Map Rating/Review Thread

[balkj06]

here's a map for the small region in kanto

"image removed"

 

[Ray Maverick]

here's a map for the small region in kanto

"image removed"

Tooooooo much empty space,but if you add height to the mountain,it'd be great.
The border rocks in the water are very square

rating: 6,23/10

 

[Crimson Stardust]

my another go

Name:Kamehame Town
From:Fire Red
Info:My another go on mapping....
Rate it guys...

Spoiler:

 

[pokerus34]

Name:Kamehame Town
From:Fire Red
Info:My another go on mapping....
Rate it guys...

Spoiler:

Kamehameha! Dragonball Power! *grrr...*

Anyways...

Rating: 9/10

Reason: Lacking a few more details (just a few more) XD. But still, the simple scenery and organization of the elements of the map makes it beautiful to the naked eye. Good job. And I like the Map name. :)

Suggestion: Nothing much... A few more details will suit it perfectly.

What hack is this? Because the map name is stuck in my head.

P.S. XD

 

[Master Terrador]

@Ageangel...Your gettin WAAY better...Good job...:)
Rating~9/10
Hm...Nothing...:)

 

[Mana1]

here's a map for the small region in kanto

Barely any of the map is actually playable, so whats the point it being so big? :P

Boring: 2/10

 

[CollinP]

i was skipped (sorta) everything else is above


i sorta like it! it does look a little off, but the gym idea is nice!
i don't really like the houses there- you could try to have grass on the mountain maybe?
7/10

skipped again............ sorry for kinda nagging
Map Town
Fire Red
I Was Bored

 

[Ray Maverick]

skipped again............ sorry for kinda nagging
Map Town
Fire Red
I Was Bored

Hmm...the fences forming the road are like squares.Watch it,fix it.
Nice try though.
rating: 4,28/10

sorry for the harsh rating,but i count the sight mistakes in the maps more than the mapping mistakes.

 

[Likewise]

Hmm...the fences forming the road are like squares.Watch it,fix it.
Nice try though.
rating: 6,59/10

sorry for the harsh rating,but i count the sight mistakes in the maps more than the mapping mistakes.

Are you kiddding me, in what way was that even remotley harsh?

skipped again............ sorry for kinda nagging
Map Town
Fire Red
I Was Bored

Does anyone else think that this looks a little too much like Slateport? Can we say edit?
The water is really boring and emtpey, there's practically no detail or effort whatsoever in it.
I can spot a large number of path errors, and while I'm at it, there are WAY to many of them, there's also way too much emptey space in the paths, and all around the map in general.
3/10

 

[~Teh Panda~]

Finally updated my map, soz for early versions I was pretty lame at posting an unfinished map.

BTW, those are lakeside terraces on northern lake, the shop going to the left exit on the map is a shop for your dormitory at school, The lake view house is the Dean's retreat, going south is Endigo Port, going to the East is the rest of the Endigo Academy, and the science building in the clearing near the lake is the Endigo Research Team's Main Base.

Spoiler:

 

[Ray Maverick]

Now,Panda,this looks better!
rating: 7,2/10

Keep up with your giant map!I'll do one soon.(once the exams are finished)

 

[Tropical Sunlight]

skipped again............ sorry for kinda nagging
Map Town
Fire Red
I Was Bored

Well, to tell the truth...
2/10
Try looking at some mapping tutorials.
It's square, and those tiles you used as a path...
Those and un-walkable.
I suggest you read Neti's tutorial.

 

[Alice]

Finally updated my map, soz for early versions I was pretty lame at posting an unfinished map.

BTW, those are lakeside terraces on northern lake, the shop going to the left exit on the map is a shop for your dormitory at school, The lake view house is the Dean's retreat, going south is Endigo Port, going to the East is the rest of the Endigo Academy, and the science building in the clearing near the lake is the Endigo Research Team's Main Base.

Spoiler:

This is much much better. Although it's still a seemingly unnecessarily long walk, that path is much more interesting and pretty. I don't like the house in the middle of the lake though... mainly the bridge, it looks a little weird.
8.5/10

 

[Spherical Ice]

Map Name: Redcedar Town
Map Game: FireRed BPRE (U)
Map Information: The hometown of my hack.
Map:

Spoiler:

And the route below...

Map Name: Route 027
Map Game: FireRed BPRE (U)
Map Information: The first route of my hack.
Map:

Spoiler:

 

[Crimson Stardust]

Map Name: Redcedar Town
Map Game: FireRed BPRE (U)
Map Information: The hometown of my hack.
Map:

Spoiler:

I love this map...
it looks natural..
i rate it 8.5/10

 

[Alice]

I've made a town this time! I couldn't decide until toward the end whether it should be a starter town, or just a regular one. I've decided that it's a starter town though (a big one but w/e lol) so the gym would be replaced with a lab. To do that, I would have to copy all the lab tiles over to a different tileset since I wasn't using that one, and that's just too boring lol. The grass is there to start the whole "don't go out into the grass or you'll be killed by a wild pokemon" speech.

Not actually a part of a hack or anything. I'm still just practicing. I'm not sure if I left too much space in the middlish grass area or not. Hopefully it's ok though.

Rate time for me now plz?

 

[Luck]

https://img132.imageshack.us/img132/589/seran.png
Just a map that I made for aesthetics only. No playability, just aesthetics.

 

[FoggyDoggy]

Rate time for me now plz?

You may wanna fix those waterfalls... I know they look alright, but you gotta have the mountain taller to have waterfalls that AREN'T just big ol' tile errors...

 

[Alice]

You may wanna fix those waterfalls... I know they look alright, but you gotta have the mountain taller to have waterfalls that AREN'T just big ol' tile errors...

Yeah, I have no clue how waterfalls work... so I just threw in what looked best as a solid tile.

 

[Neti]

Yeah, I have no clue how waterfalls work... so I just threw in what looked best as a solid tile.

you may want to check some original FR maps to see how they work