Piplup, Mudkip or Totodile?

[orangeralts21]

I'm not going to lie, I have only ever used Totodile twice in my Gen 2 gaming.



My vote goes to Mudkip because Gen 3 4 lyfe :P
I don't have a lot of Gen 4 Experience either

 

[aurevesque]

Piplup was a disappointment to me. As well as Empoleon.

I never really liked Totodile, although it is pretty intimidating.

I adore Mudkip and Swampert! They are just so cute, and I fell in love with that generation!

 

[Sheep]

TOTODILE without a doubt. Now if you put Squirtle here I'd be having a hard time choosing but Piplup and Mudkip aren't my favorites even if the 'lil penguin is pretty cute. Nothing compares to Toto. <3

 

[NKeros]

Mudkip is my answer, since I always like grd/wtr type because it can beat electric type easier than the other two imo.

 

[Hiatus]

It's got to be Mudkip for me, for sure. It's a Hoenn starter, so I'm a little biased on that (considering that it's one of my all-time favorite regions and whatnot), and it also evolves into Swampert in its final stage--a Pokémon that I absolutely love. It might look a little funky design-wise, which I'm personally not to bothered by, but competitively, it's simply great. It's a wall, and could stall your opponents indefinitely.

My second choice is Piplup. I'm personally not too fond of its evolution, but Piplup itself is amazingly adorable. If Pokémon had existed in real life, I would definitely consider having it as a pet.

 

[Entermaid]

Based SOLEY on their designs, not their evolutions, I prefer Mudkip.

Mudkip > Totodile> Piplup

Mudkip is just too cute. I mean look at this

 

[CJoE]

[color=ff0ff]Mudkip,mudkip!! He is really cute when he the first time i got him. And then he become so tough when he envolve into Swampert. And plus he is a dual type..that make him survive from water..[/color]

 

[Codename Peace]

Mudkip!
My favorite Water Type in Hoenn, of course, there is little water type in Hoenn, but.......

 

[obZen]

Totodile is one of my least favorite starters.
I'm going with Mudkip by a narrow margin
It's so adorable!
Funny, I like Dewott a lot more than Marshtomp, but I like Swampert more than Empoleon

 

[SparklingMistral]

Piplup! It's so adorable, ahhh~! I played through Platinum without evolving it ahaha.

 

[Hikamaru]

Of these three, I do love both the Piplup and Mudkip lines but my fave of these is pretty well Mudkip. It was my first ever starter, back when I played Ruby and I plan to use it again when OR/AS come out so I can relive the old days of that playthrough.

I pretty much do like the Water starters in general, given it is my fave type.