*~The Harry Potter Fanclub~*

well, i still think she's done
 
wolfie1177 said:
And Flavaquil, agreed, I think everytihng is still a bit too vague. That's why I think that there will absolutely be another book down the road, and not just some encyclopedia, like a whole 'nother book.
Click to expand...
Yeah, IMO she could have well done without the whole epilogue... it kinda ruined it in some ways...

Another book would fit in nicely... filling in a few gaps in places.
wolfie1177 said:
Spoiler:
Click to expand...

Sounds good. I don't know about the second one though.... xD It is meant to be Harry's story...
 
yeah, still dont think she's gonna write another book, but i agree with you flava, the epilogue did kinda ruin it, well, not totally, but it kept us on edge, like she did on the 4th 5th and especially the 6th book
 
0.o The epilogue didn't keep anyone on edge. At least not to my knowledge. It was downright predictable.

And it did kinda ruin it for me. I would have been much happier with there being more of an opening for another book.
 
well, i didn't explain taht as well as i would of liked, i meant it left a whole bunch of open spaces in the story
 
Chibaymega12 said:
yeah, still dont think she's gonna write another book, but i agree with you flava, the epilogue did kinda ruin it, well, not totally, but it kept us on edge, like she did on the 4th 5th and especially the 6th book
Click to expand...

Nah.. I don't think the epilogue was necessary.... it kinda didn't leave us thinking for ourselves.
 
yeah, i think it would've been better for J.K. to leave out the epilouge and let us wander for our selves
 
Hehe... then my ending would have been much different.

Anyone else reading it a second time?
 
- Flavaquil - said:
Hehe... then my ending would have been much different.

Anyone else reading it a second time?
Click to expand...
Okay and which Harry Potter book are you talking about, Alex?

~Rene~ :t025:
 
The 7th and newest book of course!

I just finished it a second time today. O.o Yay.
 
- Flavaquil - said:
The 7th and newest book of course!

I just finished it a second time today. O.o Yay.
Click to expand...
I see and I don't have the new book at home. I only have this Harry Potter book: Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone.

~Rene~ :t025:
 
I found a .pdf version of the 7th book like last week... suprisingly someone took the time to type up all 610ish pages...

Reading the proper thing is soooo much more comfortable though.
 
yeah, it's just me, but i don't ABSOLUTELY trust that, i'm sure most of it is from the book, but you never know, he could have edited some parts to kill someone he didn't like off, or make totally new characters, so i'm with flava, I'd be much more comfortable reading the actual book
 
Chibaymega12 said:
yeah, it's just me, but i don't ABSOLUTELY trust that, i'm sure most of it is from the book, but you never know, he could have edited some parts to kill someone he didn't like off, or make totally new characters, so i'm with flava, I'd be much more comfortable reading the actual book
Click to expand...

Heck... I read it through. It is exactly the same... just the odd few spelling errors here and there. I've read it once on that and once properly with the book. Book's a much better read for sitting down for a long period of time.
 
My next task is to read the whole series again. I think that'll be something to get my mind sharp before the school year starts.
 
Chibaymega12 said:
ah, well i was just saying taht he could have
Click to expand...

Very true, but I think that might be too much effort, even for someone who typed the whole book out, don't you think?
 
Back... for about a day. Anyway, I see some nice discussion is still happening. Everyone, though, please try to keep your spelling and grammar up to date. XD

I personally think another book would be nice, just to finish everything and not leave us with questions.

And, I think I read that interview that you all were talking about. If it is the same, then it was talking about Teddy kissing Victoire, who was Bill And Fleur's eldest, not Teddy.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top