The Darkest Dungeon

So gp, are you that role where Klippy says "Here are your really dumb stats 'Cause some Hell' " ?

Also, we need to decide whether we trust gp's allegiance. Do we think an inno would have these kinds of monster stats? Maybe he's some kind of "3rd party" meant to mess with us. On one hand, if he is a hero -> he'd be a huge help in wrecking bad guy face (as well as hurting us if he mishits). On the other, he's such a huge threat to us if he is a bad guy or 3rd party.

Now that I write it all out, I realize -> we should leave him alone. Regardless of his alignment, the other terrors will likely target him because none of them will know his alliance except that he's not with them. If what I can tell from the role list, there are mafia teams consisting of 3-sh players? So maybe they each have their own skype chat.

I don't know... this is ridiculous.
 
For now, I see little reason that we should target GP. If someone is worried about their own safety, that's one thing, but as it stands GP can either clear out the roster (if he is truly powerful) or remain a mostly non-threat (if he isn't). The truth will be easier to grasp more quickly with the former, and there aren't many setbacks to the latter.

I can't really see many advantages to taking him out now save for solely personal ones or closure, but he seems far more useful to us as a whole rather than a threat. For now, at least.
 
Errrr o_o nono. If Gimme had warned us before, we could have all voted before him. Now someone has been killed before most have even voted! This is not good, are you guys playing the same game here?

[kill] [attack] gimmepie

High attack stats are dangerous, I'd rather take my chances and work on eliminating you now rather than trusting the evils to do it, when you could be one of them.

Tbh even if you're a hero, a power like that is going to get more of our team killed. ;-;
 
Mana said:
Errrr o_o nono. If Gimme had warned us before, we could have all voted before him. Now someone has been killed before most have even voted! This is not good, are you guys playing the same game here?

[kill] gimmepie

High attack stats are dangerous, I'd rather take my chances and work on eliminating you now rather than trusting the evils to do it, when you could be one of them.

Tbh even if you're a hero, a power like that is going to get more of our team killed. ;-;
Click to expand...

Probably, but it also means I can wipe out dangerous threats to you guys with ease whilst you guys would all likely struggle. Personally I wouldn't be setting out to incur my wrath when I haven't decided who I want to win with yet. :)
 
gimmepie said:
Probably, but it also means I can wipe out dangerous threats to you guys with ease whilst you guys would all likely struggle. Personally I wouldn't be setting out to incur my wrath when I haven't decided who I want to win with yet. :)
Click to expand...

Comments like that just further suggest you're not a hero ;-;''.

And if you don't actually know who to aim for, you're a liability. Sorry. :(
 
Mana said:
Comments like that just further suggest you're not a hero ;-;''.

And if you don't actually know who to aim for, you're a liability. Sorry. :(
Click to expand...

I'm not a hero, I'm a third party role that wins with the survivors.
However, I'm perfectly happy to work alongside the heroes. I'm terrible at playing as a mafia so it's just a lot easier for me to open and work with you than try to be covert and against you.

The only reason I went for such a sudden and brash kill was because it's day one and there's no chance of us learning anything more valuable anyway and to retaliate against someone for attacking me for no good reason. -_-

You guys can ask me anything about my role and I'll answer if I can. I'm not allowed to share too much though apparently.
 
If gimmiepie has a large attack stat we need him to have health to survive the night phase, so we need to keep him at a high hp
[attack] mana
 
Oh goody. Protecting an admitted third party to attack a hero? You honestly believe that he's going to lead the heroes to victory?

For all we know he's already killed a friendly power role in Foxrally.
 
I think I will trust gimmiepie, but if he gives me just one reason not to I will attack him

At the same time, remember, if he didn't attack he would have lost half his hp, which no one wants. So I don't blame him for killing one of us too much.

So feel free to attack me back, to level the field if you want. I for one will not hold anything, and i don't want an all out war killing us both
 
gimmepie said:
Whatever role he is, I guarantee you want me on your side more.
Click to expand...

That's p hard to say when the roles are completely unknown :x.

Didn't the inno's trust Candy in F&L?... Look how that ended. Third parties are not innocents. They act in their own interest and this if you're day voting again it will just lead to more random, unnecessary death.
 
Mana said:
That's p hard to say when the roles are completely unknown :x.

Didn't the inno's trust Candy in F&L?... Look how that ended. Third parties are not innocents. They act in their own interest and this if you're day voting again it will just lead to more random, unnecessary death.
Click to expand...

It's really not that hard to say at all if you've had the pleasure of reading my role PM. In saying that though, at the end of the phase a bit about my role is meant to be revealed.

Anyway, you're correct that as a third party role I'm not officially an innocent. But so long as I don't die I win regardless who is left at the end and there's always a lot more innocents than mafias. I'm taking my chances siding with you because it's going to be much harder for them to kill me than you guys.

My health is pretty ridiculous and even if every person attacks me today it will probably take several nights to kill me, but I'm not immortal. I'm playing a math game right now, so before I'm dead you might as well use me to your advantage.
 
Bacteriophage said:
It makes more sense to kill you now than to let you live and hope you don't decide to join up with the baddies later in the game.

Also, assuming you're not bluffing about your health and you do survive the day, the baddies will probably label you a top priority (especially if Foxrally was one of them) and you'll be dead by morning.
Click to expand...

It makes no sense at all. Even with a chance of me turning against you later, you're far better off using me to take out any big threats incase they're able to survive and cause more damage before dying. If you want me out of the way that's on you, but you should use your brain and use the enormous ATK stat currently leaning towards the inno side to your advantage.

I'm not bluffing, I don't have any special abilities just crazy high stats. I'm not likely to die for at least another few days assuming everyone constantly attacks me. By that point the baddies will have unleashed all kinds of hell upon you whilst you've been busy focusing on me. You'd basically be handing them the game.

If I was a mafia player right now, I wouldn't want me dead. I'd want to convince me to side with them. I wish them luck regardless what they try to do.
 
I mean if you can survive so long, tell us everything about your role, you shouldn't have to fear the Mafia knowing exactly how strong you are
 
gimmepie said:
If I was a mafia player right now, I wouldn't want me dead. I'd want to convince me to side with them. I wish them luck regardless what they try to do.
Click to expand...

That's exactly the point... you're not our ally, you could be anyones. It's all well and good saying you'll side with innocents but you could change your mind any moment.

And if you have 'crazy health' then you're the right person to attack anyway, since you won't die. So people should be attacking you whether you're useful or not, at least for today, just because you're the one role that can take it apparently.
 
These attacks are coming in pretty quick for one person. Since the attacks are supposedly done in real time and currently The Ancestor is out, you guys might be attacking a corpse.

Wanting to get Gimme out is one thing, but mind your pacing. Lest you waste an Attack action.

EDIT: With that in mind, we don't know if he has crazy health because there's yet to be an announcement. I mean, only real way to say is to infer that you have a pretty high attack stat yourself, Mana, but I'll chalk that up to pure assumption on your part.
 
Mana said:
That's exactly the point... you're not our ally, you could be anyones. It's all well and good saying you'll side with innocents but you could change your mind any moment.

And if you have 'crazy health' then you're the right person to attack anyway, since you won't die. So people should be attacking you whether you're useful or not, at least for today, just because you're the one role that can take it apparently.
Click to expand...

I'm honestly half a mind to think you're a mafia who doesn't want me as a potential enemy with how hard you're trying to get me, who is arguably the most powerful ally the innocents can have, killed. Yes, I could turn on you. I don't plan on doing that though when there's a hell of a lot more innocents to worry about than mafia.

I have crazy health, not unlimited health. With every bit of damage you guys deal to me I become that little bit less reliable.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top