4th Gen Which Starter?

[heavenschaos1950]

Totodile....but for many reasons...adn don't kill me cuz of them: 1) He's a water pekemon and I love water pokemon. 2) he's the best choice of the three. 3) he's the first pokemon I chose when I played silver for teh first time =)

 

[Hardy Har Har]

For me, I'll choose Cyndaquil on both HeartGold and SoulSilver.
Cyndaquil is so cute, that's why.

 

[jackowacko876]

I would pick Totodile. I always pick water-types (except Turtwig).

 

[Chaos Feraligatr]

totodile all the way ^_^ i just love that little energetic alligator

 

[Ársa]

I've always picked the Grass starter in my first run through of EVERY game. I won't be changing anytime soon .

 

[jmadude]

I'll start Heart Gold with Cyndaquil and in Soul Silver I'll start with Chikorita since I already got a Totodile in pokemon Emerald

 

[JeTz]

Chikorita~~~~~~~~

Cant wait til the released of these version in my country?

I missed the johto region.

The 3 awesome HedgeDogs!

 

[the bitter end.]

I'm going to start with Cyndaquil, he was my favorite in the original G/S/C and still is really.

 

[Lukar]

In the originals, I always started with Cyndaquil, but I'm gonna start with my new favorite- Totodile. ^^ If I can also get HeartGold, then I'll get Cyndaquil in HG.

 

[hank jones]

Totodile!!! Hands down, no competition, totodile is by far my favorite!

 

[Chris The Nerd]

Cyndaquil, because my cousin is getting Chikorita. aslo, Cyndaquil was my starter

 

[iTzKaizer]

Totodile, Cyndaquil, Chimchar, Treecko, Charmander *cough*Mudkipz*cough* are my favourite starters, and I think I'll chose Cyndaquil first. Specially because Typhlosion has ERUPTION as lv 57!!!!

 

[Kesey]

Totidile he is well the best.

 

[Cid]

I'd be getting Chikorita from HeartGold.

I had him on my first Pokemon game, Pokemon Gold.
Good times.

 

[ghostofherooftime]

cyndaquil... there is no other choice

 

[Volkner's Apprentice]

I get Totodile, my friend gets Cyndaquil. Then, we duel. XD Water Gun!...I win!

 

[Forci Stikane]

Once again, I am going to fall back to my default option:

All of the above.

 

[Finnel]

Chikorita.
... Or Totodile.

I guess I'll get both games and pick Chikorita on one, Totodile on the other.
I'm not a huge fan of Cyndaquil and its' evolutions.

 

[Coma-san]

Totodile.
It was my Silver starter, and it shall be my SoulSilver starter too.

Besides, no matter what anyone says, a blue anthropomorphic crocodile pwns a fiery hedgehog and a green... thing... any day of the week.

 

[Sneaky Panda]

I honestly have no clue. I'm playing through Shiny Gold Beta 5 on my micro with cyndaquil, last time I played through gold was with totodile, and before that, shiny gold beta 4 was played with chikorita. Cyndadquil is my favorite of the bunch, but I don't want to play through it again with one. One would then say go with chikorita, but I really hate its evolutions other than bayleaf :D. So it looks like totdile?