Map Rating/Review Thread

[Griin.]

I've decided to post this forest because I doubt I'll use it for Distant, due to it's amazing difficulty. Ah well ><
Here is the biggest map I ever posted on this thread. Don't judge by it's huge amount of unplayability. It's meant to be nearly impossible. :D

Spoiler:

haha, just kidding. Look at the next spoiler for the actual biggest map I ever posted

Spoiler:

Wow that forest is amazing. Good job on it. Its really difficult. Um maybe add some more of those flower things and add maybe some paths.
8/10

 

[Alucia]

I've decided to post this forest because I doubt I'll use it for Distant, due to it's amazing difficulty. Ah well ><
Here is the biggest map I ever posted on this thread. Don't judge by it's huge amount of unplayability. It's meant to be nearly impossible. :D

Spoiler:

haha, just kidding. Look at the next spoiler for the actual biggest map I ever posted

Spoiler:

worked it out :P nice one disturbed the ting was difficult for sure but it was a little plane also if you were playing through the random battles would probably make you get lost very easily still the chalange was refreshing so 8/10

 

[Disturbed]

Another one >_>
Here's Resaga City

Spoiler:

 

[michaelh]

can someone please rate me this map i really want to know whats good and bad about it

7/10

Pros:

• Really nice custom tileset
• Good layout of route

Cons:

• Some tiles don't quite look correct.

Unfortunately, I do not have 15 posts so I cannot post images to correct this. I will PM you them instead.

If you fixed those I could confidently give you a 9/10 :)

Hope this helps,
Mike

EDIT: PM Sent. Check your inbox.

 

[Griin.]

Guys another one xD:
Map Name: Florem Town
Map Game: Firered / Solarium

I should remove those fences right ? =/

 

[negative]

Guys another one xD:
Map Name: Florem Town
Map Game: Firered / Solarium

I should remove those fences right ? =/

WOW! You came back from the break!
the map is nice and playable ,but remove some of the fences(or all) and replace them with some trees, beacouse the map would be too square then.If you are making with fences then make the same fences!
Overall:
9.5/10
Suggestions: Do as I told you :P

 

[Alucia]

7/10

Pros:

• Really nice custom tileset
• Good layout of route

Cons:

• Some tiles don't quite look correct.

Unfortunately, I do not have 15 posts so I cannot post images to correct this. I will PM you them instead.

If you fixed those I could confidently give you a 9/10 :)

Hope this helps,
Mike

EDIT: PM Sent. Check your inbox.

thanks a lot
i cant really see a way to fix to odd tile error type areas without them looking worse
the tiles are a mix of mine and kyledove's i made the large trees and both types of grass normal and long but the rest are kyledove's

 

[Visored]

Guys another one xD:
Map Name: Florem Town
Map Game: Firered / Solarium

I should remove those fences right ? =/

7/10
Yeah the fences look a little odd, i would take them out, spread the flowers out a bit more, have a little variation with the trees. Other than that a really nice little village.

***repost

 

[Alucia]

7/10
Yeah the fences look a little odd, i would take them out, spread the flowers out a bit more, have a little variation with the trees. Other than that a really nice little village.

***repost

sorry but the pic it too small

 

[Visored]

click on it -.- and rate please

 

[BananasGoMoo]

click on it -.- and rate please

theres nothing to click on. you try.

 

[Vrai]

theres nothing to click on. you try.

He was talking to the poster above him. -_-

As in, click on the thumbnail image.

Edit: xD

I didn't actually try it. Sorry 'bout that. Visored, you need to fix that link, 'cuz it doesn't connect. :D

 

[Disturbed]

Here is a map I made in Gold =D
My second or third map ever in gold
Oh, and on the corner of the mountains, that's how Nintendo did them, =P

Spoiler:

 

[0m3GA ARS3NAL]

Too much blank space 0m3GA. It is big enough as a city, but the space needs filling a little more. Try adding more buildings into it. The houses with a green roof have tile errors, so don't use them.

7/10

Actually, those houses are taken straight from Fire Red... no tile errors...
And to anyone who asked, the Lake is there for a reason, it ties into the story, including the house placement, and messy grass around it.
Everything in my map is there for a reason, and no, there are no border errors, I checked...

Anywho, I wanna rate...

Rejnbow's Map

Guys another one xD:
Map Name: Florem Town
Map Game: Firered / Solarium

I should remove those fences right ? =/

I give this map a good 9/10
I like the Fences to be honest, makes it seem more of a town instead of a village.
I like hte house placement and paths work well.
Keep it up!

 

[Megiddo-san]

Map Name: None
Game: Firered
Credit to Saurav for tiles.

 

[Braeden23000]

Map Name - Edge City
Map Game - Ruby

Note - Has a few tile problems caused by using the default tiles (eg. left side of gym.) And, yes, cities usually dont have tall grass, but i wanted a garden, and all the same flowers looked bad, will be fixed with new tileset. Its inaccessible anyway.

 

[tImE]

And now for a map from me:

Map Name: Olivine City
Map Game: Firered BPRE

//44tim44

I'm bumping myself to this page since, my map was ignored,
and nobody rates maps from the previous pages.

 

[aeroshinobi]

I'm bumping myself to this page since, my map was ignored,
and nobody rates maps from the previous pages.

Are you attempting to do an exact remake?

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

I'm bumping myself to this page since, my map was ignored,
and nobody rates maps from the previous pages.

Well, it's a good remake. There are no tile errors, and it's Olivine as I remember it.

...Which leads me to wonder whether I remember it at all.

Nonetheless, it's a good remake, but the lighthouse's proportions are dodgy-looking.

9/10

 

[Cheesymitten]

Map Name - Edge City
Map Game - Ruby

Note - Has a few tile problems caused by using the default tiles (eg. left side of gym.) And, yes, cities usually dont have tall grass, but i wanted a garden, and all the same flowers looked bad, will be fixed with new tileset. Its inaccessible anyway.

This seems incredibly quite and peaceful :) maybye make it a bit more spaced out great work though :)