Map Rating/Review Thread

it is too small to be new bark!
7/10
besides the size it's a pretty good remake!

~element said:

it is too small to be new bark!
7/10
besides the size it's a pretty good remake!

Click to expand...

Yeah, I mean premade, but okay.

The original maps from Nintendo/Gamefreak are so.. boring..
I think Gamefreak is to lazy to put a few extra trees on the map, xD

That is a nice re-make of New Bark Town! :D

Rating: 9.1/10
Errors: Absolutely none! :D
Comments: Nice

UltramasterBDX said:

Hey

Here is my NEW BARK TOWN remake ^^"

I used FR/EM Tiles ~ colors by me!

Note: Its a premade Map, not a remake from the original!


Greetz from germany!

Click to expand...

well, the first thing that caught my attention is the house. for me it looks like a little building or a warehouse because of its roof, but if you dont mind the house the map looks very peaceful, the vegetation is placed well so i'll give ur map an 8/10

Here's a little village I made.
Rom: Firered


'

Austinia said:

Spoiler:

I made this map a few days ago :D please rate and give suggestions.

Click to expand...

cool tiles, did you insert them yourself or is there a rombase?
if not you could think of making one
map rating: 9/10
beautiful placement of trees, awesome tiles and palettes, variety in the streets and house placement
the only thing i dont like is that all houses use the same tiles

edit: since most mappers read this thread it might be good to post it here as well:
my Frozen RomBase is finally Released
Check it out here: https://www.pokecommunity.com/showpost.php?p=3896185&postcount=110#frozen

Hi there!

Here is my new improved ROUTE 29 ;3
I hope you like it:



Note: This is a premade map - not a remake.

Woo Hoo! A Town done with Neti's base already!

Map Name: Unknown at this point
Credits: Neti for the Base, Me for mapping it xP
Map Shot:

oww uhhh im dribbling its so good i love the cliff placement very good i give it a smashing 10/10
well done!!!

UltramasterBDX said:

Hi there!

Here is my new improved ROUTE 29 ;3
I hope you like it:

Note: This is a premade map - not a remake.

Click to expand...

Rating: 9.5/10
Reason: I love the map. It's so simple yet so nice. I like the simplicity in the map. No more I can say.

Xray said:

Woo Hoo! A Town done with Neti's base already!

Map Name: Unknown at this point
Credits: Neti for the Base, Me for mapping it xP
Map Shot:

Click to expand...

Rating: 9.5/10
Reason: OMG another good map XD. I love it. Especially the way you placed the mountain tiles and the trees. Everything looks so gorgeous XD. It's really nice.
Suggestions: Nothing.

Well, here is a sort of another Map ;3



I call it WEST BARK TOWN, because it's like NEW BARK TOWN, xD

UltramasterBDX said:

Well, here is a sort of another Map ;3

I call it WEST BARK TOWN, because it's like NEW BARK TOWN, xD

Click to expand...

Nice map. The only tile error I see are the windows on the houses other than that its fine. Perfect amount of room, however, I would put the big trees as the surrounding trees, but thats just me!
9/10

I like how you put the Tree's on the houses, it makes them look 10 times better ;)

8.7/10!

Neti said:

cool tiles, did you insert them yourself or is there a rombase?
if not you could think of making one
map rating: 9/10
beautiful placement of trees, awesome tiles and palettes, variety in the streets and house placement
the only thing i dont like is that all houses use the same tiles

edit: since most mappers read this thread it might be good to post it here as well:
my Frozen RomBase is finally Released
Check it out here: https://www.pokecommunity.com/showpost.php?p=3896185&postcount=110#frozen

Click to expand...

Its not a base, I inserted them myself. :p I'm not sure how to make a rombase, but maybe :p lol. And thanks for the suggestions. I'm not sure which other tiles would look nice. Theres not really any houses... theres gonna be a subway underground in one of the buildings so people can travel for work there everyday... lol... anyways, yea. Thanks ^^

I have a map to get rated.
here it is.


Xray told me to make a map like colco_styles and this is what i came up with.
i will post the other maps that were only rated ONCE soon, and i will rate A map soon.

EDIT:

tell me if you can't see it.


Whoops, forgot to credit.
credits to PHO, Xray, and xiderwong for the forest tiles and credits to ryousha and wind for the palettes and tiles(the snow one).

makunouchi said:

I have a map to get rated.
here it is.


Xray told me to make a map like colco_styles and this is what i came up with.
i will post the other maps that were only rated ONCE soon, and i will rate A map soon.

EDIT:

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

tell me if you can't see it.

Click to expand...

Rating: 9/10
Reason: It's a great map. I like the way you've placed the mountain tiles and trees, the paths and well everything. The little pond with the little waterfall looks nice. But I don't like the little cave entrance there. And a nice variation of trees. Nice work!
Suggestions: Remove the cave entrance there..

EDIT
Only first map XD

Thanks for the rating and sorry for the message, i didn't think you would rate it.
well, the cave there is supposed to be an edited version of pewter city, where instead of the museum, its something less boring.
and thanks for the rating.

And now i will rate a map since this post is pointless.

Xray said:

Woo Hoo! A Town done with Neti's base already!

Map Name: Unknown at this point
Credits: Neti for the Base, Me for mapping it xP
Map Shot:

Click to expand...

8/10
The mountain placement is nice, although i think you went crazy with making all the mountains follow the same path.
you have also killed it a bit when you put in too much rocks.
and i have not seen a single flower in the whole area.
Suggestions: cut down on the rocks, addmake flowers, and make the mountains a bit more natural, even though the mountain placement is good.

well heres my map.

Thanks for the Constructive feedback Mack!

Heres a new Map, The First Route in one of my hacks..
Name: Route 1
Map Game: Pokemon Snowfall
Credits: Neti for the base, Me for mapping it
Side notes: This took a while xP
Map Shot: