• Ever thought it'd be cool to have your art, writing, or challenge runs featured on PokéCommunity? Click here for info - we'd love to spotlight your work!
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.

The Curse of Mt. Doom [GAMEOVER]

First of all, R.I.P Gunner. Secondly, I'm super confused about Coiny "switching hats" then leaving again. What's that supposed to mean? Like I get that their name is "Coiny Crossdresser" but how does switching hats benefit them at all? And I'm guessing that she can only do her action if whoever she targets doesn't use their night action, because of the "with nothing to do that night" line.
 
In the quiet of night, Coiny tiptoed from room to room. She found the person she was looking for sleeping soundly, with nothing to do that night. Creeping up to their target, the crossdressing pirate did the most peculiar thing - she switched their hats and wandered back off in to the night. How odd.

Ooo, it looks like we have a role switcher! I figure that makes sense with the Crossdressing gimmick; though it seems like the role they swapped for doesn't have an active NA. The "room to room" line makes it sound like Coiny visited multiple people as well. Hopefully all this means that Coiny knows someone inno or scum.

Gingerbeard and Limey Loud Shakes slept peacefully through the night, not leaving their quarters or being disturbed. Unfortunately, this wasn't all to the crew's advantage.

Sounds like some people didn't submit their NAs.

[PokeCommunity.com] The Curse of Mt. Doom [GAMEOVER]

But ... The "crew's advantage" thing makes me feel like this is lowkey incriminating either Limey or Gingerbeard. Else, why would it be considered an advantage for them to be idle? I suppose "advantage" refers to them being undisturbed, but this wording is odd.

A shadowy figure appeared before Lady Arvine. She knew it was only a matter of time, she was hoping to go down shouting during the day just to fire off her own killing shot. Unfortunately, the shadow cut her life short.

SHE WAS A HUNTER TRYING TO ACT SUSPECT TO SHOOT SOMEONE AGAIN

[PokeCommunity.com] The Curse of Mt. Doom [GAMEOVER]

As for the lynch on Caps ... I was gone for the rest of the day phase, so I didn't see any of his claims after that ... But for what it's worth, the rest of the players who voted for Caps also agreed with Kiyo, and I didn't see any of them change their votes after Caps "revealed" ... tbh I would say that Kiyo was the leader on the Caps lynch not me, but I'm leaning town on Kiyo, so I dunno what to think now.

This part is worded a little too defensively, don't you think? You haven't even given people a chance to go down your throat this phase yet; this kind of backtracking feels preemptive.

Though I can understand why, considering you must feel like Caps' inno flip incriminates the hell out of you. But just because this reaction is logical, does not free it from having a scummy texture. If you're keen on people believing you're innocent, just be an innocent player and scumhunt.

But I do feel like a scum player would try to throw all the guilt onto me; which you contemplated here but didn't go through with because you townread me. I'm not sold on reading you as town (since this play does make sense from a clever scum perspective), but I'm keen to give you a neutral reading for the time being.

I have a feeling he was a Bomb or something, which really sucks if that's the case.

His theme is seducing your subconscious, I think. I'm not getting the same notion, since he said he "found out" stuff when we nl.

If I had to vote for someone on the Caps wagon (me, Kiyo, Klippy, drewbie, and Wiz) I think it would be better to focus on those who joined the wagon later. Scum usually doesn't start a wagon, and before everyone joined in, it was still a no lynch.

Here, let's take a peek at the responses:

That's scummy, Caps.

ngl, we should try to go for Caps. :| It's not really sus to act lost, but get real dawg. I was gone too and managed to read a few pages.

"don't know what's going on" there is about a page of stuff... Also we NL'd yesterday so we might need to start making some moves here.

"I'm town" 20/10 best defense

I'm reeeeeally not all that confident in Klippy, since he sounds similar to how he spoke in BttB. But all in all, the worst of the responses is drewbie's. Though all of these are flavorless, don't provide anything reflective, and don't add further logic behind the decision to lynch Caps, drewbie's feels the most parrot-y and bland; drewbie's and Klippy's also feel like they have an element of theatricality, which I never trust in a mafia game.

Though, not as theatrical as this mess:

I'm with Kiyo. Time to make shit happen.

[Kill] Caps

Plus, Mana won't allow us to no-lynch again. Bad things will probably happen if we try that.

...of course, Caps could be softing a cop role... I think that's what he means by weeding out scum. If that's the case, then I am in favor of letting Caps have time to do some digging. So... I changed my mind.

[Kill] jdthebud under similar logic of going after Caps.

And we'll see if my theory holds true by the end of tonight, if Caps gets killed or not. If he survives the night without being targeted, then he should spill investigation results or more info.

The fuck is this? I can get behind having ideas and second thoughts when you set all your ideas down, but this is messy and a pure abuse of ellipses. This reads like a scum player trying to appear innocent and seeding a lynch for the next day.​
 

Kiyo muttered a bad word.

Coiny the Crossdresser fell dead!
She was a member of the crew.


Bardothren was revealed as
Swaggity McSwaggykins

Spoiler:
 
Silly gunner trying to death post
 
Everyone be dyin...

Shame we don't have any info on Swaggity, otherwise that reveal may have been useful.

Might be worth looking at Kiyo's reads, as he did hint to knowing some people's alignments. He seemed pretty set on Bard being scum (although I did agree with him in the end last phase soooo idk...) plus ellipses are great, I love to abuse them... ... ...
 
Lost whipped out a gun and shot at Klippy, the bullet hit a vest and he clambered away alive.

Spoiler:
 
Well that sucks, Kiyo was playing well for us. RIP bud.
Should we RNG the vote?
Why? You really have no scum reads? Even a minor one?
Silly gunner trying to death post
Hi there! Would you like to contribute something useful? Perhaps about someone still alive?
Everyone be dyin...

Shame we don't have any info on Swaggity, otherwise that reveal may have been useful.

Might be worth looking at Kiyo's reads, as he did hint to knowing some people's alignments. He seemed pretty set on Bard being scum (although I did agree with him in the end last phase soooo idk...) plus ellipses are great, I love to abuse them... ... ...
So, what do you think about Kiyo's other reads besides Bard?
Holy ****ing mother of god what is going on here?

Do we have any info on Bard? Maybe we could compile a list of all the pirate names we know so far?
Sure, besides the dead pirates, we have:

Professor Eiter - hooker/lover/drunk?
Loud Limey Shakes - BS? Tinkerer BS?
Cho Inselvecki - ??? avoided the Songstress for some reason
Pinkbeard - Santa/BS/GS?
Gingerbeard - ???
Swaggity McSwaggykins - Bardothren's latest ego boost? ;)

Anyway, Klippy was probably visited by Pinkbeard on N1, which is why he said they were a Santa/GS/BS yesterday, and why he had a vest.

One thing I don't understand is why Lost shot Klippy when Kiyo said he thought Klippy was town...wouldn't have been my first choice.
care to explain?
 
Pretty much off the top of my head rn (if I wasn't on mobile and on holiday doing stuff I'd be able to make some better reads, but hey,) I'd say Kiyo's other reads are weaker reads rather than outright accusations like in Bard's case, meaning they aren't things he knows for sure. I agree with his stance on you, jd - the part he quoted was worded very defensively for someone who hadn't even been challenged yet, but it seems like you've taken his advice since and started scumhunting, so personally I'd lean town on you. Drewbie has been acting lost quite a lot in this game, as well as being quite parroty or not offering much to the discussion, although that could just be down to inexperience. I'm not too sure about Klippy (but he wouldn't have been first on my "to shoot" list...an unclaimed gun as well, tsk tsk Lost...)

Also might be worth noting that Kiyo quoted Wiz, but then didn't say anything about him. Kiyo's more likely to talk about people he thinks are scum / being scummy, so perhaps this means he thinks Wiz is town? It's hard to tell who his strong townreads are as he's usually focused on scumhunting.

As an aside, I'm also scumreading Lost for whatever that shot was. Normally when you're town and you have a gun, when you want to use it you claim it and then the town can discuss who to shoot (or at least in my experience anyway.)
 
Drewbie has been acting lost quite a lot in this game, as well as being quite parroty or not offering much to the discussion, although that could just be down to inexperience.

Honestly, I really have been out of it lately. I've had some IRL stuff going on along with being sick so I haven't had too much time to read up on all of this and get some good reads. I apologize for being behind on everything, I'll do a quick catch-up in a bit ;)
 
Um why did lost shoot Klippy
 
One thing I don't understand is why Lost shot Klippy when Kiyo said he thought Klippy was town...wouldn't have been my first choice.

I shot Klippy precisely because Kiyo thought he was not town...
I'm reeeeeally not all that confident in Klippy, since he sounds similar to how he spoke in BttB.

I had a gun and figured that I might as well. I trusted his judgement and seeing as he had been target and died it seemed safe to do so.
 
I don't have a ton of time to give out insight and reads right now, but I put aside like 5 minutes to just scan through and get a few reads... So to me, Abby and Lost are my main scumreads, just because Lost didn't say that he had a gun and just YOLO shot at Klippy. You are really lucky he had a vest bud :/ Also, the only things I have heard from Abby are this:

Songstress sounds like some sort of siren to me:/ It fits with the boat theme too:/

I think we should call these bandwagons badwagons


Should we RNG the vote?

Just a bunch of filler. I wanna know what you think about everyone right now, what reads you have, anything that seems off, etc. Also, getting town from NightKrow.

For now, I'm gonna [Walk the Plank] Lost
 
Hi. Still moving, so still semi-inactive. Naughty Lost. I am most definitely town though.

[WALK THE PLANK] Lost
 
I'm also not active but last time JD voting to lynch caps and then saying Kiyo is the one leading bandwagon came to me quite scummy. I know it's not much reasoning but still I'll go with my gut...

[Walk the Plank]Jdthebud



And whoever gunsmith is...... gimme a gun next time plz xD
 
I shot Klippy precisely because Kiyo thought he was not town...
Wow, I totally misread that sentence there. It thought he meant that he wasn't confident in Klippy being scum. *facepalm*

Seems legit, although it would have been better to claim your gun first. Klippy still wouldn't have been my first choice.
And whoever gunsmith is...... gimme a gun next time plz xD
Why should you get a gun?

I'm neatral on the Lost BW, but I think there are more scummy players, namely, this gal:

[Walk the Plank] G-Cis Harmonia Gropius

She has no contributing posts. Wants to RNG the lynch on D3. What?
 
Okay I'm not that much of use. I've this feeling I'm going to die soon xD. I'm deputy. I was the one who killed ullion. I want gun so i can shoot through shadows c:
 
Back
Top