4th Gen So, HeartGold, SoulSilver… whatcha getting?

[Ash&pikachuarethebest]

I am getting Heart Gold because I like Ho-oh plus it was the first one I bought of the 2nd gen games and I loved the game. Plus my mate is getting Soul Silver so I know there will be pokemon he can't get on Soul Silver but I can on Heart Gold.

 

[linkinpark187]

I'm probably going to get both. Should be fun. :D

 

[Teapot Turret]

Since me and my brother have Nintendo Dual-Screens, I'm getting SoulSilver, and he's getting HeartGold. Yet, he never catches Legendaries. Apparently, I need them for my Pokedex, so. >:-(

 

[Zidy]

HeartGold. I had both back in the day, but I played so much Gold, then I lost it. So, I'm really leaning toward HG.

 

[Kyo Wolf]

Soul Silver first because its the first second generation game I played, but I probably will get Heart Gold as well at some point to be able to get both Kyogre and Groudon, as well as Rayquaza.

 

[- Red -]

Soul Silver. I played the original Gam Boy Color pkm Silver, so, might as well get the newly re-made one.

 

[Palamon]

Both, so I can have the Pokemon that aren't available in Heart gold and the ones not available in Soul silver.

 

[Tanaki]

Silver won me over woth the initial launch of the 2 titles, and as such I will probably get silver, although I might pick up both eventually and a crystal version if it does come out.

 

[latios09]

Soul silver all the way!!!

Even though u can get lugia in both, Silver has Lugia on the cover. Lugia is OSM!!!

 

[nick99]

I'm going with heart gold. In the end it comes down to ho-oh over lugia.
It also seems that more people are getting silver so I wanna be different.
I might change my mind though. it depends what particular pokemon are in what versions.

 

[SugoiPanda]

I'ma go with Soul Silver since you are able to get lugia,
and i prefer lugia over ho-oh.

 

[NeonJellytot]

**********************************

Soo Many People Are Goin For Soul Silver!
One of my first games was gold version
so I'll proberbly get Heart Gold..anyone agree??
and plus me and my friend alwas get the opisite
to each other and shes getting Soul Silver

~Kate

**********************************

 

[poopnoodle]

I'll probably get Gold, since Silver was my first. That way I'll have both colors.

 

[mervyn797]

hear gold sounds cooler. but is silver better?

 

[PokemonBroski]

I'm going to get both but the first game I'll get is HeartGold since for some odd reason I have always like Gold more than Silver
Maybe because I want to get Ho-Oh first

 

[GoldCold Ice]

Soul Silver because I like water pokemon and silver is my 3rd fav colour

 

[KatouBot]

SoulSilver all the way! I like Lugia more than Ho-oh, and that tower always annoyed me anyway...

 

[Sarcastic Prince]

Heart Gold is whatcha gettin'. Gold pwns Silver.

 

[Rain]

I'm getting Heart Gold in English because I originally had Gold.
I will be getting Soul Silver in Japanese, because I know if I don't buy it, I will end up reading spoilers and I'd rather play through the game myself instead of reading spoilers.
There is no way that I can avoid Pokecommunity and Serebii for the next six months or so.

 

[Poison Master Tox]

Soul Silver. I hate gold, I only ever wear silver accessories. It's prettier.