Farmafia [GAME OVER]

Arx said:
mass claiming has downsides though. i mean it'll just tell the mafia exactly who to avoid (the hens) and who to attack (the animals that produce resources).
Click to expand...

This is true, as there are certain advantages they might want to take in choosing their kills.

But at the same time, I'm not sure what we can do right now.
I feel like I could be putting myself at risk, but, we need to get suss reads fast, and there's no better way then to find inconsistencies with role reveals.

I'm a pig. On the first night, I found a mushroom, I can eat it at anytime and has a 50% chance to kill me. It's a good thing someone mentioned a famine, because I was going to eat it to see if it produced any "effects", but saved it for now. I don't think I was mentioned in the night post as I was allowed to eat it during the day. So I started that night with a 0% chance to die, and this night will only be a 20% for me. I ate it during the day so if I died you'd probably get a clearer message of what's going on.

However, by knowing the animals less likely to starve, it does mean the mafia may target us so it's easier for the rest of us to die out and they win.

Oh, but mafia, if you're reading this I'll be waiting till night to eat another mushroom tonight. If I die from mushroom poisoning and you grab me...well, no promises my meat won't be tainted. :>
 
Eh, I was a bit hesitant at first cuz I could potentially reveal someone but here goes.

I'm a hen. I've got an egg, but as you've figured out I'm keeping it. Seeing as many of us were alive until yesterday, I thought I could afford not eating it last night, in case I don't get another. But now I gotta thank RNGesus for surviving the night lol, so I'm gonna eat it tonight.

On another note, I find it strange that Nimsy suggested we role reveal but she didn't do so. I've been a bit suss of her and her "gut feeling" and I'm starting to think I was spot on.
 
Holy balls a shotgun?? That's interesting, I assumed we'd just find mushrooms. Nice.
 
Elektra Heart said:
Mass-claiming sounds good.
Click to expand...

Add me to your list of sheeps.

I think we're going about this vegetarian business incorrectly. While I do think there's one more PETA-aligned player (due to the "PETA finally did something" hint back when, meaning they recruited someone - bringing their number to a total of 3?), it says in the OP:

"They may persuade animals to join their cause although the Bloodbones never will."

That means the remaining vegetarian presumably has an animal (that they were originally assigned) to claim as; therefore, saying there's "one vegetarian" seperate from the animals is false, because they are a part of the animal population.​
 
I was waiting for someone to claim my hen role.
I ate my egg last night.

I believe alex is mafia, and a pig having a gun is super weird so I think bac is maf too.
 
sheeps unite o/ \o
 
> nimsy cc's alex
> also throws shade at bac
> bac has a gun and nimsy dont give a flip
> bac be like "hm girl not saying u a vegie but u might be vegie"

[PokeCommunity.com] Farmafia [GAME OVER]

I think Nimsy's recklessness definitely clears her from being a Bloodbone in any case - there's four of them left (presumably from narrative context clues) so there's no need for her to go on the attack like that if she had allies. Unless there's some hip new strategy these youngin's have devised that I'm not jiggy with.

Arx said:
sheeps unite o/ \o
Click to expand...

Is this actually a sheep claim or encouragement for the ship between me and Ulli because I find it intriguing in one case and sexy in the other.​
 
Nimsy said:
I was waiting for someone to claim my hen role.
I ate my egg last night.

I believe alex is mafia, and a pig having a gun is super weird so I think bac is maf too.
Click to expand...

I was expecting you'd cc me, tbh. I was purposefully the loudest hoping you'd night kill me, but you were smart enough not to, I'll give you that.
I've also thought of the possibility that 3 hens remain (including Anna). But I've dropped the theory for the following reasons :
1. Having 4 loudmouths in a game of 25 would be extremely town sided, as if you get to somehow be a confirmed loudmouth you're essentially immortal for the rest of the game. 4 of these? Hmm
2. The rooster role was able to invite hens to his own chat. Having 4 hens in your own chat, while it's a different task to accomplish, means 1/5 of the total players are innocents who know each other and can confirm each other. And this defeats the purpose of innos not knowing each other.

So, I believe there are 3 hens total and thus Nimsy is probably mafia. Of course she would cc the last hen, it's the only way for mafia to safely get rid of me.
[Slaughter] Nimsy

Also, @Bac : I'd argue that Nimsy's contribution for the innos is nowhere near mine, don't know where you're getting that from.
 
I'm going to go with this not because I'm totally convinced/making a bandwagon but...that I ended up not getting a vote in last time before phase change and making sure I don't get inactive killed if I forget again, pft.

[Slaughter] Nimsy
 
I can see all the scum.

If you're stupid enough to lynch me.
Kill Kiyo, bac, alex and arx

I am positive my "three of every animal" theory is correct.
 
Tbh I was suspicious of Arx as soon as he questioned the RR claiming idea. It was our best shot at getting some form of info this game. He also came out and claimed a role I don't think exists any longer outside of myself and maybe one other player (pending if Nimsy's consistency of animal numbers theory is correct).

Based on that, I do want to lynch Arx first and foremost, before trying to make a decision between Bac/alex/nimsy. On the other hand, I can always find out who is a sheep and who isn't based off our flock power. As such as we could make a more accurate lynch tomorrow against Arx/Kiyo (or myself if you guys think I'm lying).

What is everyone's thoughts on this before I do vote and make up my mind?
 
I'm fine with lynching any of my FOSs.

Also, if anna can come out and say she didn't eat her egg, then I'm clear.
Because that would confirm me to be the chicken in the narrative.
 
Flocking seems like the way to go. But even in this case fake sheep(s) could claim they used flocking too. But I suppose it can't be helped.

What's troubling me atm is Nimsy's scum list. Wondering how much bussing is happening in there. I've been scumreading Arx for the most part and Bac on a lower degree, though her items claim seems legit.
Nina is kinda high on my scum list also, ever since day 1 actually. She was among the first to support Naku, so I initially thought of them being mafia. I mean, she just went straight into supporting Naku even tho he killed CB. After Naku was proven bull, I thought she just tried to befriend him, knowing she'll kill him that night, and then proceed and claim town credit the next day. Or she was just following her pig gut.
On the other hand, the other pig claim, Bac, has hardly posted at all. I'd be surprised if she has more than 15 posts total actually. Claiming a pig has a gun sounds nuts, humans are more likely to have one. Then again, she could have just found one lying somewhere outside the house idk.
Thoughts on the pigs claims?
 
alexkaz61 said:
Nina is kinda high on my scum list also, ever since day 1 actually. She was among the first to support Naku, so I initially thought of them being mafia. I mean, she just went straight into supporting Naku even tho he killed CB. After Naku was proven bull, I thought she just tried to befriend him, knowing she'll kill him that night, and then proceed and claim town credit the next day. Or she was just following her pig gut.
Click to expand...

I'll be honest, I've been playing very weird this game, but that's like I said before some reason I'm getting really confused in this game and getting wrong scum reads everywhere when usually I'm not too bad at it. I don't really have any way to prove I'm a pig, so all you have is my word.

Naku made a stupid move just killing at random, but it doesn't mean they should die just for killing an inno. You've got killed by your own teammate before, you know those accidents happen. and yea, I was following my pig gut on naku's innocence oink
 
[slaughter] Collector Elwood

a hunch of mine, because of the sudden FOS on me on d3.
 
I did not eat my egg last night. However, I don't believe that clears alex nor Nimsy because it's... really easy for maf to claim or cc that role off of the narrative. :/ I also don't believe that the animals were evenly split up but I have to go to work lmao I'll try exploring that later.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top