• Ever thought it'd be cool to have your art, writing, or challenge runs featured on PokéCommunity? Click here for info - we'd love to spotlight your work!
  • It's time to vote for your favorite Pokémon Battle Revolution protagonist in our new weekly protagonist poll! Click here to cast your vote and let us know which PBR protagonist you like most.
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

4th Gen So, HeartGold, SoulSilver… whatcha getting?

Heart Gold, or Soul Silver?

  • Total voters
    1,314
I originally got Gold, so Heart Gold for me.

IF I'm unable to get both. XD
 
BeachBoy said:
I originally got Gold, so Heart Gold for me.

IF I'm unable to get both. XD
Click to expand...


Same here, except I know I'm not getting Silver. My brother never got a chance to play the Johto Games, so I'm gonna let him get Silver. Gold takes up most of my childhood memories anyway.
 
SoulSilver FTW.
I'm so excited that Nintendo's Pokemon department is starting to fulfill our needs.
TT_TT
What about crystal? MindCrystal? IntestineCrystal? (Lawl)
But really, I'll probably buy the Silver remake, AND the Crystal remake. (If there is one)
 
Heart Gold all the way. I always bought the "Red" versions of the Pokemon games, and I feel Gold more to the "Red" side than Silver.
 
Gold was my very first game (not just pokémon-I mean like ever), though I may get Soul Silver this time around (Lugia is one of my favourite pokémon). May get both games, re-complete the dex in HeartGold since 1)I'm still missing, like, 5 in my regular Gold XD and 2) Its become a tradition :).
 
I am really happy right now. Today is a good day. :3

I will definitely more than likely get both eventually, but I'll probably get Soul Silver first since I got Silver first on the Game Boy.

If these games aren't ten times better than Platinum, I will be a very sad little boy.
 
NytewolfAU2k7 said:
I voted neither, because I think I'll wait till more information is actually known about them, no point getting all excited then finding out only the graphics are different ;)
Click to expand...
Even if only the graphics are different, Gold/Silver are great games.

I'd get SoulSilver. Based on how expensive D/P was, I'd only be able to get one, and I prefer Lugia over Ho-oh. Man, I can't wait for them to come out! It'll be way easier to get Lugia/Ho-oh in G4. Seriously, before you needed GC, GBA, Coloseum/XD, GC-GBA Link Cable, and a GBA Pokemon game. Now all you'll need is SoulSilver/HeartGold. (P.S. I wonder when they'll start to be abbreviated, you know like FR/LG, HG/SS.)
 
Silver was probably the best Pokemon game so far and it was my second Pokemon game I have ever gotten.

I still miss my poor Chikorita. XD
 
prolly gonna get silver cuz its one of my favorites. Hopefully you will be able to catch both main legendaries and the legendary dogs wont be hard to find.
 
I'm getting Soul Silver, because

1. I preferred Silver to Gold anyway, because of the sprites, pokemon, etc..
2. Silver was the first one that I got
3. I <3 Lugia =))
 
Both ftw. I always loved Silver. Silver is just.. so. Silver.
Gold is so overrated. In terms of mascots, Silver.
Colour, Silver. Pokemon, Silver. First game, Silver.
Silver silver silver! My preferred trainer name is also,
well whaddya know! SILVER! (and my rival is gold).

But I'm getting both so I can:

1) Have two files to play between
so I can't really get bored of my team

2) Fill up my Dex faster, if I win that
Eggo contest for another DS T_T'

3) I wanna get the legendaries x2.

4) Silver will be my main, Gold will be
for Wi-Fi. EVs, Eggs, all that pointless
stuff.

5) My two fave starters: Chikorita and Totodile..
or was it Cyndaquil and Chikorita? Or Totodile and
Cyndaquil!?!?!?!

6) For plenty of other reasons I can't think of.
Oh, this is also my first time to get both versions
and play them simultaneously!



Also, I think the translated names will be different.
Heart Gold, no one will really understand. Soul Silver as well.
The Ho-Oh wings are shaped as a heart, so it might be restrained,
and people won't know why the hell Lugia looks like a dinosaur.
I still don't, either.. It should be Sunshine Gold and Moonlight Silver
or something. Makes sense, too, so I wouldn't be basing your
choices off the name..
​
 
I have already decided on getting Soul Silver. Why? Well....

  1. The name, in my opinion, is better.
  2. I do it for the sake of Lugia.
  3. I prefer Silver more than Gold.
  4. I made a coin toss to see which one I'm getting.
 
My answer is the same as it always has been:

I will have both games reserved and 100% paid for as soon as the option is available.
 
Soul Silver (or whatever it ends up being =3) because I never had the original Silver. I had Crystal and Gold, so... Silver it is. Plus: Lugia > Ho-oh
 
;_; Why is nobody getting Crystal?
Crystal was definitely my favourite, and the first ever handheld and Pokemon game I got. I think they will make a Crystal Remake cos the three legendary dogs/cats were very much win. Meh, just staying hopeful.

-Ace_McPhail

Ps- I think it''ll be called "Mind Crystal". Heart, Soul, Mind. See what I did there?
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top