enough to give a consistent view of me! only one time did i run with confused inno and that was my v first game, where it worked. :P so gunner trying to redirect suspicion using that is questionable imo

 

[Altaria]

i've been in like three completed games to date- hardly enough to give a consistent view of me

Okay yeah that makes sense, I didn't realize you were almost as new as I am lmao. I should've done a bit more research on that before throwing that opinion out there, whoops

So with this.. and the fact that the more I go over their last few posts the more I just get some pretty weird vibes, I think I'm gonna go ahead and also [#Vote] Salzorrah.

 

[Lucario]

Gunner has been suspiciously silent, maybe they're trying to hide something or perhaps just not posting much idk

 

[Mr Cat Dog]

Catdog here seems legitimately confused about the mafia target on N0.

Here's Catdog again; even though I suspected him before because of this, I realize now he was just sticking to his guns, if he were mafia he could've just changed his vote in an attempt to look inno, but this somewhat proves his concern. He's clear in my eyes.

I could see Gunner being scum. I've also got a hunch that Altaria could be Gimmepie, as Nina called them out last phase, and now Nina is dead. Plus, Altaria and Lucario never replied to me last phase, which is kinda suss and also kinda rude tbh... #ignored

As soon as Nina was announced as night killed, my mind went to this theory. I probably wouldn't have done this if I were Gimmepie as it seems a bit obvious in its retaliation; I don't imagine a more seasoned mafia player doing it either if he/she were Gimmepie for the same reason. However, the fact that Altaria is very new at this (although, haha, I'm one to talk) gives it a bit more plausibility.

Poison Pie targeted GP, most probably a one time use ability that ensures that the kill goes through, even though the doctor saved them. Doc wasnt blocked, Poison Pie did it.

You sound very confident about this theory. Is it something that you've encountered in a game before? You're on my scum list at the moment because of the sudden burst of activity now compared to earlier (especially from what I've seen of you in previous games), so I would be happy to join the current bandwagon if no pertinent info arises.

 

[Abby]

Surprised I'm not scumread yet

 

[Aquacorde]

abby you're being just bizarre enough to be not scumread imo

[#Vote] Salzorrah

 

[jdthebud]

Seth Rollins is being replaced by Alex Kaz.

Do not discuss subs, please.

 

[Mr Cat Dog]

Surprised I'm not scumread yet

You're on my list also, don't you worry! :D

And welcome (back) Alex.

 

[Alex Kaz]

Hello friends, I am back. Well, kind of. It's not exactly me, as I came back from the dead and possessed poor Seth's body bwhahahaha!

-

I am Satan confirmed.

...I'll need to do some proper catching up, but as far as I know I am the bp, hit once and confirmed by the cop. Also Johnny and Nightkrow look pretty good right now, given I've been reading the game from the sidelines.

 

[Nina]

i'm gonna go and eat pie in heaven have fun guys

 

[Salzorrah]

You sound very confident about this theory. Is it something that you've encountered in a game before? You're on my scum list at the moment because of the sudden burst of activity now compared to earlier (especially from what I've seen of you in previous games), so I would be happy to join the current bandwagon if no pertinent info arises.

Obvious from the phase posts. GP should not have died because Doc was on them.

 

[jdthebud]

Current Day 4 Vote Count:

Salzorrah - 4 (Johnny, Altaria, NightKrow, Aquacorde)

Voteless: Salzorrah, Mr Cat Dog, Bidoof FTW, Abby, Lucario, Alex Kaz 2

Lucario and Salzorrah must vote today or they will be removed or subbed out. Please remember to use the correct format!

There are approximately 15 hours remaining in the phase.

-

Day 4 Vote Count #1

 

[Mr Cat Dog]

OK, so I had three hours of sleep last night, but I've done a 'Johnny' and read through this thread today to try and improve my reads. Here's what I've got:

Town: Johnny, NightKrow, Alex Kaz. If any of you guys are mafia, I tip my hat to you.
Town-leaning: Lucario. Genuinely think he's a bit confused and it's not an act.
Unsure: Altaria, Salzorrah. I kinda subscribe to NightKrow's theory about Altaria above, but also think it could be a very convenient frame job. I was all ready to jump on the Gunner bandwagon also, but her post today shifted my suspicions; her theory about gimmepie's death strikes me as logical, but given that no one else has mentioned it, makes me believe that she was aware of some element of it (i.e. being Poison Pie or the Doctor). That's why I'm not jumping on the wagon.
Evil-leaning: Aquacorde, Bidoof FTW. Mainly because their posts remind me of what Johnny accused me of earlier in the game: 'contributions without contributing'. I suspect one of these is Pie O'Clock.
Evil: Abby. I just don't get this strategy that you're using. I'll be thrilled to learn about it at the end of the game, but I do think it's some triple-ninjutsu reverse psychology, whatever you're doing. And for me, I'm not buying it.

[#VOTE] Abby