So I've found an interesting development already:
If a person is innocent they would likely follow Johnny's plan, or at least as closely as humanly possible (for example: I didn't vote for the person who posted before me because I got ninja'd, so my vote was for the person two posts above me).
In contrast, if a person
does not follow this within reason then they could be painted as suspects. More so because the mafia can guarantee who it is they wish to kill this day phase since it is 100% determined by Dialga's vote. So, has anyone strayed from what has been suggested? Yes, two players:
Catmandatrainer voted for grey bidoof who has yet to post at all (let alone post before catman) where if catman was following Johnny - he would have been the one to vote for Johnny and not I.
Personally I find the second offender as more suspicious: Bardothren. Why? He voted for Superjolt, another player yet to post in the game - despite still having (at the very least, myself) to vote for out of who has posted already. Secondly, I think we all agree Superjolt is a pretty good player, especially when innocent (he has a tendency to get lots of players to talk and share reads, etc.). This can be a thorn in the mafia's side, so this way they can kill Superjolt off with Dialga before he find out his true identity.
As things stand, I am highly suspicious of Bard atm for being Dialga and wanting to take Superjolt out before he dies.
edit: Aaaaaand Bard just killed Catman, interesting. My strong suspicions still remain.