A Song of Ice and Fire [EPILOGUE]

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think we're essentially killing a wounded animal here. I'd rather have a known enemy that's crippled than allowing Jaime to peck off whomever he likes.​
 
Kiyoshi the Polar Bear said:
I think we're essentially killing a wounded animal here. I'd rather have a known enemy that's crippled than allowing Jaime to peck off whomever he likes.​
Click to expand...

It just doesn't make sense ;-;. Lynching randomly could be swayed by a house (they could have sent a letter on Night 0) so the only way to have any control over who dies now is to kill Joffrey.

Add to the mix that even if we DON'T kill Joffrey one of the houses could use their NA to take him out, and then we're in the same position, but with less targets for Jaime to pick from.

Lets add more cause to this - there's a (very very very) slim chance that there will be a hint about Jaime's identity if he is forced to use his power. Aaaaaand the amazing chance he might accidentally kill one of his own or the/a white walker it might be slim but it could get interesting!

Hell, someone could just block Jaime in the night phase and make sure he's sitting still for the whole night, if we have any leftover powers like that.
 
I second bard. Jaime would be better making an uninformed decision.
 
I find myself agreeing with Mana again here - there are some roleblocking abilities. Now, we don't know who Jaime is - but if someone is able to block him then he can't kill at all (since he has to kill on the night following Joffrey's death). But that's a shot in the dark if I've ever seen one.

I'm still feeling unsure as to where to proceed. But killing Lycan feels like the most sure possibility over anything else right now. :/

edit: And thanks No for the reply. That makes sense... so was Naku just a normal peasant then or unaffiliated secret role because of the colour name? At least we got rid of a weird role before we had to suffer the consequences of Naku being alive and selling swords. ;)
 
On second thought, yeah it may be better. Who knows.

Still I find it funny how you all are relying on luck and are super afraid to random vote even tho random voting also completely relies on luck xD
 
Ehhh I can't do this. I don't know how killing Lycanthropy is right. It doesn't matter if jamie's kill is uninformed, it's just better not to. It's better if we wait till he is finally killed to kill Lycan.

[kill] Cosmic

I still think it's suspicious how he viewed this thread 6948772058 times but didn't post. I don't think I will change my vote but I can be easily persuaded.
 
So, I'm to lazy to read back 5 pages. I'm just going to vote for me until someone explains to me why I shouldn't.

[Execute] Ice
 
Arx said:
Anyone ever wondered why Lycan would reveal his role this early? A sane person wouldn't really do that.
Click to expand...

Maybe he didn't expect to be met with such a backlash? It's not like Tywin has any extensive info with a target in mind for Jaime to kill. Besides, why would you sacrifice one of your named players for one kill? That seems that unstrategic.​
 
^ Pretty much what Bard said. They probably were planning their moves by letters, and Tywin thought it was a good idea killing Nakuzami.

BUT they ended up killing a peasant...how unlucky lol. Tantrum wasnt a horrible ability, it should have been used more carefully.
 
Even a peasant can win the game of thrones. And Naku is a veteran player, no need to underestimate him, even as a peasant.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top