Happily Never After II [Villains Win!]

Okay, after rereading, my reads are...

100% Townreading Rabi and Naku because of engagement and quality of their contributions. Strong townread on Saws and L'Belle because of their claims.
Partial townreads on Doof because of contribution, Salzorrah and purple for leaving out their doublevotes are out of my scumreads too.

Pecilia with the benefit of the doubt because of the magic mirror message.

So I wouldn't point to any of the people mentioned about and won't vote any of them unless some groundshaking thing happens.

I notice this Sparkin abscense now that you mention it, but I don't know, he's always pulling stuff that confuses me so I'd leave the discussion about it to people that can understand his play better.
 
Last edited:
I'm keeping my vote on ASD. That's not enough to convince me to vote Sparkin, but well, as there are a lot of people blindly following what the others say without giving their own opinion, I believe Sparkin is going to get lynched unless he roleclaims.
 
Player
Nakuzami
TheUncreativeSawsbuckFan
ASDBUDDY
Bidoof FTW
Sparkin
L'Belle
aeternum
Desox
Newtsie
jdthebud
Rabinov
Pecilia
Salzorrah
Miah
purplecicada
Forever
Fletch
Vragon
Kiyotaka Ishimaru
Claiming Vote On
Sparkin
Sparkin
???
???
???
Desox
???
L'Belle
ASDBUDDY
L'Belle
Newtsie
Sparkin
Sparkin
???
???
???
???
???
Pecilia
For now, I'm going to roll with the Sparkin lynch, because at least Newtsie and Pecilia have shown up to the party. Newtsie still hasn't really said anything worth removing suspicion from him, however.

Here's the current vote tally from what people have claimed. Obviously a lot of people haven't claimed, and a lot of people haven't even been posting. As long as we can get at least five votes on one person, however, we should be able to wall off a free lynch coming from the maf.

I'd prefer a pure consensus, but of course that's unlikely.

The current tally is:

Sparkin - 4 claimed votes
L'Belle - 2 claimed votes
Desox, ASDBUDDY, Newtsie & Pecilia - 1 claimed vote
9 unclaimed votes

Also, @Newtsie lmfao seriously
each thing you say
makes me want to kill you more
and I swear, it's going to happen after this
the point is that we need to reach a consensus to outnumber the maf votes.

If you choose to splinter off just because, then you're basically trying to help the mafia.
 
Well, my role is REALLY important to the town and if I die you will all regret it.
Also, why the heck a mafia would claim that is voting someone else like this when I could just say I'm voting Sparkin and vote someone else? kek
 
Did I say you were mafia?

No, I was more saying that you're acting like an idiot.
 
Newt, I'm unsure what it is you're trying to accomplish here. Your play style is something else and tbh I really don't like it. Also, Sparks is being unusually quiet... I'm going to abstain for now and wait and see what happens. But if nothing else happens, I'll shift a vote to Newt as I'm not really liking his behaviour -- although I do not want you to reveal yourself if you are an important role.
 
purplecicada said:
Newt, I'm unsure what it is you're trying to accomplish here. Your play style is something else and tbh I really don't like it. Also, Sparks is being unusually quiet... I'm going to abstain for now and wait and see what happens. But if nothing else happens, I'll shift a vote to Newt as I'm not really liking his behaviour -- although I do not want you to reveal yourself if you are an important role.
Click to expand...
Since the vote is leaning on Sparks right now, I'd really rather you not split it up further unless everyone switches over to Newt.
 
I didn't like what Newt implied on a previous post.
This...
I believe Sparkin is going to get lynched unless he roleclaims.
Click to expand...
(...)didn't feel like a comment to me, It felt more like a "push". Like presetting Sparkin on a disadvantage already. But everybody has his/her own expressions, and I was put on the spotlight by L'Belle just for a word, so I'm not gonna heavily judge anyone by their wordings unless it's repeated several times.

Newt is unsettling me, and I'd be more prone to vote on him before Sparkin just because, to be real, 98% of the time I don't even know what Sparkin is onto, so he could just be doing a different strategy this time, or he just could be inactive.

Also Naku, I put L'Belle as townread because of a believable claim. So I'm not gonna vote him.
 
Last edited:
Desox said:
Also Naku, I put L'Belle as townread because of a believable claim. So I'm not gonna vote him.
Click to expand...
I realize, but you hadn't stated intentions to vote for anyone else yet, so that's all I had to put there.
 
Oh okay. I'm neutral rn, but I agree with your opinion that we should focus on someone we all agree, so, depending on what ends happening I'll declare who I'll vote.
 
I have an idea of what role Newtsie is softing, but I think I've seen him play enough to say he's full of shit.

My vote will be on him.

I honestly really doubt scum!Sparkin would literally just not show up for an entire phase, even when being pressured, so I don't really feel like voting that direction.
 
Last edited:
Bidoof FTW said:
I honestly really doubt scum!Sparkin would literally just not show up for an entire phase, even when being pressured, so I don't really feel like voting that direction.
Click to expand...
I am partially inclined to agree with this.

But I would also rather lose an inactive townie than have the maf lynch one that could be more of a threat to them.

Overall, Sparkin's actual posts when he was being somewhat active didn't impress me, though.

We only have about eight hours to solidify whether we want to lynch Sparkin or Newt.
 
That's fair.

Sparkin it is, and here's to hoping Newtsie lives if he really is who i want him to be
 
L'Belle said:
Fine then i'll claim, it seems to be neccesary. I'm the Magic Mirror. Each night I tell a randomly generated secret to a player. I don't get to hear what secrets I tell (Which makes me hightly curious.)
Click to expand...
Do you actually choose the player or is that random as well?

Since there hasn't been a CC yet, I'll switch over to Sparkin.
 
I'm going with Sparkin as well. The logic seems sound and I don't really see anything else I can add. (School is annoying in mafia games)

Gratitude to you Nakuzami for keeping records and track.
 
woah had a busy day and come back to some great activity

too reply to what newstie said: well these are one of my earliest maf games i just started less than a week ago and was not familiar with what role does what exactly and thought it would be better to ask about it rather than assume stuff and go with instinct.

imo i townread jd, naku and rabinov, town lean on saws, I'm still vary of belle.
though how much i'd wanna vote Newstie in tis scenario, I would have to agree with what naku and bidoof have come to conclusion of and yes it seems strange to see the absence of sparkin's straightforward behaviour, like many others have pointed out, and to not let maf get their way i'll concentrate my vote towards sparkin as well.
 
Well the day is ending in game as so is in irl.

I'm sorry Sparkin but I won't be able to see the thread until before the phase change, so I cannot change this.

Voted for Sparkin.
 
Sorry y'all, have been sick today. Will try to chat more, sorry!!

Going with Sparkin because I agree what you guys have said, defo being super quiet.
 
Okay, current tally:
Sparkin - 11 claimed votes
Newtsie - 2 claimed votes
Desox, ASDBUDDY, Pecilia - 1 claimed vote
3 unclaimed votes

Nice to see that the mafia are publicly playing along as well. This should be interesting.

Sparkin, Alvey, and Miah are the only m.i.a. individuals so far today.

With very little time left in the phase, Sparkin is obviously who we've locked in for the lynch. So hopefully that's the result we'll be seeing.

I'm going to ask that Saws give L'Belle a vest tonight, and another protecting role to be on Saws. Don't want the maf to go targeting our inno claims.

With that, I'll be heading to sleep soon, so I expect the phase will have shifted into night before I'm back. Guess we'll see what happens.

Player
Nakuzami
TheUncreativeSawsbuckFan
ASDBUDDY
Bidoof FTW
Sparkin
L'Belle
aeternum
Desox
Newtsie
jdthebud
Rabinov
Pecilia
Salzorrah
Miah
purplecicada
Forever
Fletch
Vragon
Kiyotaka Ishimaru
Claiming Vote On
Sparkin
Sparkin
Sparkin
Sparkin
???
Desox
???
Sparkin
ASDBUDDY
Sparkin
Newtsie
Sparkin
Sparkin
???
Newtsie
Sparkin
Sparkin
Sparkin
Pecilia
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top