Map Rating/Review Thread

[Platinum Lucario]

OK, this is my first map on this thread, and this is what you'll see. Please rate this map and tell me what should be improved.
I didn't make it any square like or anything. Well here it is:

Spoiler:

Nice map isn't it?

 

[Tyrantrum]

I like the shape of the map, but the r some empty spaces and too many ledges...8.5/10

 

[Thrace]

OK, this is my first map on this thread, and this is what you'll see. Please rate this map and tell me what should be improved.
I didn't make it any square like or anything. Well here it is:

Spoiler:

Nice map isn't it?

Rating: 1.5/10
Comments: You guys worry way too much about your map looking square. Take a look at the maps that are already in FR (the Sevii Island ones). Why is there so much randomly placed grass everywhere? It looks terrible, so do the placement of stones and flowers. Same with the trees. Just bad, sorry. I do like how you've tried to incorporate the ledges. But you used way too many and it just looks bad.

 

[Neti]

OK, this is my first map on this thread, and this is what you'll see. Please rate this map and tell me what should be improved.
I didn't make it any square like or anything. Well here it is:

Spoiler:

Nice map isn't it?

Nice shape and good placing of stuff like rocks, flowers and grass
at the left part there are too many ledges, that should be changed
and the small trees there are standing in rows, which is not good
the right part is cool to me
rating: 7/10

I like the shape of the map, but the r some empty spaces and too many ledges...8.5/10

where do you see empty space? Oo

Rating: 1.5/10
Comments: You guys worry way too much about your map looking square. Take a look at the maps that are already in FR (the Sevii Island ones). Why is there so much randomly placed grass everywhere? It looks terrible, so do the placement of stones and flowers. Same with the trees. Just bad, sorry. I do like how you've tried to incorporate the ledges. But you used way too many and it just looks bad.

just cause the original FR maps are square doesnt mean we have to do the same mistake ;-)
everybody can work things out on their maps that they think are important. in my opinion the shape is like the most important feature of a map, so it shouldnt be boring

 

[Tyrantrum]

Well, not empty "space", just empty spots. ^_^"

 

[Neti]

i dont think so, i think he didnt overdo it or put too less stuff on the map. the placing is nice
but thats a matter of taste

 

[Tyrantrum]

Well, I guess I'm seeing it in a weird way! :P
Overall, the map is good. :)

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

dshayabusa was talking about how good the shape of the Sevii Islands were, not how bad!

 

[Tyrantrum]

Here's a map by me! :D

 

[Chimchar 9]

Here's a map by me! :D

its really good not to square nice tiles good and small as what your good at but too many flower's for me accept that i like it i give you 9/10 well done

 

[Neti]

thats a beautiful palette you made there Eeveon

 

[Chimchar 9]

i just made a map without trying but you might like it so here it is

please vote

 

[Tyrantrum]

@Neti: That's a Rom Base by Christos! XD

@riolu9: It's very good, and the mountains keep it from being too empty.
Of course, about the ledges:
1. U can jump onto the rock! O.o
2. The tiny ledges should look like that. :\
...9/10

 

[Austinia]

Here, check out this forest I made :D

Its for a event to catch celebi :) please tell me what you think!

 

[.:God:.]

Here, check out this forest I made :D

Its for a event to catch celebi :) please tell me what you think!

This is for Oak's Murder? I'm a fan of it... that's one thing. And 2. the rating:

I'll give it a... 7.5/10

Why?
Props:
Nice and long, keeps the player going
Grass is placed well

Slops:
Kinda too long... it would get boring
And since I can't see the tile errors, there are probably a ton. Now... for my map:

It's the first map for Pokemon Revelation. Here it is: Techlabo Town!

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

The house's shape is funny...
But...oh well.
Let's see...
The flowers at the bottom are disturbing...Too many of them.
The paths are dodgy...
And the house has tile errors galore.
Also, it's very unrealistic. Who would want ONE LITTLE bit of room to walk in?
5/10

Now for my own map

Spoiler:

 

[Austinia]

This is for Oak's Murder? I'm a fan of it... that's one thing. And 2. the rating:

I'll give it a... 7.5/10

Why?
Props:
Nice and long, keeps the player going
Grass is placed well

Slops:
Kinda too long... it would get boring
And since I can't see the tile errors, there are probably a ton. Now... for my map:

It's the first map for Pokemon Revelation. Here it is: Techlabo Town!

There are not many tile errors, I don't think anyways. And I noticed its kinda long :s but its to get celebi! So, I guess the player will have to endure it :p You also go back in time--- erm.... yea.... ;)

Your map- 7/10 tiles placed kinda weird and hard to navigate through the town, but overall its pretty nice.

 

[Tyrantrum]

 

[FinalEclipse]

Here is another map of mine.

Map Name: A random town.

Map Game: Firered using the Super DP rombase (credit to X buster for it)

Comments: This is just for the ratings.

Mapshot:

 

[Austinia]

Anyone care to rate Apricoa city? :D

back in time town.