Map Rating/Review Thread

[cooley]

Incredible! Extremly well done, mabye a bit too much grass, but overall
FANTASTIC! 9/10
Oh, forgot:
Map Name:Route 345
Map Game:Firered.
COmments: The route after Mondercose, rate please.

Spoiler:

Neminoa, I like your maps, but they have to many mistakes. Revise and edit your maps before you post them.

Overall 8/10 for look.
10/10 for difficulty of getting through
5/10 for mistakes

 

[destinedjagold]

I felt a bit bored so I decided to make a map.
Name: ???
Game: Fire-Red
Additional Comments: It's a bit big so it's in the spoiler. It's nothing special, just a random map I decided to make. It only took me about an hour.

Spoiler:

Wow, thethethethe, I really like the map. Also, I do tend to fall in love with blue flowers. :D 9/10

I love the trees also and the placements of the houses. ;)

Btw, a small tile error on the mountain edges...

 

[suoert]

I felt a bit bored so I decided to make a map
Name: ???
Game: Fire-Red
Additional Comments: It's a bit big so it's in the spoiler. It's nothing special, just a random map I decided to make. It only took me about an hour.

Spoiler:

That is a really cool map, but there are some things i didn't like, like those little round bushes, and the fact that there are so many different colors of buildings i just don't like that. but that's just my opinion, other than that a great map 9/10

and also here is a new map from me..

Spoiler:

 

[destinedjagold]

Simply amazing! I love the new looks of both PC and PKMN Mart! 9/10

 

[.hack]

and also here is a new map from me..

Spoiler:

cool map its definately a 9/10 if not 9.999999999999999/10

 

[Binary]

Wow that map is amazingly done!
And OMG I love the pokemart and PC!
Its simply amazing.
10/10

~Celebi

 

[~!Fuddmeyer!~]

My New Map

Map Name: New Bark Town

Map Game: FireRed

Comments: It's for my Silver Remake, please do not steal it.

Mapshot:

 

[Zanacross]

not another silver remake

its the same as every other silver remake

try to make it diffrent and i may rate it.

 

[~!Fuddmeyer!~]

New Media

More media for my Silver Remake:

It's big so click the spoiler:

Spoiler:

 

[Νιτραμ]

It misses out some Pokémon grass... and the normal grass is too unnaturally placed... and the map lost its cuteness of the GBC ages... 6/10. Sorry. I think this could be done nicer.

 

[Zanacross]

like i said befor i wont rate your maps until u go away from the silver remake idea. we have a silver remake all ready

We dont need another one

why dont ou make a map from scratch like other hackers

 

[~!Fuddmeyer!~]

People started flaming me for doing a Silver Remake: So here is my first real map. It might be a town in my first official hack, but I'm not sure.

 

[destinedjagold]

Well, it is really a good map to start in thy hack, RH. :)
But the bushes and the flowers on the uper-right corner of your map is kinda, disturbing...
Btw, if it's a town, maybe you could add at least one more doorless house. But I don't know. It is just my idea, btw.

Oh, almost forgot... 8/10... You could change the tiles to make it look very interesting. :D


Ok, it's my turn. In the spoiler is where my new map is. I wanna know about what you think about it. Thanks in advance. I present to you, Green Valley...

Spoiler:

 

[Erimgard]

destinedjagold:
looks pretty good
suggestions:
Change up the ground a little bit. put a little more variation. there's just too much of that green tile
Also the map seems a tad to squared...to perfect looking, ya know?

anyway, solid map. 8/10

 

[Binary]

People started flaming me for doing a Silver Remake: So here is my first real map. It might be a town in my first official hack, but I'm not sure.

Meh...I think its too much of a square.
Note: Dont make maps like totally squares(that i hate)
Anyways I think its really good and simple. Good use of the lighter patches of grass there.
7.5/10

Well, it is really a good map to start in thy hack, RH. :)
But the bushes and the flowers on the uper-right corner of your map is kinda, disturbing...
Btw, if it's a town, maybe you could add at least one more doorless house. But I don't know. It is just my idea, btw.

Oh, almost forgot... 8/10... You could change the tiles to make it look very interesting. :D


Ok, it's my turn. In the spoiler is where my new map is. I wanna know about what you think about it. Thanks in advance. I present to you, Green Valley...

Spoiler:

I think its a really good map, I think the connections of the tunnels are well made. Aside from that, I really like the tiles.
It gets a solid rating of: 9/10

~Celebi

 

[~!Fuddmeyer!~]

My new map:

Spoiler:

I'm really proud of this map. It is the Route that connects at the bottom exit of my previous town. It will be full of trainers. Inside the lone house is a guy that will heal your Pokemon. Rate please.

 

[destinedjagold]

Thanks for the ratings, guys!

@ pokemonhacker9507,
It looks okay, but you could add some level 2 mountains on those mountains of yours...
Anyways, 8/10

I want my SIDE PATH to be rated! :D
This map is already accessable in Beta 2. Here it is...

Spoiler:

Thanks!

 

[~!Fuddmeyer!~]

Here is another new map!

I think it's my best yet. Also I added grass to the other route map.

Spoiler:

Now I need to map the starter town and remap my first town.

@ DJG: Love the map! I like the placement of the trees. 10/10

 

[Binary]

Here is another new map!

I think it's my best yet. Also I added grass to the other route map.

Spoiler:

Now I need to map the starter town and remap my first town.

@ DJG: Love the map! I like the placement of the trees. 10/10

I like the map. It shows lots of pathways(which I like)
But I saw some errors there:D Anyways its a good map.
7/10

Thanks for the ratings, guys!

@ pokemonhacker9507,
It looks okay, but you could add some level 2 mountains on those mountains of yours...
Anyways, 8/10

I want my SIDE PATH to be rated! :D
This map is already accessable in Beta 2. Here it is...

Spoiler:

Thanks!

OMG You always make big maps :D
Anyways I love the map. Its sorta like a seaside jungle.
I like the pathways and placement of trees.
9/10

~Celebi

 

[~!Fuddmeyer!~]

@ Celebi_XD: Oh.. Where are the errors so I can correct them?

Anyways: Here is the revamped version of my first town.

Spoiler: