So here's the deal. Because of the increase of stealing on the server, I had to revert the world to a 1.7 state, which in the process removed anything 1.8 related (including monuments and stuff earned there.) Because of this action, I hypothesize that the server itself had to reset the item list because all inventory items are gone as well as any items you may have had in chests. However, the world itself - i.e. the town and any buildings you may have had - still stand tall and I believe that's the most important part here.
The server itself was on Vanilla before, which inadvertently does not support any plugins. What this means is that there would have been no way at any point to put in plugins that would have allowed users to protect their items and stuff from griefing and robbery. As such, I took the Beastnode staff's advice and used a Spigot model which on paper should have worked to support 1.8 - as legit, the world name of it is "Mod: 1.7.10 (Build #1647 - 1.8 Supported)" - but for some bizarre reason it only supported the plugins and not 1.8. Hence, the position we are currently in.
As stated, items have been lost. However, I strongly believe that the gains outweigh the losses here. Not only did we gain the ability to lock our chests from theft again, but I gained my admin powers back, which means I can replace every single item that you lost. I don't need legitimacy if you had the item, enchanted or not, I can and will replace them for you. Down below, please create a list of all the items you need and I will place them in a locked chest in your house. I will be providing this service for 2 weeks time until September 27th, so please let me know what you need and I'll get it for you.
For Lockette to work, all preexisting chests need to broken and then placed again with the sign on it. Any chests that you had and aren't replaced are not protected and thus can be subjected to griefing.
Before you ask, I'm not reverting the server back to the Vanilla version. Again, I believe the gains are seriously outweighing the losses here as everything can be replaced once more. I was tired of hearing about people getting robbed left and right and I wasn't going to wait for a plugin that may not ever come out considering the amount of plugins that I've viewed that have been abandoned and not patched for further versions. However, just to make absolutely sure this isn't fixable with the item loss, I have contacted Beastnode to see if this was a glitch in the system and it's possible to get everyone's items back (because on paper, this shouldn't have happened.) If you have any other questions or concerns please feel free to let me know.