Battle for Gotham - Game Over!

Oh hey, it's finally over! Like Glendle, this was my first game on here (and my first game as mafia, at that), so it's nice to see it come to a close with a win for my faction. :)

Overall I thought our biggest advantage on the Mafia side was that we all worked surprisingly well together.

the feeling when you technically won, but you died n0, came back as a different role, died again, and not sure if you are counted among the winners :x

eh, im still gonna count it :)

GOOD JOB DEFENDERS, I KNEW I COULD TRUST YOU (inb4 i actually switched sides and targeted you lmao)

jdthebud said:

Syn, did you figure out I was Nightwing?

Mana, what did the Walrus do?

Click to expand...

No, but it wasn't very hard to figure out who was a defender near the endgame.

Also, I wonder if my last gun really could have killed Bard. IIRC it killed anyone I shot at.

It could break vests but wouldn't kill any immortals

Batdoof and Rozuraider would get a power everytime they were hit. Since you guys kept hitting bard he got the powers and I just stayed in the shadows so we could survive I guess :')

I'll be showing all role PM's later in the next post, but any player can choose to show the role PM while y'all wait :P

Well jd that was well played, i had completely forgotten about night-wing and was surprised no one caught that
Good job mafia you scummy schmucks won

What? You want a cookie?

Nakuzami said:

I stopped keeping up with this game when I was removed and could no longer see it, obviously, but in the end, it turned out quite interesting. A victory is a victory. It would have been a swifter one had I not been removed, but I heard that d00f used my Killer Moth idea <3 who would have thought that a bidoof would ever make me proud

Click to expand...

I'm not so sure about that haha, because even if you hadn't been removed, I had connected the dots at that point when I saw you had gotten napalm on N2 so I knew you were the one that was protected by Poison Ivy that night. So even if you had remained in the game, I would have fought hard for your lynch :P

It's also interesting because I was prepared to lynch Spartacus the day after the carol contest, and my preferred lynch targets after that would have been Fun Size, GlendleYoung, Shak/Archy and then probably jd (though I was still trying to sort jd out around the time I died). It was surprising enough to become part of the Doof cult for winning the carol contest, but what I really wasn't expecting was to die when I used the rocket lol, all because of Shak taking the hit for Klippy :( But hey, I decimated the Owls (killed the last recruit and made Archy start bleeding) and brought the WLG down to 2 members and caused a Defender to bleed so I guess it was worth it lol.

Speaking of that though, I was surprised Bard didn't try to push a lynch on someone else besides Juno, because I thought he knew Juno was already bleeding and would have died anyway

Well played by the Defenders though. Never expected GB to be Batman, this will probably make me paranoid about him in future games lol

I noticed. Somehow I still got notifs from the UG when it was closed off to me.

But, trust me lol, I was fully prepared for someone to finally point something like that out. I was honestly surprised it didn't happen sooner. Y'all are slow.

It wouldn't have been a hard situation to talk myself out of. I've gotten out of much worse, and your response was one I had been anticipating. I was never worried.

So, yes, it would have been a swifter victory, of that I have no doubt whatsoever, lol.

Being Dr. Kirk was fun. I'm glad I chose the right side to stick to! Woo Defenders!

I really liked this game, well done everyone!

You missed Klippy forgetting how to count to 4 Defenders

I hadn't been paying attention to the number of enemies. I was also presuming the game would continue for a bit longer. :'(

This is probably the longest mafia game I've ever been in, in terms of real time.

That last day, not that it ended up mattering, it was obvious that GB was lying. There were 2 confirmed doofs left, 2 confirmed WG left (oysters in the phase posts), and 4 Defenders, since 3 Defenders were mentioned in the post + Nightwing (who announced they were alive once Draskk died). Once Johnny and desishinon were confirmed Rogue, the remaining 8 people + Syn were all that was left. No more room for Rogue roles.

Your only hope was to lynch GB that day since even Syn's gun wouldn't have killed him. Batman couldn't get killed by items. :D