Caterpie or Weedle?

[xxReshiramxx]

While I find both to be super cute simple designs choices I end up finding myself drawn to caterpie more I really like the new gigantamax butterfree more then the Mega Bedrill. Its just so pretty.

 

[Sheep]

caterpie
ash's was cute and sweet!! and butterfree grew to be one of his best mons imo. weedle is okay, but i'm not exactly pleased with pokemon that have poison stingers and evolve into big bees. seems scary. D:

 

[icycatelf]

Caterpie has a more interesting aesthetic and I think it's cool that you can find caterpillars that look almost identical to it, but I think I lean more toward Weedle. It was one of my very first Shiny Pokémon, plus I remember Pokémon Zeo making a really cool glow-in-the-dark Weedle card back in the day.

 

[LakeOverTheCity]

I prefer Caterpie to Weedle by far. It's design is more appealing to me as it's a much cuter Pokemon. Aesthetically, the entire Caterpie line is more pleasant than Weedle's. Mega Beedrill is pretty much the only reason I would pick Weedle instead, and that's mostly because Adaptability is an OP ability to pair with STAB U-Turn

 

[Straylite]

I always stick to more spiky designs instead of rounded ones. And Beedrill is sick anyway heh - Weedle

 

[Lyktestolpe]

I go for Caterpie! Just prefere the look.

 

[Roni]

Caterpie vs Weedle is 5-1 as of right now. Not looking good for my spiky boi. I love them both though.

 

[Pok3pals]

From a battle and sort of battle stand point, Weedle since it has a chance of poisoning with poison sting so over time the opponent can faint even when Weedle runs out of attacking moves. Caterpie on the other hand doesn't have that kind of benefit and would have to resort to struggling if it hasn't already been defeated.

 

[VisionofMilotic]

Caterpie because it is portrayed with such a sweet personality, and evolves into one of the most beautiful Pokemon in the franchise Butterfree. The episode where Ash's Butterfree goes to finds a mate always moves me to tears. Caterpie also has the better shiny of the two choices, it's golden.

 

[Brendino]

Anyone that doesn't pick Caterpie is wrong. Butterfree may not be the strongest, but it's a fantastic Pokemon, and to this day, I still think Ash letting Butterfree go is one of the most emotional moments in the anime.

 

[Raffi]

The show made me love Caterpie so much; that episode is one of my childhood favorites of any show ever. Butterfree is also adorable, especially the shiny.

 

[Zeostar]

Caterpie, butterfree is cute. It doesn't have the best stats but it can get some nice status moves and nice abilities. It can even learn Quiver Dance.

Beedril is difficult to use without the mega evoultion.

 

[Raicheot]

Caterpie for me tend to have a butterfree in my squads quite a lot

 

[Setsuna]

I'll cast another vote for Caterpie, it's cute and I just think Butterfree is pretty. I feel like they're both seen as "those bug types you just toss away" but you don't have to worry about being poisoned when fighting one of the two in the early game...

 

[Sydian]

caterpie is more difficult to train than weedle, but you get a much better reward for sticking with it than you do for weedle. butterfree is fucking awesome.