• Our friends from the Johto Times are hosting a favorite Pokémon poll - and we'd love for you to participate! Click here for information on how to vote for your favorites!
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

The Nightmare Before Christmasfia - THE END!

Nimsy jumping on everything looks a bit suspicious to me, though it's too early to say for sure.
 
Could you explain why I am in any way suspicious? All I've done is state facts and voice minor opinions. I don't think I'm the only one that believes you, Nimsy, are more suspicious than I.
 
@wiicked
That's how I play.

I'm usually quiet when I'm maf.

----
@spartacus
d1 you switched your vote onto johnny for no reason.
And kept it there, even though we were trying to get the boxtroll.
---
My list is broad, and a few people on there may be inno.
But I'm going with my gut.

My list in grandmafia was right.
But I have been known to be wrong.

I'm just putting my thoughts out there.
It's up to the rest of you to agree with me or not.
 
Last edited:
I'm inclined to not to believe that since then you'd just get yourself killed every time you're quiet, so there's gotta be a bit more to it than that I think.
 
I have the feeling Nimsy isn't mafia, I trust her on that.

however, I'm not sure how sound her theory on the suss list is. A lot of the people on the list just seemed to me like new players not very sure of what to say.
 
Probably.

-steel faked the carol and voted naku
-probably to throw him under the bus and appear inno.
-steel said they were both maf.
or
-Steel was trying to incriminate naku

Vote naku or follow my theory.
As long as we kill a mafia member, I'm happy.
---
True.
I may just be mixing up new players with being mafia, since they don't really have the feel for the game yet...

but.

Spartacus,Wizardman11 and TheCapsfan
Have been in quite a few games.
So I think they should have their bearings by now.

Childe of malkav has been a pretty good player in the few games I've seen them in.

The only really new person on my list is bobandbill.

So my theory stands.
 
Last edited:
If Steel Master really outed Naku last day, would that be considered game throwing and would the GMs intervene (ie. give Naku a different role)?
edit: by that I'm referring to the part where he just said "I'm mafia and so is Naku"
But on second thought I think we'd get some sort of notice if they did anything about it

And yes about Nimsy, she's always like that lol
 
I don't know why people still believe that Bard is the Caroler. He isn't.
 
The only thing I saw in the phase posts is that oogie isn't sending in his night actions.
And halloween town members jumped on the steel wagon.
But I think pretty much everyone voted steel.

----
And I can't believe it either tbh.
 
Bard please omg you're not the Caroler. You're James.
 
Sure.

But if you are telling the truth, the mafia will most likely kill you.

----
@naku
He might be james.
Like I said last phase:
He probably outed because krampus found him.
And krampus found james last phase post.

But that interaction may have been James roleblocking krampus.
So bard may have outed for a different reason.
 
Last edited:
That could work.

I feel like there might be one more possibility, however I think it is very unlikely. Cult might have started with two members and may have not disbanded. Caroler might steel be part of the cult and Bard is just moving the strings to divert the attention from themselves. Because, while Johnny could receive a carol tonight, we can't be sure it will be Bard who sent it.

but, idk. the more I think this through, the more far fetched it seems. still something to consider, I guess.

edit: nevermind
 
Last edited:
It's in the character list that carols will not work on people using their NA.

Probably to make the game a little more balanced since santa, the inquisitive elf and krampus have investigative roles.
 
Hmmm. So, since we are going to wait for the carol tonight, who are we going to lynch today?
 
[Kill] Nimsy From d1 I am behind her. Everyone trust me on this one . Because I have a solid proof but I have to role reveal myself . This time again. Either kill her or see if she is mafia or not . I know she is mafia for sure but in any case if she is not I gonna kill myself in next phase.
Or vote for me today and kill me , see who I am and then kill Nimsy . It is least I can do for inno.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top