ericgall23
Quiet Pokémon fan
- 36
- Posts
- 7
- Years
- Canada
- Seen Dec 30, 2023
Hi there! :)
I played your game up to the end! I want to say that I really loved it! It's awesome, very well done and it was very fun in most cases! It brings back memories from HGSS in Kanto, which is really good!
What I really liked in your game:
- The new sprites for the Pokémon, as well as the new mini-sprites for them! It feels like your game is really unique, and in some cases, better than the original! :) The fact that each Pokémon has it's own mini-sprite is really awesome, and it should have been this way in the originals as well! Very good job! ;) ;)
- New movesets for most Pokémon! This makes your game more unique, and exciting too, and different too! ;)
- You kept the original 251 Pokémon and the same moves as Gen 2! It's very important for trading with TGB DUAL with all games, including originals! ;) Thanks for keeping those the same! ;)
- The moves got updated up to Gen 8! This is truly awesome, coz I do this in all my Gold version games (since 2018 precisely), but I keep them up to Gen 7 (which is very good enough), and always, coz I want the same basis for all my Gold version games, and my future ones too! I'm very glad that I'm not the only who do this! Thanks for doing this as well! Very good job! ;)
- TMs compatibility have also been updated up to Gen8 for most Pokémon (Well, I tried teaching Sweet Scent to my Teddiursa via TM12, but it can't learn it, even though it learn Sweet Scent via level-up, but it's alright and i don't care much about Sweet scent, coz it was just for trying it!)! This is really awesome that you did this as well, and I do this too in my Gold version games as well! Very good job for this too! ;)
- The fact that TMS are reusable all the time, like HMs! This is a huge improvement, and I couldn't believe it!!! This is REally awesome for sure! I was feeling like I played Black2, the best and last game I bought! It's really fun to have TMs that are reusable! It should have been this way in all games since the first one! A very good job for this significant and important change! ;)
- The fact that use of HMs are replaced by a brand new fonction, the Pager! This is also very huge improvement, and it's so convenient and awesome!!! I didn't believe it too, and it could have always been a feature present in all games since the first ones! Because of it, we don't need to teach weak or useless moves in fight like Cut and Flash anymore, and it's a very welcome change! Thanks a lot for doing this too! A very well done job too! ;)
- The fact we can reuse a repel when one is finished! I remember this feature was in Black2 too, and it's really convenient too! Thanks for putting this too! Well done! ;)
- Kanto Gyms and most Kanto trainers got updated and stronger! Thanks a lot for this, coz Kanto was really more fun and more challenging than the original game! ;)
- The new areas (Viridian Forest, Cerulean Cave, Seafoam Cave, Yellow Forest, Route 47-48 and Pokémon Mansion are all really awesome and very well done! They really feel like we're playing HG/SS in most of them. However, the brand new one: Yellow Forest (instead of Safari Zone), is really cool too, but I wonder where it come from? Whatever, seeing new places is always awesome in a game, and love differences! ;) Good job for all of this! ;)
- The new musics for Routes 47-48, Yellow Forest, Cerulean City and Routes 24-25, as well as legendray battles musics, are all very well done and enjoyable! Very good job for this! ;)
- Blue's Gym was really cool and awesome! A great memory from HG-SS! ;) Thanks so much! ;)
- GS Ball is obtainable in your game, and so, we can get Celebi!
However, here's what I liked less in your game:
- Well, most trainers in Johto, including the Gyms and Elite Four, are the same as in the original game! However, since there are new movesets for Pokémon, it's not that of a problem! But, I would have liked some differences, even little...
- Most dialogs (like 98%) are the same as the original game. However, it's not that of a problem too, since it's still Johto and Kanto... It's alright!
- It was funny that a boy in Cerulean City talks about Cerulean Cave in the past form ("There used to be a cave...), when in reality, in your game, the cave is still present and we clearly see it! :) It's just funny and weird!
- Why would we buy TM29 (Psychic) at Celadon Game Corner when we can get it for free in Mr. Psychic's house in Saffron City? At least, there's a verification of this! (Good job for this! );) Also, the fact that TM33, TM41 and TM48 are both sold in the two big marts (Goldenrod and Celadon) is redondant. I think all TMs should be sold/obtained in one place...(it's not that of a problem, but it would make more sense.)
- The new Pokémon Center on Route 3 is nice, but if you lose a battle after exiting it, you're sent back in your home, in New Bark Toen (Johto)... I know a solution: Make a jealing house with a tilest from an house (like the one on Route 26 where you can heal your Pokémon) The reason for this is the Pokémon Center tileset (well, it's this way in a gold version game). Believe me! ;) Otherwise, it's not so "grave", coz we can always use fly via the Pager to return all the way to Pewter City, and so to Mt.Moon or Route 3.
- The fact the adventure is mostly the same as the original game, but it's not a big problem... I was expecting this, so it's alright.
Bref, I'm really proud to have played your game, and I will keep it in my games for sure, coz I want to play it again in the future! You did a very excellent job (sometimes even better than me!). I truly respect your work and your skills, and it's clear that you put a lot of work, passion and love into it! :) I felt it all the way in my adventure in your game! ;) Also, I think we have things in common in this domain, and I sincerely love what you done, and I'm sure that if we were to know each other in the real life, we could get along very well, coz it's clear that we have a passion for creating games and Pokémon! ;) However, i don't think this will happen ever, but it's alright! ;) Don't worry! ;) I just support you! ;)
If you have made some other games (Gen 1 or Gen 2 with same original Pokémon and original moves (but moves can be updated up to Gens later, like 3 to 8)), I will be very interested to try them! ;)
I sincerely wish you the best success and luck in your fututre projects, if you have some others! ;)
I played your game up to the end! I want to say that I really loved it! It's awesome, very well done and it was very fun in most cases! It brings back memories from HGSS in Kanto, which is really good!
What I really liked in your game:
- The new sprites for the Pokémon, as well as the new mini-sprites for them! It feels like your game is really unique, and in some cases, better than the original! :) The fact that each Pokémon has it's own mini-sprite is really awesome, and it should have been this way in the originals as well! Very good job! ;) ;)
- New movesets for most Pokémon! This makes your game more unique, and exciting too, and different too! ;)
- You kept the original 251 Pokémon and the same moves as Gen 2! It's very important for trading with TGB DUAL with all games, including originals! ;) Thanks for keeping those the same! ;)
- The moves got updated up to Gen 8! This is truly awesome, coz I do this in all my Gold version games (since 2018 precisely), but I keep them up to Gen 7 (which is very good enough), and always, coz I want the same basis for all my Gold version games, and my future ones too! I'm very glad that I'm not the only who do this! Thanks for doing this as well! Very good job! ;)
- TMs compatibility have also been updated up to Gen8 for most Pokémon (Well, I tried teaching Sweet Scent to my Teddiursa via TM12, but it can't learn it, even though it learn Sweet Scent via level-up, but it's alright and i don't care much about Sweet scent, coz it was just for trying it!)! This is really awesome that you did this as well, and I do this too in my Gold version games as well! Very good job for this too! ;)
- The fact that TMS are reusable all the time, like HMs! This is a huge improvement, and I couldn't believe it!!! This is REally awesome for sure! I was feeling like I played Black2, the best and last game I bought! It's really fun to have TMs that are reusable! It should have been this way in all games since the first one! A very good job for this significant and important change! ;)
- The fact that use of HMs are replaced by a brand new fonction, the Pager! This is also very huge improvement, and it's so convenient and awesome!!! I didn't believe it too, and it could have always been a feature present in all games since the first ones! Because of it, we don't need to teach weak or useless moves in fight like Cut and Flash anymore, and it's a very welcome change! Thanks a lot for doing this too! A very well done job too! ;)
- The fact we can reuse a repel when one is finished! I remember this feature was in Black2 too, and it's really convenient too! Thanks for putting this too! Well done! ;)
- Kanto Gyms and most Kanto trainers got updated and stronger! Thanks a lot for this, coz Kanto was really more fun and more challenging than the original game! ;)
- The new areas (Viridian Forest, Cerulean Cave, Seafoam Cave, Yellow Forest, Route 47-48 and Pokémon Mansion are all really awesome and very well done! They really feel like we're playing HG/SS in most of them. However, the brand new one: Yellow Forest (instead of Safari Zone), is really cool too, but I wonder where it come from? Whatever, seeing new places is always awesome in a game, and love differences! ;) Good job for all of this! ;)
- The new musics for Routes 47-48, Yellow Forest, Cerulean City and Routes 24-25, as well as legendray battles musics, are all very well done and enjoyable! Very good job for this! ;)
- Blue's Gym was really cool and awesome! A great memory from HG-SS! ;) Thanks so much! ;)
- GS Ball is obtainable in your game, and so, we can get Celebi!
However, here's what I liked less in your game:
- Well, most trainers in Johto, including the Gyms and Elite Four, are the same as in the original game! However, since there are new movesets for Pokémon, it's not that of a problem! But, I would have liked some differences, even little...
- Most dialogs (like 98%) are the same as the original game. However, it's not that of a problem too, since it's still Johto and Kanto... It's alright!
- It was funny that a boy in Cerulean City talks about Cerulean Cave in the past form ("There used to be a cave...), when in reality, in your game, the cave is still present and we clearly see it! :) It's just funny and weird!
- Why would we buy TM29 (Psychic) at Celadon Game Corner when we can get it for free in Mr. Psychic's house in Saffron City? At least, there's a verification of this! (Good job for this! );) Also, the fact that TM33, TM41 and TM48 are both sold in the two big marts (Goldenrod and Celadon) is redondant. I think all TMs should be sold/obtained in one place...(it's not that of a problem, but it would make more sense.)
- The new Pokémon Center on Route 3 is nice, but if you lose a battle after exiting it, you're sent back in your home, in New Bark Toen (Johto)... I know a solution: Make a jealing house with a tilest from an house (like the one on Route 26 where you can heal your Pokémon) The reason for this is the Pokémon Center tileset (well, it's this way in a gold version game). Believe me! ;) Otherwise, it's not so "grave", coz we can always use fly via the Pager to return all the way to Pewter City, and so to Mt.Moon or Route 3.
- The fact the adventure is mostly the same as the original game, but it's not a big problem... I was expecting this, so it's alright.
Bref, I'm really proud to have played your game, and I will keep it in my games for sure, coz I want to play it again in the future! You did a very excellent job (sometimes even better than me!). I truly respect your work and your skills, and it's clear that you put a lot of work, passion and love into it! :) I felt it all the way in my adventure in your game! ;) Also, I think we have things in common in this domain, and I sincerely love what you done, and I'm sure that if we were to know each other in the real life, we could get along very well, coz it's clear that we have a passion for creating games and Pokémon! ;) However, i don't think this will happen ever, but it's alright! ;) Don't worry! ;) I just support you! ;)
If you have made some other games (Gen 1 or Gen 2 with same original Pokémon and original moves (but moves can be updated up to Gens later, like 3 to 8)), I will be very interested to try them! ;)
I sincerely wish you the best success and luck in your fututre projects, if you have some others! ;)
Last edited:
