• Just a reminder that providing specifics on, sharing links to, or naming websites where ROMs can be accessed is against the rules. If your post has any of this information it will be removed.
  • Our friends from the Johto Times are hosting a favorite Pokémon poll - and we'd love for you to participate! Click here for information on how to vote for your favorites!
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

Map Rating/Review Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
neminoa said:
Incredible! Extremly well done, mabye a bit too much grass, but overall
FANTASTIC! 9/10
Oh, forgot:
Map Name:Route 345
Map Game:Firered.
COmments: The route after Mondercose, rate please.
Spoiler:
Click to expand...
Neminoa, I like your maps, but they have to many mistakes. Revise and edit your maps before you post them.

Overall 8/10 for look.
10/10 for difficulty of getting through
5/10 for mistakes
 
thethethethe said:
I felt a bit bored so I decided to make a map.
Name: ???
Game: Fire-Red
Additional Comments: It's a bit big so it's in the spoiler. It's nothing special, just a random map I decided to make. It only took me about an hour.
Spoiler:
Click to expand...

Wow, thethethethe, I really like the map. Also, I do tend to fall in love with blue flowers. :D 9/10

I love the trees also and the placements of the houses. ;)

Btw, a small tile error on the mountain edges...
 
thethethethe said:
I felt a bit bored so I decided to make a map
Name: ???
Game: Fire-Red
Additional Comments: It's a bit big so it's in the spoiler. It's nothing special, just a random map I decided to make. It only took me about an hour.
Spoiler:
Click to expand...

That is a really cool map, but there are some things i didn't like, like those little round bushes, and the fact that there are so many different colors of buildings i just don't like that. but that's just my opinion, other than that a great map 9/10

and also here is a new map from me..
Spoiler:
 
Wow that map is amazingly done!
And OMG I love the pokemart and PC!
Its simply amazing.
10/10

~Celebi
 
not another silver remake

its the same as every other silver remake

try to make it diffrent and i may rate it.
 
It misses out some Pokémon grass... and the normal grass is too unnaturally placed... and the map lost its cuteness of the GBC ages... 6/10. Sorry. I think this could be done nicer.
 
like i said befor i wont rate your maps until u go away from the silver remake idea. we have a silver remake all ready

We dont need another one

why dont ou make a map from scratch like other hackers
 
Well, it is really a good map to start in thy hack, RH. :)
But the bushes and the flowers on the uper-right corner of your map is kinda, disturbing...
Btw, if it's a town, maybe you could add at least one more doorless house. But I don't know. It is just my idea, btw.

Oh, almost forgot... 8/10... You could change the tiles to make it look very interesting. :D


Ok, it's my turn. In the spoiler is where my new map is. I wanna know about what you think about it. Thanks in advance. I present to you, Green Valley...
Spoiler:
 
Rubyhacker9507 said:
People started flaming me for doing a Silver Remake: So here is my first real map. It might be a town in my first official hack, but I'm not sure.

[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread
Click to expand...
Meh...I think its too much of a square.
Note: Dont make maps like totally squares(that i hate)
Anyways I think its really good and simple. Good use of the lighter patches of grass there.
7.5/10

destinedjagold said:
Well, it is really a good map to start in thy hack, RH. :)
But the bushes and the flowers on the uper-right corner of your map is kinda, disturbing...
Btw, if it's a town, maybe you could add at least one more doorless house. But I don't know. It is just my idea, btw.

Oh, almost forgot... 8/10... You could change the tiles to make it look very interesting. :D


Ok, it's my turn. In the spoiler is where my new map is. I wanna know about what you think about it. Thanks in advance. I present to you, Green Valley...
Spoiler:
Click to expand...
I think its a really good map, I think the connections of the tunnels are well made. Aside from that, I really like the tiles.
It gets a solid rating of: 9/10

~Celebi
 
My new map:

Spoiler:


I'm really proud of this map. It is the Route that connects at the bottom exit of my previous town. It will be full of trainers. Inside the lone house is a guy that will heal your Pokemon. Rate please.
 
Last edited:
Here is another new map!

I think it's my best yet. Also I added grass to the other route map.

Spoiler:


Now I need to map the starter town and remap my first town.

@ DJG: Love the map! I like the placement of the trees. 10/10
 
Last edited:
Rubyhacker9507 said:
Here is another new map!

I think it's my best yet. Also I added grass to the other route map.

Spoiler:


Now I need to map the starter town and remap my first town.

@ DJG: Love the map! I like the placement of the trees. 10/10
Click to expand...
I like the map. It shows lots of pathways(which I like)
But I saw some errors there:D Anyways its a good map.
7/10

destinedjagold said:
Thanks for the ratings, guys!

@ pokemonhacker9507,
It looks okay, but you could add some level 2 mountains on those mountains of yours...
Anyways, 8/10

I want my SIDE PATH to be rated! :D
This map is already accessable in Beta 2. Here it is...
Spoiler:

Thanks!
Click to expand...
OMG You always make big maps :D
Anyways I love the map. Its sorta like a seaside jungle.
I like the pathways and placement of trees.
9/10

~Celebi
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top