• Our friends from the Johto Times are hosting a favorite Pokémon poll - and we'd love for you to participate! Click here for information on how to vote for your favorites!
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

Grand Idea Mafia - A Grand Finish

NightKrow said:
rolecop is also more common as a scum role in the form of the Stalker, so Pecilia could be a Stalker :o

is this where my off-the-wall theory turns out to be right again?

nah I think I believe Pecilia, but I'll hear what Vincent has to say first. Not sure why you'd choose to investigate Vincent rather than someone who was active on D1, but oh well. I'll agree that roleblockers are definitely more likely to be scum.
Click to expand...
Yeah I had that thought as well, Pecelia could be scum rolecop trying to lynch a town roleblocker. But I don't see why he would share his role publically this early on even if he is trying to get a mislynch since he could just have Vincent killed the next night. I think the most likely scenario is a town rolecop finding the role of a scum roleblocker.

Selena Fluorspar said:
Reminder for the cop,
although this may seem old.
No one knows your sanity,
not all glitter is gold.
Click to expand...
I think you're confusing cop with rolecop. I don't think an insane rolecop is a thing, though I guess it could have been submitted...
 
Town roleblockers aren't uncommon & this is a random setup so it's about as likely either way
 
Have we figured out weather Doof was 3P or Mafia yet? Role post isn't quite helpful unless all the baddies are wolves.

Anyway, it looks like Pecilla's "reveal" is the best lead we have so far, so let's wait.
 
Decidueye said:
Have we figured out weather Doof was 3P or Mafia yet? Role post isn't quite helpful unless all the baddies are wolves.

Anyway, it looks like Pecilla's "reveal" is the best lead we have so far, so let's wait.
Click to expand...
Usually mafia is red, not orange, Orange is usually 3P. So I think Bidoof was 3P. But anything's possible in this game I guess.
 
Mafia is more often labelled werewolf, so in general wolves are the mafia

but also just by the way the roles are rolled here, there could easily be multiple factions with some being single people and thus "3rd party" by default
 
Honestly it's kind of obvious there are multiple factions since we had two deaths... or am I misinterpreting that phase post? I think doof was 3P just because werewolf as PCers know it is 3P, BUT I do think there are multiple layers of roles here and anything goes.

Pecilia revealing the type of role in a second post is not suspicious to me at all and I think it's silly anyone suspects over that. People get busy, so getting your big posts done ASAP when 4 is required isn't that sus.
 
Firm Handshake said:
werewolf as PCers know it is 3P
Click to expand...

though roles were taken from a non-PCer perspective

in areas such as MU, even mafia goons are typically referred to as wolves

though, yes, if you're talking about the Werewolf EM role, then it would be third party, as Johnny said, but in this case d00f was basically just a godfather role with bonus starting knowledge.

In this case, I'd risk saying he wasn't third party, but the only way it matters is if we use his d1 behavior to try to find other mafia members. either way that's not surefire, especially from limited day one interactivity, so it's probably more efficient to just leave it be at the moment
 
So I just woke up and saw that I was voted. May I ask if cop roles are common among scum as well? But please do continue, I would like to understand why am I the first one you picked though since you said it wasn't random anymore.
 
It wasn't really defensive, it was just basic questioning but sure call it that, either way's fine with me. Question, huh? Sure, if you want me to be one.
 
Really easy, isn't it? Tell you what, let's have a little fun with this. I'll tell you my role if you tell me yours?
 
Vincent, my dude, you've got to settle down, otherwise you're going to take the "wat" crown away from me.
 
Believe what you want to believe, pie. But I just want to point out that since this is random, mafia's can get cops too.
 
Abby said:
Do we need a vote tally right at the start haha
Click to expand...
It's actually helpful for when I make the first "real" vote count! So yes :P

Vote Count 2.1

Vincent (2) - Pecilia, Johnny

Currently Not Voting (17): gimmepie, Abby, Aaron, Superjolt, NightKrow, Uzumaki Naruto, jdthebud, Charlie Brown, symire, Selena Fluorspar, Nero, EvilChameleon, Firm Handshake, Strange, Decidueye, Nakuzami, Vincent

With 19 players alive, it takes 10 votes to lynch!

The day ends in 51 hours, around 1:00am EST on Wednesday, April 19th.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top