Which one gives you the better impression & why?
Sawsbuck is definitely more visually appealing in my opinion, but from playing White I find that Garbodor is harder to beat in battle most times (thus is better to use, in battle). That and the obvious type advantage. So in terms of looks, Sawsbuck wins, but in terms of practicality, Sawsbuck wins.
Which Dream World art do you prefer?
Sawsbuck.
Which Sawsbuck form do you like best?
I think I like the Summer form the best, as I very much like all the green leaves on his antlers. Just.. 'cuz.
Against each other, which one would win the battle?
Garbodor, the type advantage makes that a given.
Sawsbuck (any of the forms) or Garbodor?
Errrrrrrrrr.. I guess Sawsbuck Summer form, because it looks better than Garbodor, altogether. Meaning I'd lose the battle, but whatever.