Map Rating/Review Thread

[Satoshi Sugimori]

Fixed it.

Yes very nice :D
Now it looks wonderfull nothing to say about it now :P
my rating now: 9.7/10 not an 10 because perfection doesn't exist XD

 

[Hiche..]

Fixed it.

Wow! A perfect map :D
I like the path very much. The houses are placed nicely.
Rating: 9.2/10

 

[Dratii]

Fixed it.

Awesome map
Rating: 9.7
The only thing I dont really like is those orange things on the path.

Thanks Disturbed for your comments. I am fixing up the tree shadows now but I dont know how to fill the empty space

 

[エロカメ]

Name: Pallet Town (revamped)

Base: Fire Red

Credits: Xiderwong and Kyledove for the rombase.

Map Shot:

I'm not gonna rate because no one rated my one ;<

 

[Likewise]

credit to neti for the rome base.

 

[Dratii]

エロカメ I give your map 7.5/10.
Looks fairly good but I don't like your fence around the house

Map name: Route ???
Rom: FR
Comments: My fixed version on my map. Fixed tree shading and reduced empty space.

Once again wide so in a spoiler

Spoiler:

 

[Satoshi Sugimori]

I'm not gonna rate because no one rated my one ;<

lolz haven't seen this one...
well rate it now ;) I don't like the fences around the house... dunno a bit to much..
the city is a bit to crowded maybe because of the trees in the middle but still prettyt nice so 7.1/10

credit to neti for the rome base.

To be honest I'm really getting sick of that rom base everyone uses it XD but I can't judge on tiles.. it's pretty nice but you have such little walking space.. Rating 7.3/10

エロカメ I give your map 7.5/10.
Looks fairly good but I don't like your fence around the house

Map name: Route ???
Rom: FR
Comments: My fixed version on my map. Fixed tree shading and reduced empty space.

Once again wide so in a spoiler

Spoiler:

it's better than your other one it is nice now but I don't like the big open space in the upper middle it's just too wide and in the middle middle to ;)
Rating 7.9/10

 

[Dratii]

Yep it's fixed again

Map name: Route ???
Rom: FR
Comments: Remapped the center
In spoiler wide

Spoiler:

 

[Satoshi Sugimori]

Map name: Route ???
Rom: FR
Comments: Remapped the center
In spoiler wide

Spoiler:

it's nice now :D not really something to point out..8.9/10

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

I like it I like it, dratii
Best piece of work I've seen, I would say... Hmm...

I've got a tip! Put some good squiggly mountains in to remove empty space. I like mountains.

 

[Disturbed]

Map name: Route ???
Rom: FR
Comments: Remapped the center
In spoiler wide

Spoiler:

Looks great! All I can say is that you need to add small trees and maybe bushes!

8.9/10

I fixed it up, and made it look more realistic!

https://www.pokecommunity.com/showthread.php?t=81829&page=88

 

[Dratii]

Some of the tree shading was not right so here is a better version.

Spoiler:

With some bits.

 

[Golden Shaymin]

I hope this gets a fairly decent rating, it's for a new hack that I'm making, it's been shut off from the rest of the world but it's nearly ready for an appearance in the scrapbox

Credits:
CEll-Beach Rombase
Alastair-Some of the trees

I can't find any other credits

 

[Dratii]

Golden Shaymin I give your map 6.5/10
because it is too open, too empty, the big rocks don't really look good in the shallow water and there is tile errors. But over all it is a fairly good map. :)
How to make it better: Fill the empty spaces and fix the tile errors.


Okay here is a new one from me
Map name: Untitled (Starter town)
Rom: FR
Comments: This connects on to my other map. I am not really good at making towns so some constructive criticism would be good.

 

[Hiche..]

Golden Shaymin I give your map 6.5/10
because it is too open, too empty, the big rocks don't really look good in the shallow water and there is tile errors. But over all it is a fairly good map. :)
How to make it better: Fill the empty spaces and fix the tile errors.


Okay here is a new one from me
Map name: Untitled (Starter town)
Rom: FR
Comments: This connects on to my other map. I am not really good at making towns so some constructive criticism would be good.

Not a bad map.
The house has tiles errors(window sticked to door).
The map is kind of empty. Too much flower. Make the path to the right smaller(the one that leads to the other route).
Rating: 7/10

 

[Dratii]

Fixed

 

[destinedjagold]

@ Wind~'s fixed map...
next time, put a description or anything about your map...
RATINGS: 8/10
REASON: It's nice. The rock building must be holding something secret for the time being, which adds a little bit of 'mysterious' feel on that rock. :P
COMMENT: the white tile is actually cement, though.., and flowers are growing on cements...? :\


@ ~elements' ice-themed map
RATINGS: 6/10
REASON: Getting pretty common, and although the map is really well-created, but where does it lead? There's one entrance, but once the PLAYER jumps over the ledge, no exit to go(except to fly or to teleport)...
SUGGESTION: erm... add an exit?


@ dratii's route map...
RATINGS: 8/10
REASON: I like the map's zigzaggy pattern. though I guess adding more thin trees would make it even better, but I don't know...
SUGGESTION: nothing to suggest...


@ Disturbed's route-like map...
RATINGS: 9/10
REASON: I really like it. It's simple, yet very nice.
SUGGESTION: Nothing to suggest...


@ Golden Shaymin's beach map...
RATINGS: 4/10
REASON: Although the map looks nice, the tiles' background are wrong in usage, e.g., the wooden bridge and the boulder of the water.
SUGGESTION: Fix those tiles up. :\


@ dratii's untitled -fixed- starter map...
RATINGS: 8/10
REASON: too simple, yet I like it. :)
SUGGESTION: maybe add some windows on those houses? :\

 

[Likewise]

@ ~elements' ice-themed map
RATINGS: 6/10
REASON: Getting pretty common, and although the map is really well-created, but where does it lead? There's one entrance, but once the PLAYER jumps over the ledge, no exit to go(except to fly or to teleport)...
SUGGESTION: erm... add an exit?

well actually there is a hidden cave if you look closely.
and also the way to get to the cave needs a key item that is only in my game.

 

[Symbol]

Map Name: Selvia Town

Map Game: Pokemon Fire Red

Comments: This will be the starter map for my game.

Mapshot:



Credits: Visual for the rombase.

 

[iBlade]

I'll give you 6/10 ..

Here is mine .. no new tilesets .. and yeah .. please rate ..

Please rate :( ... I think you guys oversaw it ..