Map Rating/Review Thread

[manomow]

"Good but, those little houses are ugly :\ sorry 6.5/10"

hey you used the SAME houses. If its ugly, why are you using those houses.

 

[Neti]

"Good but, those little houses are ugly :\ sorry 6.5/10"

hey you used the SAME houses. If its ugly, why are you using those houses.

please quote properly, nobody knows who you are quoting and where we can read it

 

[~Teh Panda~]

"Good but, those little houses are ugly :\ sorry 6.5/10"

hey you used the SAME houses. If its ugly, why are you using those houses.

The little roofing on them.... Not the house itself.

 

[Tropical Sunlight]

Map name: Temple Entrance
Hack: Pokemon ??? (I'm not telling)
Base rom: FireRed English (BPRE)
Mapshot:

Comments: Guess what
Credits: Wesley FG for the temple tiles

I inserted the tiles myself! Am I good or not? (joke)

 

[sab]

Here is a map made by me I hope it is better han the last one I made.
https://img389.imageshack.us/img389/2244/coolliteralygx5.png
credit to neti for tiles.

 

[FoggyDoggy]

Here is a map made by me I hope it is better han the last one I made.
https://img389.imageshack.us/img389/2244/coolliteralygx5.png
credit to neti for tiles.

It is a nice map, pretty good overall, except the bridges... I dont like them, hehe...

7/10

 

[cooley]

Here is a map made by me I hope it is better han the last one I made.
https://img389.imageshack.us/img389/2244/coolliteralygx5.png
credit to neti for tiles.

The map looks like an edit of Route 1 in Firered. Please, make a completely new map , before attempting to create one. It is also very squared, and there isn't any particular reason for those three Cave entrances.

Final rating 7/10
Please fix your mistakes

 

[sasquatchd00d]

New map.

Comments: Half-forest, half-route. It's rather basic.
ROM: Fire Red BPRE
Map Name: Enare Timberland
Credits: Alistair - signpost

Map:

Spoiler:

 

[~Teh Panda~]

New map.

Comments: Half-forest, half-route. It's rather basic.
ROM: Fire Red BPRE
Map Name: Enare Timberland
Credits: Alistair - signpost

Map:

Spoiler:

Very nice placement of your tiles, 8/10

ACTUAL FINAL MAP EDIT OF MINE~

 

[пзо]

First map!

My first map ever! So I would like it if you dont post to harshly!

Map name: Un-named
Base: Pokemon Fire Red
Comments.. I always have room to change!

 

[~Teh Panda~]

My first map ever! So I would like it if you dont post to harshly!

Map name: Un-named
Base: Pokemon Fire Red
Comments.. I always have room to change!

7/10 for first map, a bit small plus bland, nice tree placement but a tile error on the right.
Also how do you get out?

 

[Binary]

Very nice placement of your tiles, 8/10

ACTUAL FINAL MAP EDIT OF MINE~

Rating: 9/10
Reason: I like the idea of the map. I like the road and the placement of the buildings. The Giratina-style building on the right looks nice. I don't like the green flowers. The petals can't be green, can they?

My first map ever! So I would like it if you dont post to harshly!

Map name: Un-named
Base: Pokemon Fire Red
Comments.. I always have room to change!

Rating: 8.5/10
Reason: For your first map it's very good. My first map was much much worse than this XD. The placement of the trees is good. But I don't like the combination of the D/P tree with the FR/LG tree. Nice little paths and I like the pond in the middle 8D. There are no connections, not that it matters much. And fix the error on the tree.

 

[zetavares85]

https://img120.imageshack.us/my.php?image=011234zx8.png

Map Name: New Island
Map Game: I didn't used Advance map to create it so it doesn't have a base game
Comments: As I've said I didn't used Advance Map, I used Tiled to make it; that's above the Orange Islands and below Sevii Islands. If you want to use it message me first.

 

[Makorin]

OK since i havnt post a map in a while i mite as well!

Map Name: Tohja Desert
Map Game: Fire Red
Comments: This map is a special area in my Hack Pokemon Golden Rainbow
Mapshot:

Map Name: Tohja Desert
Map Game: Fire Red
Comments: This map is a special area in my Hack Pokemon Golden Rainbow
Mapshot:

 

[Aljam]

Map name: SNOWDRIFT CITY
Hack name: Pokemon reign of fire

 

[Liquid Shadow]

Hey all, I made another map called Shorley Town.

Like I stated earlier, I'm new to mapping and this is only my third map, so please feel free to critique me and give me advice.

Here it is:

Quoting myself since nobody rated it... I think..

 

[Spherical Ice]

Map Name: WILD FOREST
Map of: FireRed
Mapshot: Click
Comments: Saved as .JPG to prevent theft (not that anyone would want to XP).

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

Map Name: WILD FOREST
Map of: FireRed
Mapshot: Click
Comments: Saved as .JPG to prevent theft (not that anyone would want to XP).

4/10
It's painfully grassy...Isn't there another way you could take up space? I mean, it's like you just used it as a filler.

Oh, and I DID steal it - although you can't really steal maps. If someone wanted that map in their game, they could just copy it from the site. :\ And as a file on the comp, it ain't much easier. :\

 

[Cheesymitten]

Map name: SNOWDRIFT CITY
Hack name: Pokemon reign of fire

Veeeery nice 9.5/10 i like how the tiles are in with everything i can't see any errors..... Good work!

 

[Binary]

Map Name: Route101
Base: Pokemon Ruby
Comments: A ma after a long time. It has no grass because the player doesn't have any pokemon at this stage.