One thing I don't get is why the sniper hasn't shot yet, since there are so many targets to choose from. Even if he was culted, he should have still had a gun...unless he is one of the dead third party? It's also possible Klippy really is the sniper but I would be very surprised if that was the case, for reasons already stated.
As for Catman, they should either give Bact another vest so she stays around as long as possible or to someone else who doesn't have one. like me
Also, Nagi, keep in mind that the only thing you should be looking for is the sniper gun if they really are still around, but it might be worth abstaining so you don't accidentally kill someone again with the witch.
As for who the remaining mafia are, I believe GB is scum of some kind, either mafia or cult. Maybe he's the sniper, since he's been inactive.
There were 4 vanilla claims - Desi (who was innocent, so I think he was one), Bard, Mana, and Ullion. This setup has 3 vanillas and one miller, who appears vanilla to themselves, so it's theoretically possible they all made it this far, but it seems unlikely. It's highly likely that at least one if these claims is bullshit. I'll take a look back at the thread later and see what I can come up with. I encourage everyone else to do the same - we are going to have to make some deeper reads in order to find the scum from now on.