Map Rating/Review Thread

[Tyrantrum]

Hey Guys, Made a new map!

Map Name: Ranish Hilltop

Game: N/A, although may be in my hack, Duskrise.

Base ROM: Fire Red

Credits: Me - Tiles, Kyledove - Tiles, Alistair - Tiles

Mapping Time: Around 1:30

Mapshot:

Spoiler:

Ooh..mountainy. :D

Rating: 10/10
Errors: None
Suggestions: None
Comments: This is by-far, the best map I've seen in the past week or so. :D
I love the mountain-like route, the paths are used nicely, and the grass is placed perfectly. Perfect amount of vegetation, and, well..that's it :P
Perfect. (b'')b

 

[HungryGengar]

I made a new map!

Map Name: Maze Forest

Game: N/A.

Base ROM: Fire Red

Credits: TB Pro and Zeikku - Tiles, Kyledove - Tiles, Alistair - Tiles

Mapping Time: Around 30 mins

Mapshot:

Spoiler:

 

[Tyrantrum]

I made a new map!

Map Name: Maze Forest

Game: N/A.

Base ROM: Fire Red

Credits: TB Pro and Zeikku - Tiles, Kyledove - Tiles, Alistair - Tiles

Mapping Time: Around 30 mins

Mapshot:

Spoiler:

Another great map TD. (b'')b

Rating: 8.2/10
Errors: No tile errors, just mountain errors, and a ledge. :P
Suggestions: The mountain shape is a little weird to me, and that ledge at the top..does it have a purpose? :\
Comments: I like the way you made it so you have to surf and waterfall to get to the top. :)
I also like the bottom maze. ;)

 

[Jordy San]

thanks for everyones comments. I will improve it but does someone know how to improve the mountains on the south?

 

[Disturbed]

I made a new map!

Map Name: Maze Forest

Game: N/A.

Base ROM: Fire Red

Credits: TB Pro and Zeikku - Tiles, Kyledove - Tiles, Alistair - Tiles

Mapping Time: Around 30 mins

Mapshot:

Spoiler:

Rating: 7/10
Reason, The fence at the south is pointless. The waterfall isn't properly done, and the mountain is the same shape throughout basically the whole map. Other than that, great job.

thanks for everyones comments. I will improve it but does someone know how to improve the mountains on the south?

Use the right tiles, and see how other maps have that part done.

 

[Swampert 22]

@Twilite Darkrai

Very interesting map, I like the way the river crosses the map. One thing though, the bottom group of trees look a little to uniformly placed. Just a suggestion, but I'd overlap a couple more of those trees.

Overall very good 8.5/10

 

[Shadows]

I have quite a Few Maps, part of my Hack's Maps.
Not sure if you can post multiples, but I'll give it a shot.
These are in Kyledove's Tiles:
Map Names: Littleroot Town;Route 101;Oldale Town; Route 103(All in order

Map Game: Pokemon Magma Version, hack of Firered.

Comments: All remakes of the Hoenn Maps. I tried to make em similar using these tiles, and it took me about an hour to finish all four. They are all in Full size.

Littleroot Town:

Spoiler:

Route 101:

Spoiler:

Oldale Town:

Spoiler:

Route 103:

Spoiler:

 

[Disturbed]

I have quite a Few Maps, part of my Hack's Maps.
Not sure if you can post multiples, but I'll give it a shot.
These are in Kyledove's Tiles:
Map Names: Littleroot Town;Route 101;Oldale Town; Route 103(All in order

Map Game: Pokemon Magma Version, hack of Firered.

Comments: All remakes of the Hoenn Maps. I tried to make em similar using these tiles, and it took me about an hour to finish all four. They are all in Full size.

Littleroot Town:

Spoiler:

Route 101:

Spoiler:

Oldale Town:

Spoiler:

Route 103:

Spoiler:

I won't judge on quality, seeing as how these are remakes. I'll judge by accuracy.

Littleroot: 8/10 (Some stuff is off, and the lab looks funky)
Route whatever: 10/10 Looks perfect
Oldale: 7/10 You're missing a house
Route whatever 2: 6.5/10, the right side is completely off, while the left side is dead on.

 

[Tialgo]

Map Name: Fallen Falls (Yup, so original...)

Map Game: -

Map Comment: It's just a map I made for my Comic. It was hard to make it, so plz don't be sooooo hard if it looks like a mess :(

 

[Tyrantrum]

Very nice. :)

Rating: 8.9/10
Errors: Couple tile errors.
Suggestions: Add some rocks in the open ocean at the bottom.
Comments: I love the shape, and the color of the roofs and doors.
Nice map. (b'')b

 

[Disturbed]

Map Name: Fallen Falls (Yup, so original...)

Map Game: -

Map Comment: It's just a map I made for my Comic. It was hard to make it, so plz don't be sooooo hard if it looks like a mess :(

Rating: 6/10
Reason: Great map, but it seems everything is a little too tidy. The waterfalls are wrong, and also the edges are wrong. There are tile errors on the lower water where the cliffs are, and the cliffs are all too even.

 

[Tyrantrum]

Just something random! XD

 

[Mr.Fury]

Two new maps!
The starter town and route are combined.
rate please.

Spoiler:

 

[TB Pro]

I made a new map!

Map Name: Maze Forest

Game: N/A.

Base ROM: Fire Red

Credits: TB Pro and Zeikku - Tiles, Kyledove - Tiles, Alistair - Tiles

Mapping Time: Around 30 mins

Mapshot:

Spoiler:

Suggestions: Make the mountains follow a more mountainous path, not so straight. Put less rocks in. Fill up empty space. Make the river less straight. Put some wild Poke Grass in.
Rating: 6.5/10
Comments: You stole my setup for posting a map:P

Map Name: Fallen Falls (Yup, so original...)

Map Game: -

Map Comment: It's just a map I made for my Comic. It was hard to make it, so plz don't be sooooo hard if it looks like a mess :(

Suggestions: Make the river less straight. Make the mountains follow less of the same path. Fill up some empty space. Remove some flowers.
Rating: 6.5/10
Comments: Sorta good map, just not great.

Just something random! XD

Suggestions: Add some diff tree tiles. Make the connections different, all of the connections for the trees are the same.
Rating: 5.5/10
Comments: This map isn't as good as your last one, But it's not bad still!

 

[Satoshi Sugimori]

Just something random! XD

It's nice but I don't like the outer trees theyre so round XD and the placing of the little trees isn't really nice but not looking to the graphics I only see the little trees as a fault so I give it an 6.3/10

Two new maps!
The starter town and route are combined.
rate please.

Spoiler:

1st one the grass doesn't look naturally it's too "made" and the trees are in a somehow military order like theyre not random enough nothing elso to complain about,, rating 6.3/10

2nd one I actually like this one (except for the tile error in the standard house (the big one)) Nice placing of the trees only a little dull but nothing really to complain about XD so I give it an 8.4/10

 

[TB Pro]

Two new maps!
The starter town and route are combined.
rate please.

Spoiler:

Just rating the route, as I've rated the town already.
Suggestions: Make it less symmetrical. Fill up some empty space. Remove some wild grass. Make the path less straight. make it less symmetrical.
Rating: 5/10
Comments: DUDE, GIVE FRICKIN CREDIT FOR THE ROMBASE!

 

[sab]

Originally Posted by Mr.Fury
Two new maps!
The starter town and route are combined.
rate please.

rating 9.2/10
comments great tiles nothing I would really think to change except mabye make the tiles better.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally Posted by Wind
Just something random! XD

comments great map! The tiles could be improved a little (they are my fav offical tiles though).there is a tile error in the house on the left just above the window.
rating 8.5 /10
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally Posted by Tialgo (image no longer exists)
Map Name: Fallen Falls (Yup, so original...)

Map Game: -

Map Comment: It's just a map I made for my Comic. It was hard to make it, so plz don't be sooooo hard if it looks like a mess :(

Comments It looks great! I'd like to see more new tiles and the over all structure of the map looks good,but I don't like the mart.
rating 8 /10
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally Posted by Twilite Darkrai (image no longer exists)
I made a new map!

Map Name: Maze Forest

Game: N/A.

Base ROM: Fire Red

Credits: TB Pro and Zeikku - Tiles, Kyledove - Tiles, Alistair - Tiles

Mapping Time: Around 30 mins

comments great structure, great tiles, great everything. Nothing to really suggest. perfect map.
rating 10/10
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally Posted by T (image no longer exists)
I have quite a Few Maps, part of my Hack's Maps.
Not sure if you can post multiples, but I'll give it a shot.
These are in Kyledove's Tiles:
Map Names: Littleroot Town;Route 101;Oldale Town; Route 103(All in order

Map Game: Pokemon Magma Version, hack of Firered.

Comments: All remakes of the Hoenn Maps. I tried to make em similar using these tiles, and it took me about an hour to finish all four. They are all in Full size.

comments Great hoenn remakes all in all.
rating 8.5/10
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I can't turn off italics no matter how many times I click the button.

 

[Tyrantrum]

Originally Posted by Wind
Just something random! XD

comments great map! The tiles could be improved a little (they are my fav offical tiles though).there is a tile error in the house on the left just above the window.
rating 8.5 /10

Whoops, forgot about that. O.o;
Thanks. :D

Also, pressing the italics button doesn't turn it off, the will just keep appearing if you keep pressing it.
-----------------------------------------------
Another Ruby map.
I know, it's horrific. :[
It's supposed to be a maze-like route, but I failed epicly. x[
Anyways, here it is:

 

[Ripper]

It's interesting Wind, but all in all it's rather pointless. The actual route part is very short, and the maze doesn't work out well. If you edit it to create a more maze like structure where there are multiple routes it would work much better.

Here's one from Pokemon Orange...

 

[TB Pro]

Whoops, forgot about that. O.o;
Thanks. :D

Also, pressing the italics button doesn't turn it off, the will just keep appearing if you keep pressing it.
-----------------------------------------------
Another Ruby map.
I know, it's horrific. :[
It's supposed to be a maze-like route, but I failed epicly. x[
Anyways, here it is:

Suggestions: Make it less symmetrical. It looks like a checkerboard, not in a good way.
Rating: 4.5/10
Comments: Man, try to get away from these not so good maps :P

It's interesting Wind, but all in all it's rather pointless. The actual route part is very short, and the maze doesn't work out well. If you edit it to create a more maze like structure where there are multiple routes it would work much better.

Here's one from Pokemon Orange...

Suggestions: Fill up the empty space. Make the mountains less straight. Spread the flowers out, and remove some of them.
Rating: 6/10
Comments: Not too bad of a map, but not too great either.