This or That! (Pokemon Edition)

[mishy.]

Rules are simple, first one asks "this" or "that" and next person answers and asks next one. Also tell us why you chose that one if you just can.

Example:

Poster 1: Cyndaquil or Charmander?
Poster 2: Cyndaquil because [insert reason here]. Bulbasaur or Chikorita?

And so on and so forth. You can do anything Pokemon related, such as Trainers, Items, etc etc.

To start off:

Cleffa or Igglybuff?

 

[classiccartoonsftw]

Cleffa, because of Magic Guard.

Pickup or Honey Gather?

 

[soulavenger]

Pickup because it provides us with more valuable things than Honey Gather.

Feebas or Magikarp?

 

[Megan]

Magikarp, because Gyarados (do I have to say anything more?)

Poke Ball or Park Ball?

 

[ShadowMirror]

Pokeball cause ya gotta keep it traditional


Celebi or Jirachi

 

[mishy.]

Ehh tough choice. I think I'll have to go with Jirachi though.

Muk or Garbordor.

 

[j_Woo]

Muk, because Garbodor's design makes me cringe...

Dragonite or Hydreigon?

 

[Dangelitus]

Dragonite, because its one of my two favorites pokemons.

Mew or Mewtwo?

 

[ShadowMirror]

New, it just is so epic


Contests or Musicals

 

[Level-X]

Contest, because you actually got to get an award from beating it. (A Ribbon)

Ash or Red

 

[j_Woo]

Red, because he's like Ash except with talent ;P

Hoenn or Unova?

 

[Munchlax11]

Hoenn because of the awesome legends. Groudon is a beast.
Gen 1 starters or Gen 2 starters? (overall)

 

[Level-X]

Generation 1 Starters, because they are the original three and will always remain very close to me. :)

Cubchoo or Spheal?

 

[j_Woo]

Cubchoo, it's like an ice type teddiursa :3

Brock or Roark?

 

[ShadowMirror]

Brock all the way, sad he left the series


Moomoomilk or Casteliacones

 

[Wyverneon]

MoomooMilk, because in the anime they could make many dairy products including Icecream too

Lum Berry or Sitrus Berry ?

 

[ShadowMirror]

Sitrus Berry, always thought it sounded tastier



Chimchar or also Chimchar

Just kidding

Berries or Poffins

 

[Tyrael]

Berries. Never really played a Gen IV game so no idea what poffins do :D

Conkeldurr or Machamp?

 

[j_Woo]

Conkeldurr, just because of his derpy name xD

Jirachi or Mew?

 

[Tyrael]

Mew, the original unobtainable Pokemon :3

Single or Dual typed Pokemon?