• Just a reminder that providing specifics on, sharing links to, or naming websites where ROMs can be accessed is against the rules. If your post has any of this information it will be removed.
  • Ever thought it'd be cool to have your art, writing, or challenge runs featured on PokéCommunity? Click here for info - we'd love to spotlight your work!
  • PokéCommunity's Easter Egg Hunt is now on! If you're interested in looking for some eggs and earning badges, click here!
  • Our weekly protagonist poll is now up! Vote for your favorite Conquest protagonist in the poll by clicking here.
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

Map Rating/Review Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
They r both perfect!
Beautiful graphics too!
All together...
1. 10/10
2. 10/10

Now time for my next map.
See attachments.
 
I give it a...9/10! I like how the PK Center is up on a mountain and the scenery. One thing though, fix the mountains behind the mart!
 
CheesePeow said:
Map 2
Thanks to Kyledove for the main tileset.
This is the first route in my hack.

Map 3
Thanks to Kyledove for the main tileset, Peyi for the PC & Mart.
The second town in my hack, Gym is relocated somewhere else :).

Maps are in attachments.
Click to expand...

The route looks really nice, i think its perfect except for onee thing: how do you get up?^^
so because of this major problem which is easy to fix: 9/10

The town: well, nothin to say here... 10/10
Eeveon said:
They r both perfect!
Beautiful graphics too!
All together...
1. 10/10
2. 10/10

Now time for my next map.
See attachments.
Click to expand...

Easy to see that you used Viridian City and just modified it... when you do taht you should first vanish the whole map and start from the beginning, not leave parts of it.
the next thing is that i dislike the mountains thee pkcenter and amrt are on, they look really unnatural...
and there is a tile error at the bottom of the bridge where it meets the water, fix that one.
Something that is quite good at your map is that you used different types of trees in a really good way, many people forget it or mess it up...
and the shape of your map is also nice
Rating: 7/10

_-TRAVIS-_ said:
The big map i managed to make!
"image removed"
Click to expand...

wow, this is a really huge map^^ the only thing i dislike is that the water borders are too straight.. .so 9/10
 
Neti said:
The route looks really nice, i think its perfect except for onee thing: how do you get up?^^
so because of this major problem which is easy to fix: 9/10

The town: well, nothin to say here... 10/10
Click to expand...

Well, the point was so you couldnt get back up :)
Cause theres a river in the first town, thats the only way to get back without fly, which you get later in the game.
 
CheesePeow said:
Map 2
Thanks to Kyledove for the main tileset.
This is the first route in my hack.

Map 3
Thanks to Kyledove for the main tileset, Peyi for the PC & Mart.
The second town in my hack, Gym is relocated somewhere else :).

Maps are in attachments.
Click to expand...
Town: 9.0/10
It looks superb! The paths are made beautifully and the tiles look great! I have a few problems with it though, a few tree placements look a little weird, the town is overly large and will look quite empty in-game and the tiles, while they look nice they're not very bright and Pokemon games are supposed to be bright aren't they? Well thats my opinion anyway.

Route: 9.5/10
Excellent placement of grass and the division with the trees good use of ledges too. The only problem is unless you open a path between the top half and the bottom half then the division on the bottom half is pointless and looks like it is only there to look good.

Eeveon said:
They r both perfect!
Beautiful graphics too!
All together...
1. 10/10
2. 10/10

Rating: 7/10
Its actually quite good if you forget about the tile errors. The size of the paths are not the same size which I don't like. The ledges are a little pointless. The mountains are pointless. If you get rid of the mountains and some of the thin trees and then fix it up a bit it'll look great.

Now time for my next map.
See attachments.
Click to expand...

_-TRAVIS-_ said:
The big map i managed to make!
"image removed"
Click to expand...
Rating: 5/10
Although there is quite a lot of bad mapping the fact that you made it this is big is very impressive. The random grass, although it says in a lot of tutorials that it is good, honestly dosn't look good if you make it as random as you have. The placement of trees that hinders your path will get really annoying to the player and don't look good anyway. The lake is way too straight and a bit of randomness to it. Theres a few tile errors and bunches of empty space. The best part of this map is the top left hand corner.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

My Map:
It's been a while since I did some mapping so I decided to make this map for some practice. I might use it for my hack, but if I do it'll be modified here and there. I don't really like how it came out but I can't really tell what I don't like about it. Maybe its the amount of trees...? Well anyway please rate and be as critical as possible.
 
New versions of my maps :D
~Starting Town(Help me think up of a name)~
Spoiler:

~Nature Village~
Spoiler:

~Route 1~
Spoiler:

~Path of Kyota~
Spoiler:
 
Here's my fixed Viridian City.
Also, that little house behind the PC, is where Nurse Joy keeps her medicine.
 
Tony the Awesome said:
New versions of my maps :D
~Starting Town(Help me think up of a name)~
Spoiler:

~Nature Village~
Spoiler:

~Route 1~
Spoiler:

~Path of Kyota~
Spoiler:
Click to expand...
Starter Town
Preety cool Starter town, different from most ones ;). I realy like it, however the Stoneds look "Random". 9.5/10

Nature Village
Wow, nice big map filled with a lot of things ;D. The house in the water brings me back to Venice. Awesome! 10/10

Route 1
Nice Route, I hate routes because they're common And they Sound Weird. This route is nice, the mountain in the middle. however preety plain. 7/10

Path of Kayota
Sounds Cooler ;) Yeah! now that looks really cool. No complaints! You're a cool Mapper ;D.

You're Probably 8.5 - 9 level Mapper. That is so awesome, if I'm doing a hack, you're my mapper.
 
I've posted this twice already and got no rating, so ill try again

Map Name: Aurum Town (Aurum is Latin for Gold)
Hack Name:Pokemon Dragon Flame (follow sig)
Hack of: Fire Red with Super D/P rom base

[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread
 
I have some maps here. Three have already been rated, but I want them all rated again. And with some thought :)
They are in the attachments.

Evergreen Town
Description: The starting town, the map is empty because it is the starting town, I tried to make it nice and simple for the start of the game. The river leads up to the other side of the region. Which can only be reached after you get a certain badge, even if you manage to get surf without it.

Route 1
Description: The route is nice and simple, you can follow your own path through the route, but halfway through you wont be able to get back. Though that was the point of the map, you cannot go back until you get fly. I used the ledges because these few towns are on a massive hill, which wont have much detail until later routes and towns.

Froma City
Description: Again a nice and simple town. There are a few mysteries behind the town, and in the top left corner lives the elder of the town. You get a bit of storyline from there. The river leads down to a massive lake. And no, it doesnt contain one of the legendary lake Pokemon.

Route 2
Description: This route basically sets off the complications around the rest of the region, the small paths that dont have much grass have cut trees, to prevent you from going across to quickly. The house in the middle is where you get fly, instead of flash, like the original FireRed. This is also where you battle your rival for the first time.

Rockham City
Description: It is a WIP, I havent finished adding all the tiles, which will include a path instead of that busy ground. The bottom half is the place where people befriend Pokemon, while the top is a town with no courtesy for any type of Pokemon. The gym used to be there, but when these conflicts started it left for a different place, which you will find later in the game.

Cant have six attachments ;(.

The maps go from left to right in the attachments, so make sure you know which one your rating. : )
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top