• Just a reminder that providing specifics on, sharing links to, or naming websites where ROMs can be accessed is against the rules. If your post has any of this information it will be removed.
  • Ever thought it'd be cool to have your art, writing, or challenge runs featured on PokéCommunity? Click here for info - we'd love to spotlight your work!
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

Map Rating/Review Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Kevin33193 said:
Hey Everyone Can Soemone Rate This Pic. Becareful Its Big

Spoiler:
Click to expand...

Ok, I am going to list the bad, then the good, ok...

Bad
1:There is a blue ground beneath those trees, is it a tile error, or are you trying to do that?
EDIT: Ok, there are a few more tile error than I expected, there is a missing block in the tree along the right edge of the map, as well as that along that same edge, the large, bright green trees have no ending tiles, eg. follow from the top of the screen down along right edge of bright green large trees, and there is no ending tiles...
2:The borders may end up a little funky, try using one type of tree for your level edges, that way, the borders blend in with them.


Good

1: I personally like the maze quality, I don't see to many maze like maps in pokemon games... other than berry forest in FR, but that was an easy maze...
2: I like the placement of the hop-able cliffs, but try to tone them down a bit, there are a lot of them, hehe!
3: Caves are good, and bad... there is something about the cave at the top that bothers me... like, the mountain like thing it is on is too square....

I give it a professional score of 5/10

I give it a personal score of 7.5/10! (after tile edits of course)

Keep it up!
 
Last edited:
αωαταρ αανγ said:
How does it look like petalburg city?

The path is supposed to be squiggly because it is slowly decaying away due to the over growth of plant life. You seriously need to look at my thread. So basically the only reason you gave me a bad rating actually should be reasons why it is good. Maps for games do need to follow the story line you know. -_-

Compare for yourself everyone!

Spoiler:


sPrough93 (8: 20:42 PM): https://i278.photobucket.com/albums/kk112/sprough93/3441161754a5419081841m-1.png
sPrough93 (8: 20:47 PM): Do they look alike at all?
atomicreactor334 (8:21:20 PM): not in anyway... what so ever
sPrough93 (8: 21:27 PM): Thank you
sPrough93 (8: 21:34 PM): someone said they looked alike
sPrough93 (8: 21:35 PM): -_-
atomicreactor334 (8: 21:39 PM): wtf

And for your map, I give it a 1.3/10. So SO many map errors. The blue house at the top left has NO windows and it is giant. o.o The map is so empty. Just because it has a lot of stuff that doesn't make it good. You need to make the map smaller. -_-

To make this post from being complete spam...here is a new map. :D

Spoiler:


Oh, I am sorry. Is it too much like Route 1?!

And no, the doduo is NOT on top of the house. -_-
Click to expand...

Oh come on, be a little more mature dude. He was just giving an opinion. Take it.
No need to be sarcastic and personally attack him. This isn't a place to defend yourself, you post maps to have them criticised. If you can't take it, then don't post them. :]

And we both know, that map doesn't deserve a 1.3.

The map isn't the best, it has many flaws and the layout strange, but not 1.3.
I'd give it a 4/10.

Now, I'm not attacking him right now. He was just the last person to do it.
This is for everyone. If you post a map here, expect to be criticized. Do not take it personally and attack the other person or make it seem like you are. You don't need to defend yourself. Let people have their opinions.

<3 αωαταρ αανγ (sorry. I'm just using you. <3)

EDIT: Haha, and. No. I don't think it looks like Petalburg City, if anything, the other one looks more like Petalburg City, but neither do.
As for a rating, i'd give "Petalburg City" a 7/10. It's nice. I just hate the placement and shape of the lake. Also, lacks alot of creativity. Looks like an average town. Which can be good. In fact, almost necessary in a pokemon game. But I still wish it had a few "WOAH! Cool!" surprises in there
 
Last edited:
@riolu 9: The map is great. It's not too square, enough space, good vegetation, and a cave! ^^
Of course the cave could be a little more realistic...9/10

This map is actually by my friend.
I made one for him because he's new to hacking.
I'm posting it because he 4got his password.
[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread

Plz rate and comment.
 
Eeveon said:
@riolu 9: The map is great. It's not too square, enough space, good vegetation, and a cave! ^^
Of course the cave could be a little more realistic...9/10

This map is actually by my friend.
I made one for him because he's new to hacking.
I'm posting it because he 4got his password.
[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread

Plz rate and comment.
Click to expand...


Well I Got To Say Its Cool All Sides Are being Used Lol Not Really That Square Sort Of And Cool. Lol

I Will Give It A 8.5 Out Of 10 Sort Of Lol.
 
Map Name: Irobrum Town
[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread

I have a reason for using that door on the gym. Theme of the town is mind and body both strong. Instead of the door opening for you, you must open it. (I know it still opens automatically XD)
 
Spoiler:

Yup it's a route give c&c, I take wide criticism.

[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread


I tried making a small village cause I'm lazy xD.

megiddo said:
Map Name: Irobrum Town
[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread

I have a reason for using that door on the gym. Theme of the town is mind and body both strong. Instead of the door opening for you, you must open it. (I know it still opens automatically XD)
Click to expand...
Lot's of tile errors
the maps are wide, alot of unspaced used
the long bush is square.
the road is connected.
6/10
 
Last edited:
@Ryousha:
Map 1: Looks good, but, the bottom seems too empty and the ledge at the far left has no use...9/10
Map 2: It's good, but u don't really need that ledge...9.5/10
 
Ryousha said:
Spoiler:

Yup it's a route give c&c, I take wide criticism.

[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread


I tried making a small village cause I'm lazy xD.
Click to expand...

Ok...let's see now...
Hmmm...
The caves on the Route basically have no roof. I'm serious, look at them. It basically counts as a tile error.
It's a bit empty at the bottom...
7.5/10

The town...OMG!! It's the haunted NET Center!!!!
xD
Some places you have too many headbutt trees (how do you script them?!)
I don't see why there's that funny yellow thing...
But..meh...
8/10

Now for my own.
Spoiler:
 
Last edited:
dark lakitu said:
Ok...let's see now...
Hmmm...
The caves on the Route basically have no roof. I'm serious, look at them. It basically counts as a tile error.
It's a bit empty at the bottom...
7.5/10

The town...OMG!! It's the haunted NET Center!!!!
xD
Some places you have too many headbutt trees (how do you script them?!)
I don't see why there's that funny yellow thing...
But..meh...
8/10

Now for my own.
Spoiler:
Click to expand...

my route doesnt have any tile error.. >_>(the cave doesnt.)

your map scares me, xD.
8/10

Yes I scripted it..
 
@riolu 9: The top of the map is a tiny bit empty.
The top of the cave is empty, and looks too Nintendo-ish.
Um...The water is empty, and the big green hedge, doesn't look good there. :\
Other than that, it's great...6.5/10
 
Eeveon said:
@riolu 9: The top of the map is a tiny bit empty.
The top of the cave is empty, and looks too Nintendo-ish.
Um...The water is empty, and the big green hedge, doesn't look good there. :\
Other than that, it's great...6.5/10
Click to expand...
thank's i will do what you said and i will improve it anyway thank's im going to put a town in there next so look forward to that
 
@RTW: New Bark looks good, but, u really shouldn't use a path like that.
That's something Nintendo and Gamefreak would do.
Fix that and the fact that it will be partly empty...7/10
 
riolu 9 said:
this is my second map on the thread please rate well here it is

[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread



this took me 20 minutes impressive isnt it
Click to expand...
No it isn't. all the right side is square, the water is useless it's square.

lessen the grass, add some shrubs,ledges,flowers.
 
Ryousha said:
No it isn't. all the right side is square, the water is useless it's square.

lessen the grass, add some shrubs,ledges,flowers.
Click to expand...
no i didnt mean the map i ment it was impressive that i done it in 20 minutes duh

and yeah your a real expert at mapping arnt you not
 
I've reached that goal, by taking my time, and listen to other people comment who don't know what they're saying

a map is what values from custom to awesome.

You need to check if it's square, add some roads, and mostly add the misc. stuff. that map if I did what I said would take 1 hour with using ctrl and right click on the grosser, since I never do that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top