Map Rating/Review Thread

[negative]

Hi! This is my new map I made for my hack-Route 1 ! Please Rate Everything exept the lack of NPCs-they will be added after...:

 

[Mr.Fury]

New map.
Three maps put together starter town, route, and a nice lake. :)
coming soon: A very large city.
Credits: Mew_Ryn and Forgotten Memory

*big map*

Spoiler:

Repost

And G@mbit I really like your map! very simple and well layed out, i really like those tree tiles, and the pallets are very nice. If you possibly need help with your hack ill help you out, send me a pm. :)
8/10
Suggestion: maybe take out some of the rocks and the grass on the bottom is kinda un-needed unless you put an item down there tempting them.

 

[Disturbed]

Am I crazy for rating maybe 10 maps at once? Of course! I'm only going to say one thing though, and rate it, because I don't want to fully rate like 10 of these... (Estimate :P)

fire red base
name: im not really sure
comments: this took me 30 minutes to do and i was thinking of posting it here because i think it was really good as i did do it in 30 minutes anyway here is the map

map:



please rate

Waterfalls are not right, look at cape brink (thanks colcolstyles)
6/10

A really stupid map I made.
I thought it was good, but..meh. =\

Map Name: N/A
Map of: Fire Red
Comments: N/A
Credits: Satoshi Sogumori - inserting; Alistair - tiles

I will take any kind of criticism.

EDIT: PS- It's supposed to be a tiny little route.

You can see the borders at some points.
7/10

Sorry to add to the growing number of posts without ratings. I've recently felt like my mapping skills have been declining, every map I make seems really ugly to me.

Map Name: Gaia City
Description: Second to last Gym Leader. Home to the CEO of Uriel Enterprises. The paths really annoy me but I don't know what I should do about them. Those two joined buildings will be replaced by the Game Corner.

Spoiler:

Scatter trees better, give more shape to the water
7/10

Map Name: Fiore Town
Description: Home of the flying gym leader. Its purposely empty because it will be filled with many people and Pokemon. It just looks really really boring to me.

Spoiler:

Nothing wrong with this map, except you can scatter trees better
9/10

Map Name: Dracovia Village
Description: I actually like this town for the most part. It looks too similar to a town from Semeles hack though. The last town in Serao and home to the last Gym Leader (Dragon).

Spoiler:

There are a bunch of tile errors, and maybe you can add more rocks. (Look on the green splotches.)
4/10

Map Name: --no name--

Map Game: FireRed

Comments: Thanks to Whack a Hack for the snowy tileset and palettes. It's ment to be the first town (an island in sevii island).

Mapshot:

Stairs aren't right, and maybe there could be a few more trees.
6/10

Now for my map
Name: none
Fire Red
Creds: Neti's rombase

I know I know its definitley as over used as garachomp but at least I waited for everyone to stop making a lot of them. :P



^Click me
Rate please.

Scatter trees better, make ice have better shape
6/10

@Mr.Fury: The only problem I see with your map is, it is too empty.
7/10~
------------------------------------------------
It appears as I have been skipped..LIKE usual. -_-;

Hmm... I was too

Hi everyone, well I need help. This is a map rating thread so I need you to judge my map and tell me what am I missing and what I can do better.

Map name: Babeil City
BaseROM: Fire Red
Comments: The first very place you visit in Nohmen region (my hack's region). You start on S.S. Dallie, get out and reach Babeil Harbor, then, at the left, here you are: Babeil City.

And this one...

Map name: Route 242
BaseROM: Fire Red
Comments:
The second route you reach in game, I thinks It's OK but I accept critisism.

Please rate and tell me what to add to Babeil City or what to remove/change. I'm out of creativity. Maybe I will make less square the cave on Route 242.

Map 1: Umm, obvious things, the cliffs need better shape and the map is generally empty
2/10

Map 2: Thicken trees, scatter more, give better shapes
2/10

I didn't get any rating on this so here it is again. I am going to change the tiles soon.
game:re red
name:celebi's forest floor 1.
It's a maze.

Oh come on, you cant give better shape to the mountains? It's also lacking shape. And is every tree on the left a tile error, and also vanishing trees at the bottom is horrible
4/10 (difficulty helped, since it was a maze) (if it wasnt a maze, itd be a 1)

New map.
Three maps put together starter town, route, and a nice lake. :)
coming soon: A very large city.
Credits: Mew_Ryn and Forgotten Memory

*big map*

Spoiler:

You need a better border to get through this map unglitched. The door goes on the left side of the house too, not the right, thats why you are doing it wrong every time.

5/10




------
Sorry for the poor ratings, but I didn't want to fully rate all of these, I'd be here forever
:P

 

[DarkShadow]

Map Name: Altomore city

Map Game: Made in ruby

Comments: Your comments about your Map.I ama very bad mapper and wish to no how this map is so i can insert it into my hack also i do not have a tiler so these were the tiles i had to wrok with

Mapshot:

 

[Banjora Marxvile]

... Don't get me started... Whats wrong with grass or beachline? Pokemon Center glitched up, though you couldn't retile, so I'll let that past...

4/10... I'm sorry, but Why not use a different tileset altogether. Well, all you really need is a connection from land into sea. Look at other maps to get the hang of good maps, especially when the land connects to water, then try again.

 

[Disturbed]

Map Name: Altomore city

Map Game: Made in ruby

Comments: Your comments about your Map.I ama very bad mapper and wish to no how this map is so i can insert it into my hack also i do not have a tiler so these were the tiles i had to wrok with

Mapshot:

0/10

I'm pretty sure this whole map is one big tile error. Sorry ><

 

[DarkShadow]

i no i needed that well i guess i desvere that

 

[Geeked]

Map Name: Altomore city

Map Game: Made in ruby

Comments: Your comments about your Map.I ama very bad mapper and wish to no how this map is so i can insert it into my hack also i do not have a tiler so these were the tiles i had to wrok with

Mapshot:

WHAT THE **** dude, it's a giant error.. I'm sorry if I sounded harsh but -10/10

 

[Satoshi Sugimori]

New map by me :D It connects with my last map the woods..

 

[TB Pro]

fire red base
name: im not really sure
comments: this took me 30 minutes to do and i was thinking of posting it here because i think it was really good as i did do it in 30 minutes anyway here is the map

map:



please rate

Suggestions: Make the mountains less square. Fill up empty space. Make the paths less random.
Rating: 5.5/10
Comments: Waterfalls aren't right. Guys, really, you HAVE to give credit for a base/tiles you are using.

A really stupid map I made.
I thought it was good, but..meh. =\

Map Name: N/A
Map of: Fire Red
Comments: N/A
Credits: Satoshi Sogumori - inserting; Alistair - tiles

I will take any kind of criticism.

EDIT: PS- It's supposed to be a tiny little route.

Suggestions: Add more large trees, and remove some little ones. Make the map a bit bigger.
Rating: 6.5/10
Comments: Nice route, just a bit small. The grass tile looks disturbing...

Sorry to add to the growing number of posts without ratings. I've recently felt like my mapping skills have been declining, every map I make seems really ugly to me.

Map Name: Gaia City
Description: Second to last Gym Leader. Home to the CEO of Uriel Enterprises. The paths really annoy me but I don't know what I should do about them. Those two joined buildings will be replaced by the Game Corner.

Spoiler:

Suggestions: Scatter some more trees. Fill up empty space. Give more shape to the water. Make the mountains less straight, and following the same path.
Rating: 7/10
Comments: Pretty good map.

Map Name: Fiore Town
Description: Home of the flying gym leader. Its purposely empty because it will be filled with many people and Pokemon. It just looks really really boring to me.

Spoiler:

Suggestions: Scatter some more trees around. Fill up some empty space. Remove some flowers.
Rating: 7/10
Commets: Pretty swell map.

Map Name: Dracovia Village
Description: I actually like this town for the most part. It looks too similar to a town from Semeles hack though. The last town in Serao and home to the last Gym Leader (Dragon).

Spoiler:

Suggestions: Make the mountains less straight, and following the same path. Add some more rocks.
Rating: 5/10
Commets: Just a bit small.

Map Name: --no name--

Map Game: FireRed

Comments: Thanks to Whack a Hack for the snowy tileset and palettes. It's ment to be the first town (an island in sevii island).

Mapshot:

Suggestions: Make the mountains less straight. Add some more trees.
Rating: 6/10
Comments: Not bad, not great.

Hi everyone, well I need help. This is a map rating thread so I need you to judge my map and tell me what am I missing and what I can do better.

Map name: Babeil City
BaseROM: Fire Red
Comments: The first very place you visit in Nohmen region (my hack's region). You start on S.S. Dallie, get out and reach Babeil Harbor, then, at the left, here you are: Babeil City.

Suggestions: Make the mountains less straight, and let them flow wherever the want, not following the same path. Fill up empty space. Give more shape to the water. The paths in the center of the map are bad, make them less awkward. The hedges at the lower area of the map look bad, remove them.
Rating: 1/10
Comments: YOU CANNOT USE ZEL'S TILES.

Map name: Route 242
BaseROM: Fire Red
Comments:
The second route you reach in game, I thinks It's OK but I accept critisism.

Suggestions: Thicken trees, give them more shape. Make the mountains less square, Make them follow their own path, not the same one. Remove some boulders. Give the water better shape.
Rating: 1.5/10
Comments: Please don't use those tiles >.<

New map.
Three maps put together starter town, route, and a nice lake. :)
coming soon: A very large city.
Credits: Mew_Ryn and Forgotten Memory

*big map*

Spoiler:

Suggestions: Make the paths less straight. Change the arrangement of trees, it looks weird.
Rating: 7/10
Comments: Not bad.

Hi! This is my new map I made for my hack-Route 1 ! Please Rate Everything exept the lack of NPCs-they will be added after...:

Suggestions: Fill up empty space. Add more tall grass. Make the mountain less square.
Rating: 6.5/10
Comments: Really guys, give credit for tiles/Base used >.<

Map Name: Altomore city

Map Game: Made in ruby

Comments: Your comments about your Map.I ama very bad mapper and wish to no how this map is so i can insert it into my hack also i do not have a tiler so these were the tiles i had to wrok with

Mapshot:

Suggestions: Change...Everything.
Rating: 0/10
Comments: It's just one huge error, no tile looks right ont hat map.

New map by me :D It connects with my last map the woods..

Suggestions: Make the path less straight. Add a few more trees. Fill up some empty space.
Rating: 7.5/10
Comments: I hate the palettes :P

 

[Satoshi Sugimori]

Heres a new map I made worked on it like 1.5 hours or something :P I like it pretty much :D

Spoiler:

 

[Geeked]

Heres a new map I made worked on it like 1.5 hours or something :P I like it pretty much :D

Spoiler:

hmm.. The palletes scare me a bit, but lemme concentrate on the map..
The mountains are too symmetrical.. Try to start making your mountains more "Squiggly".. Kind of like when someones first learning cursive :p
I personally thing mountains look better like that, overall 7.2/10

 

[.Iramet]

Map Name: Altomore city

Map Game: Made in ruby

Comments: Your comments about your Map.I ama very bad mapper and wish to no how this map is so i can insert it into my hack also i do not have a tiler so these were the tiles i had to wrok with

Mapshot:

Dude you said I was going to be a mapper on your hack, you should not have even posted this until you let me see, and I will get you a better rom base or tilesets if you need.
0/10

 

[Tyrantrum]

Credits: Satoshi Sugimori - inserting; Alistair - tiles

 

[Darthatron]

Credits: Satoshi Sugimori - inserting; Alistair - tiles

It seems a bit empty, to be perfectly honest. The shape is good, and I like the tiles. I'd give it a 6/10, because it's empty.
_________

And here is my new map!

Name: Timber City
Credits: X-Buster for his Super DP Rom Base.
Map:

Rate please. ^^

 

[Fraot]

OK, thanx for the tip. I only wanted to improve my skills, the problem here is my creativity. But I've seen many maps from this thread, some are awful for me, I mean, flowers everywere and that stuff. But some of them are too simple but, weirdly, I consider them really cool: simple but marvelous (especially the ones that have DPP's tiles).

And I say this again: I already asked Zel for these tiles... also only the trees and some flowers are the same, the pokécenter too (for both pokecenter and pokémart). But not all of them, I don't consider necessary to have every tile. The grass pallettes, dirt green paths and the yellow ones are from a picture that Kyledove (Kymotonian) made.

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

Darthatron:

7.5/10
Not a bad map, in all! Because it's a city, I won't mark you down for the straight placement of houses. It looks a lot like a normal city...pretty good! I don't really have any more comments, except, seeing as you're going for the realistic city with the straight houses, make the trees more square at the bottom, it's likely people cleared them a bit. I guess that thing in the corner is a park? If so, make the grass either less random or completely nonexistant.

 

[andyp159]

Map Name: Pendulum Valley

Map Game: Emerald

Comments: Another map from Lance Adventures, the player comes in from the right from a small desert village, and there's another town at the top left. We posted this before here, but it kind of got ignored. Please rate, as feedback is important to us :)

 

[FoggyDoggy]

Map Name: Pendulum Valley

Map Game: Emerald

Comments: Another map from Lance Adventures, the player comes in from the right from a small desert village, and there's another town at the top left. We posted this before here, but it kind of got ignored. Please rate, as feedback is important to us :)

Hrmmm... I say 5/10
The Mountain is too... triangular, and symmetrical.
You can see the border on the left from the stairs, and those 3 random planter boxes that are arranged perfectly diagonal scare me. Like they scream, "RAWR!" in my face, makes me cry.
Finally, I don't like the shape of the sand from exiting the town. It is a but too square for my tastes.
Other than that, It is a nice map. :D

 

[loitraitim]

Here my work

Map name: Kymoto Town
Map game: Crazy[V]ie version...

Map name: Route Plate
Map game: Crazy[V]ie version...

Description: anyway... non

Credits by Kyodole ^^

Please comment and rate my maps ^^