Map Rating/Review Thread

[- Sigma -]

Thnx. I am working on another map.
Oh, and... Your rating?

9/10. It looks great. XD I can't wait for more of your awesome maps, Neminoa.

 

[-Link-]

Map Name:Mondercose Town
Map Game: Fire-red
Comments:Worked on for 1 hour and 30 min...
It's the best map I've made. Please rate.

Spoiler:

Nice one...
9/10.
Like - Sigma - and Earthsvisoter said, the top mountin
looks kinda wird. Good job anyways.

 

[Binary]

Wow I think thats a very creative map, but the block you used for the top part of the mountain is not the appropriate block that should be used,
else I think that the connections of the paths and the town look absolutely amazing, but i could see a few minor errors. But the map gets an overall rating of:
9/10
Ive seen that you put alot of effort on to it and you may be an expert mapper one day.

~Celebi

 

[Nytkoi]

Elow! XD
It's me again, and thanks for rating my previous map, which was Destral City.
Now I'm gonna wish that you'll rate this little route o'mine. It's IRON PATH, that would be available later in the game.
Thanks in advance! ;)

Spoiler:

Incredible! Extremly well done, mabye a bit too much grass, but overall
FANTASTIC! 9/10
Oh, forgot:
Map Name:Route 345
Map Game:Firered.
COmments: The route after Mondercose, rate please.

Spoiler:

 

[Zanacross]

Incredible! Extremly well done, mabye a bit too much grass, but overall
FANTASTIC! 9/10
Oh, forgot:
Map Name:Route 345
Map Game:Firered.
COmments: The route after Mondercose, rate please.

Spoiler:

Its very confusing

I don't know if I'm coming or going

Theres a few errors

I still think you need to edit the pallets

but overall 6/10

 

[Nytkoi]

@Zanacross: Using punctuation wouldn't hurt, would it?

@neminoa: Anyways, I am not very fond of the map of Route 345 you made. Same for the town you made. First: Too busy. Then: Too buggy. All you can do is improve the maps rapidly. It's nice to let your ego grow on people who don't see a good map very often, but if you really want some improvement, you need some constructive criticsm and so I am here. Put less houses. Make the map look natural. My dear, inspire yourself with the real nature. Or at least with hacks of higher quality :P

4/10

Hmmm, okay. I will work on it. Thnx anyways.

 

[suoert]

here's a map I've been making. I think it's quite nice but that's just my opinion
pleas tell me what I did wrong or what I could improve!

 

[Zanacross]

That is very very nice

i love the rock pallet
and well all the pallets.

the tree's are even better
10/10

 

[Nytkoi]

here's a map I've been making. I think it's quite nice but that's just my opinion
pleas tell me what I did wrong or what I could improve!

A little empty and If it's the first town it has too much.
6.5/10

That is very very nice

i love the rock pallet
and well all the pallets.

the tree's are even better
10/10

Tsk. You's give anything with new tiles 10/10

 

[Zanacross]

A little empty and If it's the first town it has too much.
6.5/10

Tsk. You's give anything with new tiles 10/10

i think this is a very good map and the tiles look very nice

this is also more then you have done.

you've just made it complected.

Also he sas nothing about it being the first town.

 

[EarthsVisitor]

@neminoa: Anyways, I am not very fond of the map of Route 345 you made. Same for the town you made. First: Too busy. Then: Too buggy. All you can do is improve the maps rapidly. It's nice to let your ego grow on people who don't see a good map very often, but if you really want some improvement, you need some constructive criticsm and so I am here.
4/10

Don't get too elitist, Martin2.
Everyone is held to their own opinion, so what you might think is a good map, I might think differently.
You make it sound like everyone else's opinion doesn't matter, and that we all don't know what we're talking about, or are unexperienced.
:/

Nevertheless

Neminoa: Route 345
Nowhere near as good as your last town map.
The grass is too organized and in very random spots.
The map itself is very unorganized, and has alot of meaningless areas.
The rock sculpture is not good.
Still have tiles error, especially the tip of every mountain, it shouldn't be a mountain tile, it's a grass tile with a brown strip on the top of it.
5.5/10

 

[Binary]

here's a map I've been making. I think it's quite nice but that's just my opinion
pleas tell me what I did wrong or what I could improve!

Good I like the use of the mountain blocks and the pals and mountain tile look great. But I could see some minor errors so be carefull. 8/10

Incredible! Extremly well done, mabye a bit too much grass, but overall
FANTASTIC! 9/10
Oh, forgot:
Map Name:Route 345
Map Game:Firered.
COmments: The route after Mondercose, rate please.

Spoiler:

Its a fairly good map, I like the pathways used, but like before you didnt use the top part of the mountain tile and there are a few errors I could spot out.
7/10

~Celebi

 

[thethethethe]

I felt a bit bored so I decided to make a map.
Name: ???
Game: Fire-Red
Additional Comments: It's a bit big so it's in the spoiler. It's nothing special, just a random map I decided to make. It only took me about an hour.

Spoiler:

 

[Blazichu]

I felt a bit bored so I decided to make a map.
Name: ???
Game: Fire-Red
Additional Comments: It's a bit big so it's in the spoiler. It's nothing special, just a random map I decided to make. It only took me about an hour.

Spoiler:

I don't mind this map, maybe change the grass seeing as it is a DP sort of style and with the house with the bridge. Fix that up so that it is only cliff stairs, the bridge makes it appear strange and also behind that house add some floor grass so it appears that the floor grass goes from front to back.

My Rating is a 8/10.

 

[Nytkoi]

I felt a bit bored so I decided to make a map.
Name: ???
Game: Fire-Red
Additional Comments: It's a bit big so it's in the spoiler. It's nothing special, just a random map I decided to make. It only took me about an hour.

Spoiler:

That looks pretty good. I think it it gets 8.5/10

 

[Binary]

I felt a bit bored so I decided to make a map.
Name: ???
Game: Fire-Red
Additional Comments: It's a bit big so it's in the spoiler. It's nothing special, just a random map I decided to make. It only took me about an hour.

Spoiler:

The different tiles are scattered everywhere. Ohwell overall i like your map. Its not square and I could not spot many errors but you used the wrong tile for the top of the mountain there.
Else I think its a very good try.
8/10

~Celebi

 

[强有力]

Got bored, made a map. Changed the lightness of the pallette, and the actual pallette.
Rate please
Map Name: West Canyon
Info: Have to go through a series of caves to get to the other end.
Map:

Spoiler:

 

[Lady Berlitz]

Got bored, made a map. Changed the lightness of the pallette, and the actual pallette.
Rate please
Map Name: West Canyon
Info: Have to go through a series of caves to get to the other end.
Map:

Spoiler:

I don't see any mistakes, Raeden. Keep up your mapping, it's great!

9/10.

Here's a map I created. Actually, it's the first I ever put up here to be rated. And I won't spoil you with what it is... okay, I'll give you a hint: It's the first city in one of the Pokemon games that have only 4 cities in it...

Spoiler:

 

[Nytkoi]

I don't see any mistakes, Raeden. Keep up your mapping, it's great!

9/10.

Here's a map I created. Actually, it's the first I ever put up here to be rated. And I won't spoil you with what it is... okay, I'll give you a hint: It's the first city in one of the Pokemon games that have only 4 cities in it...

Spoiler:

Well, Its pretty plain, and the orange roffed house, the mountain on the back of it,
that is not the right mountain tile. Put more house and details. Its pretty good besides all that. 6.8/10

 

[Lady Berlitz]

Well, Its pretty plain, and the orange roffed house, the mountain on the back of it,
that is not the right mountain tile. Put more house and details. Its pretty good besides all that. 6.8/10

Well, it's a remake of another game so blame Nintendo lol.
And the back of the orange house, the mountain on the back comes with the tile, so it's not my fault.