Santa's Murdershop 2018 [THERE WILL BE AN END POST AT SOME POINT I SWEAR]

Anyways, has anyone been visited by the Penguins? Considering someone died last night, it stands to reason that they didnt visit each other last night.

Also @doof, unless the Gingerbread man gives you bread, or we kill the Turkey, then yes, Hence, why we're in a bit of a time crunch.

I also find it interesting that GP is townleaning Ash, considering she's only given like one statement. Not accusatory at them per se, but just strange, since I just find it to be a general statement at best.
 
Bidoof FTW said:
oh my bad, I had thought Chura's post about the elf causing famine was correct
Click to expand...
sorry haha i assumed the elf-baker was a thing since "all elves get their own unique little thing"; didn't read about the turkey wh o o ops
didn't read about the gingersmith too im doing great am i

assuming we dont get any turkey at the end of this + gingersmith is inactive/killed we'll all only last until d4 or something yea
 
To clarify:

>Killing the turkey does not end the famine (but depending on how the Turkey is killed, as the role text details, everyone will get a slice of turkey (aka an extra piece of bread) and this would occur for each turkey if more than one exists)

>According to EM Baker rules, it takes three days without any bread at all for a player to die of starvation


Also @sparkin sorry for ruining the perfect page two/day one start but I was busy apologizing for being late oops
 
I was worried I missed a lot, but I didn't. I have to be honest and say that I'm don't have a clue about all the roles you guys are talking about so I can't contribute anything meaningful ,or anything in general, (as per usual) but the players are contributing well are Kitty, gimmiepie and Slazorrah. I'll wait to see how other players play since that's something I can actually talk about. If I had to choose to keep an eye on Rabinov and Metroid who have had the weakest posts thus far, although that was at the beginning of the phase.
 
Salzorrah said:
I also find it interesting that GP is townleaning Ash, considering she's only given like one statement. Not accusatory at them per se, but just strange, since I just find it to be a general statement at best.
Click to expand...

Lean =/= read

Neon Sword said:
If I had to choose to keep an eye on Rabinov and Metroid who have had the weakest posts thus far, although that was at the beginning of the phase.
Click to expand...

You should re-read the OP
 
Neon Sword said:
If I had to choose to keep an eye on Rabinov and Metroid who have had the weakest posts thus far, although that was at the beginning of the phase.
Click to expand...
Normally I'd town lean at such a mistake as wanting to keeping an eye on a dead man, but Rabi's role doesn't meet up with the mafia so this could go either way.

Also since N0 doesn't eat bread and we have 3 pieces, we have until Day 7 I think? Plenty of time to get that bread. It would be optimal to have turkey lynched around day 5/6.
 
That's assuming the game lasts for that long, and the Turkey hasnt been killed off by then, yes.

Anyways, I'm currently town reading GP, despite the strange lean that I thought (no biggie), also getting some town vibes from Chura, while the others so far have been null, which is pretty bad tbh. Imma start pressuring some peeps to talk. Maybe we could get something out of this.

[##vote] Abby
 
Last edited:
Just gonna do the ol' random vote.

[##Vote] Kitty
 
It looks like Neon Sword made a post without reading a single part of the thread so I'm going to throw my vote his way

[##Vote] Neon Sword
 
Omgrandomus for now
Flight l8r

##vote evilchameleon

Also pls turkey(s) just in case of shenanigans
Best case tho is just one
 
There is too much to discuss that I feel like following random lynches is equivalent to attempting to erase the discussion.

I would assume Sparkin and metroid come from the same source, since their posts are similar, so both didn't read the phase post carefully.

Bidoof's first post is enough to warrant he's neither the Gingerbread Man nor the Turkey. Knowing he's not the Turkey (basing this the fact that his reaction to famine starting was genuine). I'm speculating that his genuinity is due to him being mafia that changed the kill from someone else and created famine.

Also, it seems the other posters forget that Gingerbread Man can opt to give bread to town and then create a situation where only town are against the Turkey, which can be a backup option if lynching mafia doesn't work for the next days.

(Lowkey hoping mafia kills Turkey)
 
Neon Sword said:
I was worried I missed a lot, but I didn't. I have to be honest and say that I'm don't have a clue about all the roles you guys are talking about so I can't contribute anything meaningful ,or anything in general, (as per usual) but the players are contributing well are Kitty, gimmiepie and Slazorrah. I'll wait to see how other players play since that's something I can actually talk about. If I had to choose to keep an eye on Rabinov and Metroid who have had the weakest posts thus far, although that was at the beginning of the phase.
Click to expand...

Ah geez where to start with this. There weren't as many accusations during this as there were leans. But the main one I'm getting a bad feeling from is Neon. Mainly due to the fact that he said hes saying he can't contribute anything of use. There is always a way to be helpful. But the fact that irks me is that he just immediately points fingers. Based off a couple messages. Then after pointing fingers he second thinks himself in the same post...yeah I'm just gonna vote for him. I just get bad vibes.
##vote Neon Sword
 
metroid711 said:
Ah geez where to start with this. There weren't as many accusations during this as there were leans. But the main one I'm getting a bad feeling from is Neon. Mainly due to the fact that he said hes saying he can't contribute anything of use. There is always a way to be helpful. But the fact that irks me is that he just immediately points fingers. Based off a couple messages. Then after pointing fingers he second thinks himself in the same post...yeah I'm just gonna vote for him. I just get bad vibes.
##vote Neon Sword
Click to expand...

His post didn't read scummy to me at all. He's not very confident but he gave his thoughts on some of the participants and didn't say anything that was particularly incriminatory to himself. Honestly it looks more like you're going after an easy lynch than anything there.
 
gimmepie said:
His post didn't read scummy to me at all. He's not very confident but he gave his thoughts on some of the participants and didn't say anything that was particularly incriminatory to himself. Honestly it looks more like you're going after an easy lynch than anything there.
Click to expand...

Its less of an easy lynch and more of a gut feeling for me. I'm just going off how I feel about how he worded it. Everyone else didn't feel like they gave enough of a lean for me. Being day 1 it's difficult to work off of info so I'm working with what I can get.
 
All I've got so far is a light town lean on GP and kind of a gut-lean on Pecilia

Aldo said:
There is too much to discuss that I feel like following random lynches is equivalent to attempting to erase the discussion.

I would assume Sparkin and metroid come from the same source, since their posts are similar, so both didn't read the phase post carefully.

Bidoof's first post is enough to warrant he's neither the Gingerbread Man nor the Turkey. Knowing he's not the Turkey (basing this the fact that his reaction to famine starting was genuine). I'm speculating that his genuinity is due to him being mafia that changed the kill from someone else and created famine.

Also, it seems the other posters forget that Gingerbread Man can opt to give bread to town and then create a situation where only town are against the Turkey, which can be a backup option if lynching mafia doesn't work for the next days.

(Lowkey hoping mafia kills Turkey)
Click to expand...
Sparkin's post was about a page top and all metroid said was the night could have gone worse, so I'm not sure what you're trying to say there, or whether or not you think they're suspicious. Also not sure where you're coming from about Doof because famine starting had nothing do with who died, famine was going to start at the beginning regardless just due to the turkey being in the game. Even though your reasoning doesn't make sense I'm also going to ask why you aren't voting Doof if you think he's mafia?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top