The Wolf Among Us Mafia [Dawn Of The Ninth Day][GAME OVER!]

[Alex Kaz]

Posting this first cuz I'll forget it again if I won't.

Mirror, mirror, we're not sure who to choose.
Find for me Vivian, and give us more clues!

Kendy is on the same boat with jappo, in the sense that it's their first game. I called jappo on his low contribution because he said he's played mafia irl, so he probably has the hang of the game. Kendy looks kinda neutral to me, he looks neither scummy nor townie for the moment. Maybe that neutrality could be read as an underling's attitude, but judging from my first game here, he is just there trying to figure out what's going on.

I do not have a read on Lycan yet, as he hasn't posted a lot. Then again neither have many, and it's quite possible that mafias are blending in that inactivity.

 

[Juno]

Comes back after a few hours to the thread like

But the thing about the guns though,

Jersey Has the ability to choose from a knife or a gun to give to any player. The items he gives have a 30% chance of backfiring and a -20% chance of them succeeding. The items must be used within three days, or they will self-destruct, killing the holder.

Shoot them and you die, don't shoot them and you die - they're a death sentence either way, so I think our next mafia hunt should be on Jersey because these things are hard to get rid of (safely).

Kendy has been super, super agreeable, imo, and I hate that reading the Championships have influenced me to think this way, but I do feel like there's some merit to the argument that being too agreeable is a little scummy, because it seems like you're trying to make safe plays to follow the crowd and avoid drawing too much attention. It could just be because he's new though, and a nice guy, so I'm not too sure yet. :P

And with no CC to Johnny's claim, [Arrest] No one

 

[Zehn]

That's the problem, everyone is used to each other's actions but when new people come along no one and no-one knows what to do. Pretty sure it's not a Mafia game if I don't claim an important role early

 

[Superjolt]

Posting this first cuz I'll forget it again if I won't.

Mirror, mirror, we're not sure who to choose.
Find for me Vivian, and give us more clues!

Kendy is on the same boat with jappo, in the sense that it's their first game. I called jappo on his low contribution because he said he's played mafia irl, so he probably has the hang of the game. Kendy looks kinda neutral to me, he looks neither scummy nor townie for the moment. Maybe that neutrality could be read as an underling's attitude, but judging from my first game here, he is just there trying to figure out what's going on.

I do not have a read on Lycan yet, as he hasn't posted a lot. Then again neither have many, and it's quite possible that mafias are blending in that inactivity.

Ok I see now (I made my last post around mid-page 16, so hadn't seen jappo's other posts yet) and actually agree. I dislike how part of jappo's suspicions stem from people suspecting him, making them sort of OMGUS but it's probably not very alignment-indicative. Kendy's never played before? Thought he mentioned previous experience somewhere but might not be remembering correctly

As for Lycan I didn't really like either of his posts on the last page.

The first post (cut out the mirror riddle part):

Spoiler:

I don't think we can say a lot on Caps yet. He was either trying to help or pretending to try to help, it's hard to tell the difference here.

Johnny on the other hand, has had plenty of chances to copy-paste the riddle by now, but is acting pretty stubborn. Really suss. He could be Bloody Mary, but what are the odds? Besides, SKs are anti-maf as well and she has to be killed at some point.
[Lynch] JohnnyMustang

The first comment is a wishy-washy stance on Caps yet the wording kind of throws shade on Caps at the same time despite it being an "either way" stance. The reason for the Johnny vote sounds fake. (could be overthinking this though)

The second post:

Spoiler:

I was reading other threads, I hadn't even noticed your claim, sorry.

Weird thing about the role you claim is that it doesn't mention you can't out before Georgie and Vivian are dead, as is the case with most of the Underlings. (Could be a mistake or laziness, maybe?) Anyway, I'm inclined to believe you even while it's pretty easy to claim a miller.

[Arrest] No one for now
Here ya go, Johnny.

Throws a ton of doubt on Johhny's roleclaim before changing his vote to NL

I'm still not sure if I want to give Lycan a full scum-read for this though because part of me is saying I'm just really overthinking this and that I'm wrong. Part of it is also the lurking but Lycan always lurks so yeah. Your thoughts on this though?

 

[Zehn]

Kill him! Oh sorry just want some death today other than mine. sorry kendy

 

[Alex Kaz]

Ok I see now (I made my last post around mid-page 16, so hadn't seen jappo's other posts yet) and actually agree. I dislike how part of jappo's suspicions stem from people suspecting him, making them sort of OMGUS but it's probably not very alignment-indicative. Kendy's never played before? Thought he mentioned previous experience somewhere but might not be remembering correctly

As for Lycan I didn't really like either of his posts on the last page.

The first post (cut out the mirror riddle part):

Spoiler:

The first comment is a wishy-washy stance on Caps yet the wording kind of throws shade on Caps at the same time despite it being an "either way" stance. The reason for the Johnny vote sounds fake. (could be overthinking this though)

The second post:

Spoiler:

Throws a ton of doubt on Johhny's roleclaim before changing his vote to NL

I'm still not sure if I want to give Lycan a full scum-read for this though because part of me is saying I'm just really overthinking this and that I'm wrong. Part of it is also the lurking but Lycan always lurks so yeah. Your thoughts on this though?

Kendy hasn't played mafia again, he has only spectated us playing a couple of games on em. As I said, jappo is the one who's played again, but irl not on a forum.

Lycan has indeed been throwing doubt. He appears to be easily swayed around, changing his vote and hasn't tried to scumread.
But then again, that's not rare for an innocent who doesn't know what's going on, is it? Also, I don't remember Johnny being confirmed as a non mafia. Some of us townreading him does not clear him, as well us my suspicion on jappo doesn't make him a mafia.
So, as I said, I do not have a clear read on Lycan yet.

My turn now, Super. What are your thoughts on Klippy and Omicron?

 

[Superjolt]

1) Kendy hasn't played mafia again, he has only spectated us playing a couple of games on em. As I said, jappo is the one who's played again, but irl not on a forum.

Lycan has indeed been throwing doubt. He appears to be easily swayed around, changing his vote and hasn't tried to scumread.
2) But then again, that's not rare for an innocent who doesn't know what's going on, is it? 3) Also, I don't remember Johnny being confirmed as a non mafia. Some of us townreading him does not clear him, as well us my suspicion on jappo doesn't make him a mafia.
So, as I said, I do not have a clear read on Lycan yet.

4) My turn now, Super. What are your thoughts on Klippy and Omicron?

1) Ok, thanks for clarifying that
2) In general, a townie being unsure/having paranoia about being wrong about things isn't rare, if that's what you mean. In Lycan's case, it depends on how you read it - was he just looking for an excuse to jump on Johnny or did he (Lycan) believe what he (himself) was saying? I see it as the former but I'm not saying the latter is impossible. You even say in the next sentence that Johnny isn't confirmed as non-mafia, so do you think Lycan was too quick to jump off?
3) Never said Johnny was confirmed non-mafia. "Clearing" him just because others townread him would be a dumb reason. I do think I trust Johnny though, but not because others are trusting/townreading him. As for jappo, that's true, but I didn't suspect jappo just because you were too
4) I think I'm slightly leaning town on Klippy, nothing's really pinged me as scummy from him yet. He seems quieter than usual here but IIRC he dropped something earlier that could be a town-tell. No opinion on Omi, kind of forgot Omi was even here - I'll run through Omi's posts later

Thoughts on jd aside from his post you agreed with earlier?

also [Arrest] no one

 

[jappo]

Yeah, this is the game I play with friends of mine, and most of the time are a GM/moderator for:

https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/25821/werewolves-millers-hollow

kinda same, but yeah IRL and different terms for things.

So I know how the game works, but still, researching all the new terms and definitions. ;)

[Outofgame]Have to get up for work in 6 hours, so Ill check the situation on the town then {Outofgame]

 

[Syndrome]

Yo this phase ends in 3 hours and 24 minutes.

Update!

Update!

Update!

Update!

Update!

Update!

Update!

Update!

Update!

Update!

Update!

Update!

Update!

Update!

Update!

Update!

Update!

Update!

Update!

Update!

Update!

Update!

Update!

Update!

Update!

 

[TheCapsFan]

Oh my gosh Nani, I am so sorry, first for calling you a man and second for getting you killed... :( Bad mistake on my part.

I will be back before EOD to post my wallpost which I have queued up, but I right now I gotta go watch my sister's band concert. I got some splainin' to do.

 

[Cay]

[arrest] no one

what up slime

 

[Nakuzami]

Pretty sure I'm still voting for a dead person, so I'm going to go ahead and Kill Lycanthropy, based on the suspicions that have already been stated, as he seems a better target than anyone else right now.

Edit: Johnny . . . what? For one thing, it's possible that Bard did need to vote for nani to override it, just as Mana had to do as the Queen of Hearts in HNA. Secondly, Bard was the one being voted . . . so why would he save his override when he was on the chopping block?

 

[Omicron]

Lycan just acted the same way in Happily Never After and was the cop. I really don't get scumreads from him.

I'll [AREST]No one for today.

 

[Killua]

arrest no one

 

[TheCapsFan]

I'm back from the concert. It was...well, it actually wasn't too bad for a seventh grade band concert.

I'll start with a response to the following post, as it highlights several mistakes with my interactions with Nani:

Would seem like "solid reasoning," except Nani does this everywhere. Take FF Mafia, where she was town, and Mafia 102, where she was scum. Some of her posts from both games loosely resemble her posts in this game. If anything, her posts in this game resemble her town posts in FF Mafia more than they resemble her posts from Mafia 102. It's just that the only knowledge she has about TWAU came from the OP so, unlike FF Mafia, she didn't have any prior knowledge to go on.

I wasn't in FF Mafia, and Nani happened to be the person who shot me N0 in Mafia 102, so I didn't have a chance to play with her in that game. So, generally speaking, this was the first game in which I've played with Nani, and I felt that her overall demeanor seemed scummy. You can't blame me for thinking that she's scummy at first sight when she looks it. Also, I'd like to note that although you say that Nani "does this everywhere," Klippy says the opposite. Not sure whether to read him town or mafia after Nani's flip, though...Overall I feel like his demeanor reads protown.

General question to all: how does Omicron normally play? Are they one to go with the flow when they are town?

Next. I know it's obvious, but if any town players have any protective roles, vests, whatever that can protect Zehn from dying tonight, use it tonight.

Alright, now it's time to follow the yellow brick road to Wallpostopolis~

Spoiler:

[Arrest] Mew naniI've slight scum read on abby and kendypls. I'm not sure about kendy because he seems to be new and all but still...

Last night I was actually reading kendy as a town role based off a possible softclaim I saw, though I can't seem to pinpoint what it was right now...

You wouldn't happen to have a Phoenix down on you, would you...?

_{good job caps}

Again, berry, berry sorry Nani :(

I agree with Jd on Johnny and Caps. I'd also like to add that they've been bumping the thread when the mafia didn't need to, which earns extra town points in my mind.

I also wanna point out that mafia apparently can gather together their gold, and that they've spent it on a gun, which was used to kill Nani. I doubt a townie could afford a gun so soon.
That said, Georgie won't be protected for a good while, so the beast can find him and calm down.



Is this an attempt to guilt trip into another role reveal? You've been acting scummy and this post combined with your overall contribution to the game leads me to think you could be mafia.

If he's smart, he should be able to figure out what my role is alrea-tree...

What is up with the hostile attitude man? Are you trying to save a fellow bad guy? I am like the 9th person who voted for Johny, and I am the one who is acting scummy? Kinda weird behavior if you ask me.

Being the ninth person on a large wagon is not good, especially if the wagoned flips town. That's called blending in, my friend.

Also @everyone, is this guy a new player as well? His posts kind of seem like it, but if he's not he reads scummy to me.

Okay then, I know for a fact who are the mafia. I didn't want to reveal because that'd probably got me dead but since I know who are the mafia (some of them at least) I'd know if the mafia is leading a bandwagon, correct?

Well ****, I am Nerissa, I overhear **** going on at the pudding and pie, I can't disclose information until Georgie and Vivian are dead. If Georgie and Vivian are dead I win with town.

I started with a ribbon and I was taboo'd on d1, you can make a good guess of what was my taboo by now.

How much are you allowed to tell us?

Turns out there were less relevant quotes in the wallpost than I thought there were. Most of the ones I took out were pre-Naniflip, so they didn't real-lea(f) have any relative information.

Gonna poke around a bit and iso Lycan and Omicron before phase ends real quick. I can see why in this specific situation a no-lynch might be relatively kind of okay, though my feelings about no lynch overall still stand...

 

[Strange]

Again, berry, berry sorry Nani :(



If he's smart, he should be able to figure out what my role is alrea-tree...

Turns out there were less relevant quotes in the wallpost than I thought there were. Most of the ones I took out were pre-Naniflip, so they didn't real-lea(f) have any relative information.

Seeing the hints but not seeing the role that corresponds to them?

 

[Killua]

I'm back from the concert. It was...well, it actually wasn't too bad for a seventh grade band concert.

I'll start with a response to the following post, as it highlights several mistakes with my interactions with Nani:



I wasn't in FF Mafia, and Nani happened to be the person who shot me N0 in Mafia 102, so I didn't have a chance to play with her in that game. So, generally speaking, this was the first game in which I've played with Nani, and I felt that her overall demeanor seemed scummy. You can't blame me for thinking that she's scummy at first sight when she looks it. Also, I'd like to note that although you say that Nani "does this everywhere," Klippy says the opposite. Not sure whether to read him town or mafia after Nani's flip, though...Overall I feel like his demeanor reads protown.

General question to all: how does Omicron normally play? Are they one to go with the flow when they are town?

Next. I know it's obvious, but if any town players have any protective roles, vests, whatever that can protect Zehn from dying tonight, use it tonight.

Alright, now it's time to follow the yellow brick road to Wallpostopolis~

Spoiler:

Last night I was actually reading kendy as a town role based off a possible softclaim I saw, though I can't seem to pinpoint what it was right now...



Again, berry, berry sorry Nani :(



If he's smart, he should be able to figure out what my role is alrea-tree...



Being the ninth person on a large wagon is not good, especially if the wagoned flips town. That's called blending in, my friend.

Also @everyone, is this guy a new player as well? His posts kind of seem like it, but if he's not he reads scummy to me.



How much are you allowed to tell us?

Turns out there were less relevant quotes in the wallpost than I thought there were. Most of the ones I took out were pre-Naniflip, so they didn't real-lea(f) have any relative information.

Gonna poke around a bit and iso Lycan and Omicron before phase ends real quick. I can see why in this specific situation a no-lynch might be relatively kind of okay, though my feelings about no lynch overall still stand...

You shut up about mafia 102!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[Klippy]

CapsFan didn't really just claim Greenleaf, a Crooked Crew member, did he... That's legitimately the only "leaf" related role, is it not?

 

[Strange]

Maybe Holly? idk

 

[Juno]

Holly, maybe? The one that corresponds the most would be Aunty Greenleaf, but I don't think he would soft a mafia role, lol. I mean she can win with town, but I don't think his teammates would take too kindly to him outing like this for a chance to betray them if that's the case.

edit: ok well double-ninja'd