Happily Never After II [Villains Win!]

All votes today will be privately messaged to CB instead of posted in the thread

Which means, if the town doesn't agree on someone to lynch, the mafia will simply all pile their votes onto an inno and get a free lynch

Which isn't good.
 
Honestly, even if we can only come up with a lame semi-random vote, it'd be something, because that'd at least provide a chance to hit scum, whereas spreading out would guarantee that the maf would get a free lynch on an inno (or one of the two remaining third parties, though that's unlikely)

edit: plus, if we openly discuss and come up with a lynch, we can at least base things on that later
 
Last edited:
Desox said:
Well I've got a supposed visit from our friend the mirror that partially leaves Peci out of fault.
Click to expand...
so perhaps this means the Mirror is simply a Penguin role. Still fitting, and obviously more common than the Witness role (which I don't believe has ever really appeared on PC)
 
My line of thought for roles was similar to Naku's... but I feel Naku's might be more accurate. I was thinking Queen of Hearts could be a Granny role, but I'm not sure if that'd be balanced with a Bomb in play.

Also, I'd like to back up what Aaron said too. But please only mention if you have received something otherwise you'll be wasting precious time. As our votes are going to be anonymous for this phase, I'm going to back up whomever (I believe it was Naku?) said we should come to some sort of agreement as randovoting probably won't help us again.
 
I have received an item, but it wasn't a potion. Unless CB tells the recipients of said potions the generic mafia item that the potion is meant to be
 
If both of you got that last night, a fabricator might be confirmed
 
Sparkin said:
If both of you got that last night, a fabricator might be confirmed
Click to expand...
It depends

In theory, we could have a blacksmith, gunsmith and santa

but I also highly doubt that we'd have all those roles and no Fabricator, anyways
 
Well, that's at least three items right there, with potentially four+ item giving roles
 
Oh I forgot to mention last time, but yesterday, I received the Mushu Potion.

Basically, it counted my votes as two, however votes against me were also counted as two for that phase, hence why EC was one of the people who got lynched.
 
Here I'll do your death posts for you both.

EvilChameleon said:
I'm so confused I can't even properly decide on what to put in this death post.
Click to expand...

[PokeCommunity.com] Happily Never After II [Villains Win!]


Bardothren said:
Thank you for putting me out of my misery. What a poor way to go for the one that once made the princesses weep tears of blood.
Click to expand...

[PokeCommunity.com] Happily Never After II [Villains Win!]


and one more time...

[PokeCommunity.com] Happily Never After II [Villains Win!]


23.5 hours left in day phase
 
Nakuzami
TheUncreativeSawsbuckFan
ASDBUDDY
EvilChameleon
Bidoof FTW
Sparkin
L'Belle
aeternum
Desox
Newtsie
gimmepie
jdthebud
Rabinov
Pecilia
Salzorrah
Miah
purplecicada
Bardothren
Forever
Fletch
Vragon
Kiyotaka Ishimaru
Kitty
22
20
12
10
9
7
6
6
5
5
5
5
5
5
4
4
4
4
3
3
3
2
2

Here's the player post count, for activity level reference.

Obviously I'm not saying to base a lynch solely on how many posts someone has made, but it's something to look at.

Onto individual contributions:

TheUncreativeSawsbuckFan - unCCed Cruela de Vil. town.
ASDBUDDY - d1 vote on gunner, and mostly just seems confused overall. null.
Bidoof FTW - initial push on Saws, some role theory-crafting and an item claim. slight town.
Sparkin - d1 votes on Newts and saws, and suggestion of a Fab being present. nothing else. null.
L'Belle - no votes and no contributing posts. null.
aeternum - d1 vote switches from saws to asd to doof, in order to keep it spread. pointed out that only mods have been NKed. null.
Desox - hasn't really done anything other than confirm the Magic Mirror as being a penguin-esque role. A useful tidbit of information, but not necessarily town. I could see Desox forgetting to do so as scum, however. slight town.
Newtsie - has only voted for Sparkin and asked Saws who he vested. null.
jdthebud - d1 vote on gp, and has pointed out that purp and gunner got EC lynched. Simply bc I don't want to see that he'd vote for gp and then nk him, I'll say slight town.
Rabinov - complained about ug sheeping and early double votes, and inquired about potions. no d1 vote. despite this, slight town.
Pecilia - three posts about death posts and one with a one word random vote on myself. null.
Salzorrah - helped lynch EC with a doubled vote. town.
Miah - just a d1 vote on Rabi once it was pointed out that abstaining wasn't allowed. null.
purplecicada - also voted for EC. could be an early bus, but considering how spread votes were, I'll assume she wouldn't leave it on and risk what actually ended up happening. town.
Forever - d1 vote for Saws for him being overly defensive and suss, before he ended up claiming, but lbr he was. due to meta-status as generally not being from here and then at least trying to contribute in that way, slight town.
Fletch - congrats to Kitty's death post, and claiming of an item. null.
Vragon - d1 random vote on Bard is p much it. null.
Kiyotaka Ishimaru - nothing. you've done literally nothing (besides d1 random vote on L'Belle). null.

In summary:
town reads - TheUncreativeSawsbuckFan, Salzorrah, purplecicada
slight town reads - Bidoof FTW, Desox, jdthebud, Rabinov, Forever
null reads - ASDBUDDY, Sparkin, L'Belle, aeternum, Newtsie, Pecilia, Miah, Fletch, Vragon, Kiyotaka Ishimaru

Of my null reads, the players I would suggest initially going for a lynch on are L'Belle, Newtsie, Pecilia, Sparkin and Miah, in that order.

Thoughts? We have just under 18.5 hours to figure out an organized vote on someone, or else we're going to get screwed over. And, personally, I don't want to get screwed over lmao.



Also for reference, an updated role guesstimation list
Spoiler:
 
L'Belle said:
Why me though?
Click to expand...
L'Belle - no votes and no contributing posts. null.
Click to expand...
You just don't seem very useful, despite being one of the "higher" post counts thus far in the game.

You could always convince me to go after Newtsie first, instead. This is why I asked for thoughts.
 
Ehhh I just said nothing because all my reads are null right now
Btw you got my role right
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top