• Our software update is now concluded. You will need to reset your password to log in. In order to do this, you will have to click "Log in" in the top right corner and then "Forgot your password?".
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

4th Gen A G/S Remake?

Status
Not open for further replies.

PB.

'PB
923
Posts
17
Years
    • Seen Mar 2, 2011
    I thought i would revieve this as the last one was closed.

    To answer the question, I would like a remake because it was a great game with an exciting plot and lots of great pokemon. But I'm guessing it would have little problems such as wheter they should include new evoulotions that are there now, Such as Ambipom.
     

    BDT

    On my way to be a MASTER
    230
    Posts
    16
    Years
    • The only reason the did the remake of Red/Green to the GBA becasue they must have planned it out back then that Diamond and Pearl on Nintendo DS could use GBA games and take Pokemon from Pal Park with Ruby/Sapphire FireRed/LeagGreen and Emerald. So what would the point of remake of Gold and Silver? It would be cool yes..but we just have to wait and see. I would like more info of Game 3 on Gen 4 cos' will this be the last game or are they going to do more like Gen 5 Pokemon??
     

    BakingBluePotatoe

    The Red Death Alchemist
    2,281
    Posts
    16
    Years
    • they will make it. I know they will. They have the Location Data- just like they had Kanto Data on R/S.

    Trust me, it WILL be done!
     

    Twinx

    s o m e t h i n g M O R E
    1,802
    Posts
    17
    Years
    • Perry! are you gonna keep reviving this topic until the remake is released? hehe

    I agree with ~KiTsUnE.
    They don't need to have a reason to do it.. It's nintendo :P
    Do they have a reason to make two version of the same game? (Diamond/Pearl) NO
    Do we need a third game that has useless extras? NO

    Yet, nintendo does it :D
    REMAKE=More $$ :P:P
     

    BakingBluePotatoe

    The Red Death Alchemist
    2,281
    Posts
    16
    Years
    • acctually, I think they did it to force you to either spend a lot of money, or Socialize with other people...

    Game 3, I dunno.......


    but yeah, DC, you have a point.
     

    Jim

    Dinner
    1,211
    Posts
    17
    Years
    • Age 30
    • Seen Dec 25, 2011
    Yes, a remake would not be needed, but who can really say that they would hate a remake if it was announced tommorow.

    Generation II is the best out of all four (in my honest opinion ._.). Now imagine strolling through Johto (and an extremely disfigured Kanto) with DS graphics and mechanics.

    I hope Kanto is a bit less... Dead. I mean it's fair enough that the Safari zone is closed, I accept that. What I DO NOT like is how short Rock Tunnel and Mt Moon were (Although I loved Mt Moon square) and I also despised how Viridian Forest was gone.
     

    Twinx

    s o m e t h i n g M O R E
    1,802
    Posts
    17
    Years
    • lol, what was up with the lvl 3 pikachu's near virdian city?
    I'm not really that excited about seeing kanto again :P
     

    BDT

    On my way to be a MASTER
    230
    Posts
    16
    Years
    • ~KiTsUnE said:
    they will make it. I know they will. They have the Location Data- just like they had Kanto Data on R/S.

    Trust me, it WILL be done!
    Click to expand...

    I hope your right hehe

    DarkkChildd said:
    Perry! are you gonna keep reviving this topic until the remake is released? hehe

    I agree with ~KiTsUnE.
    They don't need to have a reason to do it.. It's nintendo :P
    Do they have a reason to make two version of the same game? (Diamond/Pearl) NO
    Do we need a third game that has useless extras? NO

    Yet, nintendo does it :D
    REMAKE=More $$ :P:P
    Click to expand...

    Here my answers =

    Do they have a reason to make two version of the same game? (Diamond/Pearl) YES Why do have Different Pokemon in each game as they have done from Red and Blue to make you trade, for Diamond and Perl Exclusives, makes sense

    Do we need a third game that has useless extras? Just for people who are new to the game when thats released like with Yellow/Crystal and Emerald
     

    Twinx

    s o m e t h i n g M O R E
    1,802
    Posts
    17
    Years
    • Do we need version exclusives? NO
    It's a marketing technique Nintendo uses to gain more $$$$.
    That's what our world is about, unfortunately.
     
    icycatelf

    icycatelf

    Alex
    3,559
    Posts
    19
    Years
    • According to PokeBeach, a Beckett (I think) magazine said something about the release of Pokemon Platinum. Since it's an unofficial source, who knows if it's really true? They also don't know if it will be the Y/C/E of D/P or G/S remake... or another game entirey (hopefully not). Platinum is a metal, so it very likely could be a G/S remake, but it's odd how it's just 1 game (they normally come in twos).
     
    Last edited:
    Percy Thrillington

    Percy Thrillington

    The Mad Hatter
    4,425
    Posts
    16
    Years
    • Seen Jan 1, 2023
    I thought i would revieve this as the last one was closed.

    To answer the question, I would like a remake because it was a great game with an exciting plot and lots of great pokemon. But I'm guessing it would have little problems such as wheter they should include new evoulotions that are there now, Such as Ambipom.
    Click to expand...
    It probably would, but Nintendo won't make one, sorry.

    The only reason the did the remake of Red/Green to the GBA becasue they must have planned it out back then that Diamond and Pearl on Nintendo DS could use GBA games and take Pokemon from Pal Park with Ruby/Sapphire FireRed/LeagGreen and Emerald. So what would the point of remake of Gold and Silver? It would be cool yes..but we just have to wait and see. I would like more info of Game 3 on Gen 4 cos' will this be the last game or are they going to do more like Gen 5 Pokemon??
    Click to expand...
    Well, that's the question in'it? They'll make a Yellow/Crystal/Emerald version of Diamond and Pearl, most likely called Quartz, and then they will move onto fifth generation, and a remake will never happen for G/S/C.

    they will make it. I know they will. They have the Location Data- just like they had Kanto Data on R/S.

    Trust me, it WILL be done!
    Click to expand...
    No.

    Perry! are you gonna keep reviving this topic until the remake is released? hehe

    I agree with ~KiTsUnE.
    They don't need to have a reason to do it.. It's nintendo :P
    Do they have a reason to make two version of the same game? (Diamond/Pearl) NO
    Do we need a third game that has useless extras?     NO

    Yet, nintendo does it :D
    REMAKE=More $$ :P:P
    Click to expand...


    Nice, logical post... If only Nintendo were nice and logical.

    Yes, a remake would not be needed, but who can really say that they would hate a remake if it was announced tommorow.

    Generation II is the best out of all four (in my honest opinion ._.). Now imagine strolling through Johto (and an extremely disfigured Kanto) with DS graphics and mechanics.

    I hope Kanto is a bit less... Dead. I mean it's fair enough that the Safari zone is closed, I accept that. What I DO NOT like is how short Rock Tunnel and Mt Moon were (Although I loved Mt Moon square) and I also despised how Viridian Forest was gone.
    Click to expand...
    I concur, if only Nintendo did too.

    Do we need version exclusives? NO
    It's a marketing technique Nintendo uses to gain more $$$$.
    That's what our world is about, unfortunately.
    Click to expand...


    Amen.

    According to PokeBeach, a Beckett (I think) magazine said something about the release of Pokemon Platinum. Since it's an unofficial source, who knows if it's really true? They also don't know if it will be the Y/C/E of D/P or G/S remake... or another game entirey (hopefully not). Platinum is a metal, so it very likely could be a G/S remake, but it's odd how it's just 1 game (they normally come in twos).
    Click to expand...
    Lies, all lies.

    Until Nintendo release an offical document, nothing is proven.
     
    Jayster23

    Jayster23

    1,244
    Posts
    16
    Years
    • I hope they will make G/S remake it would be totally awesome i just want to start with Cyndaquil again without getting all 200 in Emerald
     

    BakingBluePotatoe

    The Red Death Alchemist
    2,281
    Posts
    16
    Years
    • what Pichuu, said.

    I'm still going with my statement from eirlier:

    Back in R/S they had Kanto data, right? and they remade Kanto!

    and now it's D/P that has hidden data with another region.

    do you see the pattern?
     

    Olumuyiwa

    Ultimate Trainer
    62
    Posts
    16
    Years
    • ~KiTsUnE said:
    what Pichuu, said.

    I'm still going with my statement from eirlier:

    Back in R/S they had Kanto data, right? and they remade Kanto!

    and now it's D/P that has hidden data with another region.

    do you see the pattern?
    Click to expand...

    Have you ever thought Nintendo did that just for us to expect something and nothing will come out of it in the end
    --Olu
     

    Evan

    Check out my Hatchery!
    71
    Posts
    17
    Years
    • Because Nintendo lives to get our hopes up and then crush them...

    Perry! said:
    I thought i would revieve this as the last one was closed.

    To answer the question, I would like a remake because it was a great game with an exciting plot and lots of great pokemon. But I'm guessing it would have little problems such as wheter they should include new evoulotions that are there now, Such as Ambipom.
    Click to expand...

    I'd assume that they would do the same kinda thing they did with the new evolutions for the Kanto remakes, not have them initially, but have them once the National Pokedex is unlocked.
     
    Last edited:

    XSeerian

    My name is actually Drenz!
    29
    Posts
    16
    Years
    • Well, according to Wikipedia/Bulbapedia, many other nonofficial sources and ~KiTsUnE's amazing statement:

    They have put Johto data in the D/P games and I've tried(as I bet many other have) to put my Pokemon Crystal in my DS, but it doesn't fit. So...less we just imagine they put Johto in there to be caca, there has to be something being cooked up.

    Not only that...there are so many clues to support it within Diamond and Pearl.

    Why was Jasmine necessary? She gave us Waterfall...why? So she can make an appearence, that's why! And she tells you, you should visit her Region someday.

    Not only that, they speak of Professor Elm a lot, when it comes to Egg research.

    Then a big clue in my eyes, is the readdition of the Day/Night system.

    There are so many clues to support it and make this little dream become a reality. I think we may have to start believing Johto will be remade with D/P graphics! ^_^

    ~ Drenz
     

    Legendary

    49
    Posts
    18
    Years
    • Seen Dec 13, 2013
    Oni Raichu said:
    It probably would, but Nintendo won't make one, sorry.
    Click to expand...

    And you know this how?

    Well, that's the question in'it? They'll make a Yellow/Crystal/Emerald version of Diamond and Pearl, most likely called Quartz, and then they will move onto fifth generation, and a remake will never happen for G/S/C.
    Click to expand...

    Doubtful. The remake could end up being just another way to get the Pokemon not on the Dex of Diamond/Pearl. If someone jumps in, and wants to catch all their own Pokemon, but doesn't have access to Gen 3, then GSDS would supply a good number of those Pokemon.

    No.
    Click to expand...

    That's a GREAT response. Someone points out that Nintendo has VERY clearly included data that points to a remake and has no reason to be there UNLESS a remake is planned, and your only response is no.

    Nice, logical post... If only Nintendo were nice and logical.
    Click to expand...

    When it comes to milking cash cows, they don't seem to be amateurs.

    I concur, if only Nintendo did too.
    Click to expand...

    I'm also in agreement.
     
    Status
    Not open for further replies.
    Back
    Top